Live data from Hacker News

I swapped my iPhone for an Apple Watch to live in an audio-first future

franzschrepf.medium.com

51–60 of 87 posts

Re: I swapped my iPhone for an Apple Watch to live in an audio-first future

#51
Is there a non-wristband "mount" for an Apple Watch ?

Which is to say, if I wanted to carry an apple watch in my pocket, and didn't want the sort of lame, and unifinished, aesthetic of bare/empty band connectors ... is there some pendant or medallion or ... something ... that you can attach the watch to that isn't a wristband ?

OH, AND ALSO ...

The op speaks of the necessary iphone that he leaves in his drawer, at home, like a router ... now that we have apple silicon, etc., can I run my "iphone" on a mac mini, in an emulator ? I mean, if you were developing apps, etc., for Apple Watches, or doing Q&A, you wouldn't have 50 iphones somewhere, right ? RIGHT ?

Re: I swapped my iPhone for an Apple Watch to live in an audio-first future

#52
When everybody started to have mobile phones around me, I shelled out for a PDA (remember those?) instead and wanted to wait for those headsets to actually not need any phone anymore. I hoped the advent of the smartwatch would get us there, but alas. I have a smartphone now, because what else can you do, but I can't wait for the time that I can just voicedail or at least have my watch be the personal computing device. Carrying around a watch is so much beter than carrying around a phone, but Google makes me carry both! Plus headset/in ears!

Re: I swapped my iPhone for an Apple Watch to live in an audio-first future

#53
> The future will be audio-first. We’ll trade our tiny screens for always-in Airpods [...]

No.

It comes with a lot of drawbacks:

- Speed. A lot of people can read a lot faster than your usual conversation speed (and in their own pace), while audio is at a rather constant speed, which you might not even be able to control. Additionally, you can easily re-read something when you missed it or did not understand it - doing so with audio is not that easy.

- Privacy. When you're using a voice assistant, you're broadcasting your inputs to your surroundings and maybe even the output. Yes, people can already look on your screen, but the field is limited and the behaviour is discouraged. You're basically becoming that annoying person on the phone overheard by everyone, all the time.

- Scalability. Somewhat related, but a full bus with people on their phone is not a problem (in non-pandemic circumstances). Now, imagine 40 people talking to their phone in that bus.

- Clarity: Human-to-human understanding is quite imperfect already, especially in noisy environments or with distance. Text does not have any problems with this [0].

- Information density. "A picture can say more than a thousand words". Try reading a scientific paper with graphics via audio only, it'll be fun.

That's not to say that voice is useless. When you're driving or your hands are full while you're in your home, it is ideal. It also opens up accessibility to people which might not handle screens that well (for example very old persons).

But given these limitations, I can not imagine voice replacing screens as the main input method any time soon, or at all. For the edge cases above, sure. But in the general case? No.

[0] There are still understanding problems with text, but voice has those, too.

Re: I swapped my iPhone for an Apple Watch to live in an audio-first future

#54

Voice control has recently improved to Barely Useful, but still certainly Not Usable. I now listen to audiobooks, podcasts for ~2 hours daily, while walking my dog. If there's a way to control apps, navigate options, perform useful dictation, I haven't found it. I can barely get Siri to reliably start and stop audio playback. I'm now curious how blind people manage these things. Also, I dimly recall Marvin Minsky or…

> If there's a way to control apps, navigate options, perform useful dictation, I haven't found it. I can barely get Siri to reliably start and stop audio playback. google assistant is getting close https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GILvyiWB7xY

Ok. Google Assistant is available for iPhone. I'll try it. Thank you.

Continuing my rant...

I know that Siri is impaired by choices Apple's made wrt to privacy or some such.

But why does local voice recognition fail so often? Like while hiking or I'm in the basement. Surely some hybrid is possible. Does Siri really need network access to process a stop playback command? (I do fuss with the Voice Control features every few months, to see if things have improved.)

Warning, idea incoming:

I want the ¡Tchkung! voice interface. Pops, clicks, buzzes, Looney Tunes sounds effects. Why are we limited to just speech recognition? Why can't I beatbox to control my phone?

In the 80s, there was a comic who'd straight read serious writing, adding sound effects for the punctuation. Hysterical (at the time). Sorry, can't remember name. But I want to make sounds for punctuation, backspace, back one word, newline, etc.

Re: I swapped my iPhone for an Apple Watch to live in an audio-first future

#55
post #52

When everybody started to have mobile phones around me, I shelled out for a PDA (remember those?) instead and wanted to wait for those headsets to actually not need any phone anymore. I hoped the advent of the smartwatch would get us there, but alas. I have a smartphone now, because what else can you do, but I can't wait for the time that I can just voicedail or at least have my watch be the personal computing device…

This wasn't mentioned in the article, but the newer cellular variants of the watch allow you to place and receive calls even without your phone nearby. You can also stream music, stream podcasts, etc. without the phone nearby, listening with a bluetooth headset. I suspect certain android ones do as well, though I don't know which ones.

I like the idea of only carrying around a watch + headset. I'm actually thinking of doing this next month.

Re: I swapped my iPhone for an Apple Watch to live in an audio-first future

#56

When will we get a watch that can be fully de-coupled from your phone? I’d love to make that trade right now.

There would need to be an incredible breakthrough in battery technology. Cellular radios just take up too much power for it to be a reasonable experience right now, unless you want to change watches mid-day.

There's no breakthrough necessary. The batteries are already good enough to manage standby with an occasional call, which meets the _phone_ needs of most users. The Apple Watch today is at least as good as a phone today as the iPhone was a decade ago. I can't even imagine the complexities of carrier/Apple politics to know what the real reasons are for why Apple hasn't allowed the watch to be standalone, but they aren't technical.

Re: I swapped my iPhone for an Apple Watch to live in an audio-first future

#57
post #51

Is there a non-wristband "mount" for an Apple Watch ? Which is to say, if I wanted to carry an apple watch in my pocket, and didn't want the sort of lame, and unifinished, aesthetic of bare/empty band connectors ... is there some pendant or medallion or ... something ... that you can attach the watch to that isn't a wristband ? OH, AND ALSO ... The op speaks of the necessary iphone that he leaves in his drawer, at ho…

Was thinking the same, I'd love to carry my apple watch around like a fancy pocket watch on a chain! Will dig into the emulator though, great idea.

Re: I swapped my iPhone for an Apple Watch to live in an audio-first future

#58
post #51

Is there a non-wristband "mount" for an Apple Watch ? Which is to say, if I wanted to carry an apple watch in my pocket, and didn't want the sort of lame, and unifinished, aesthetic of bare/empty band connectors ... is there some pendant or medallion or ... something ... that you can attach the watch to that isn't a wristband ? OH, AND ALSO ... The op speaks of the necessary iphone that he leaves in his drawer, at ho…

Yes, in general this gizmo is called a "fob", and a search for "Apple Watch fob" will turn up as many as you would like.

Re: I swapped my iPhone for an Apple Watch to live in an audio-first future

#59

My first thought was it's a bit ironic this was a medium post (especially one with obnoxious visuals as someone else pointed out). Why not post an audio file?

And while we're at it write an app to hear the sound of the claps

And also a great web-based player for both desktop and mac for easy sharing and consumption
Post reply on HN