Live data from Hacker News

Is this plane landing or departing? (2017)

aviation.stackexchange.com

51–52 of 52 posts

Re: Is this plane landing or departing? (2017)

#51
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I mean, people collect stamps, coins, and many other things that seem completely ridiculous and useless to me, why not collect pictures of planes. Chances are most of your hobbies are as ridiculous as that for most people out of the hobby

Almost no one starts a stamp collection in this day and age. It used to be done simply because there weren't as many forms of superior entertainment as there are now.

No one starts collecting stamps nowadays because, relatively, no-one receives stamps any more. An unusual stamp used to signify receiving an interesting letter -- perhaps a parcel, or a letter from a relative living abroad.

Without that experience, why would anyone start collecting them?

People still collect similar types of useless stuff (bottle caps, beer mats, guitar picks, fountain pens, license plates).

Re: Is this plane landing or departing? (2017)

#52
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This applies even more to the moon, in my opinion. Looking at the moon, that's one thing. But taking a picture of the moon? Go to NASA or Wikipedia for a great high-res picture.

I think the key to understanding the allure is by extending your line of reasoning even further. Why play piano? There are plenty of recordings of people who play better than I ever will. Why play chess? I will never be able to beat my computer anyway. Why paint portraits? I will never be as good as Rembrandt, and my camera is infinitely better anyway. I think the point of the activity is not "I will take the best pi…

My issue with the moon, in particular, is that:

a) it's not hard, it just requires a long focal length. b) it's not a creative act. The moon drowns out anything else, so it ends up being just a picture of an orb surrounded by black.

Piano is extremely challenging, and playing something well gives you that feeling of having overcome a worthwhile challenge.

Chess is likewise a battle of self-improvement.

Same with painting.

Moon photography? There's zero creativity involved, it's just about whether you've gone out and bought that 150-600 zoom you've been eyeing.

Post reply on HN