Live data from Hacker News

A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

github.com

51–60 of 80 posts

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#51

I've wondered if the AI superintelligence everyone is watching out for is actually slowly being built from the bottom up, and encompasses evening in the entire world. Deep Thought from Hitchhiker's Guide is seeming more and more plausible to me. Perhaps this bot that makes Reddit videos doesn't do anything "useful" per se, but it is doing what a human might otherwise do, and adds itself to Reddit as an entity that co…

maybe so, but I don't think this particular program does anything like AI. glancing at the code, it looks like it just pastes the full text of a reddit comment into a video template, using a different template for each unique commenter in the thread. it no more "does what a human might otherwise do" than how a sorting algorithm might emulate how I sort my socks.

It uses a neural network for sentiment analysis, so it can be classified as "using AI".

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#52
post #4
post #2

This bot is a lot of fun! Maybe we need an HN clone? :P

That wouldn't work, the characters in ace attorney aren't that passive aggressive ;)

You do often win the game by being pedantic and pointing out small issues that didn't have anything to do with the original main testimony, so maybe parent is on to something after all :)

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#53

I've wondered if the AI superintelligence everyone is watching out for is actually slowly being built from the bottom up, and encompasses evening in the entire world. Deep Thought from Hitchhiker's Guide is seeming more and more plausible to me. Perhaps this bot that makes Reddit videos doesn't do anything "useful" per se, but it is doing what a human might otherwise do, and adds itself to Reddit as an entity that co…

You are spot on. We are so self-centered that we think an AI superintelligence will be something like a superintelligent-human-mind/person inside a computer, when most likely, it will be nothing like a human and probably completely unrecognizable to us. In fact, I'd argue it's already here and already taken over. Most of us are now enslaved by screens and the Internet, we are addicted to them, even if we don't want t…

> Can any single person turn off the internet or prevent everyone else from using their phones/screens for hours every day?

Google "ICANN"

https://deadline.com/2020/07/internet-down-outage-cloudflare...

https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/25/21719396/amazon-web-serv...

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#54
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually the original series is from Game Boy Advance, but the GBA games were never released outside of Japan. Nintendo DS ports were the first one releases in the rest of the world. BTW, I am a great fan of the series, really recommend it.

Did you know that it's actually a rather pointed parody/criticism of the Japanese justice system? I had no idea myself! Perhaps I was the only one who didn't know. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_justice_system_of_Jap... The conviction rate in Japan is over 99% -- going to "trial" is essentially the same as being found guilty. The prosecuting attorneys have a lot of discretion over what is prosecuted, and are…

I wonder if this is partly an extension of what you might call "confirmation culture", which could be described as a way of avoiding disgrace/humiliation.

For instance, when applying for a promotion, I've heard that in Japanese culture it is common to get pre-approval from various parties beforehand so that it is ensured before a formal/public application is made; this way, nobody is disgraced by being turned down. Not sure how true that is. But it could apply to the justice system in a similar way; having a high conviction rate means the justice system is effective, whereas trying someone and not convicting them might make the justice system look bad.

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#55
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That wouldn't work, the characters in ace attorney aren't that passive aggressive ;)

You do often win the game by being pedantic and pointing out small issues that didn't have anything to do with the original main testimony, so maybe parent is on to something after all :)

Objection! Don't do that here. (this is a joke btw)

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#56

I've wondered if the AI superintelligence everyone is watching out for is actually slowly being built from the bottom up, and encompasses evening in the entire world. Deep Thought from Hitchhiker's Guide is seeming more and more plausible to me. Perhaps this bot that makes Reddit videos doesn't do anything "useful" per se, but it is doing what a human might otherwise do, and adds itself to Reddit as an entity that co…

Apparently it's not running anymore, but https://www.reddit.com/r/SubredditSimulator/ is sort of apropos. It's an entirely bot-generated subreddit. You can still read through the old posts.

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#57

I've wondered if the AI superintelligence everyone is watching out for is actually slowly being built from the bottom up, and encompasses evening in the entire world. Deep Thought from Hitchhiker's Guide is seeming more and more plausible to me. Perhaps this bot that makes Reddit videos doesn't do anything "useful" per se, but it is doing what a human might otherwise do, and adds itself to Reddit as an entity that co…

> a giant brain that is continually self-improving

...nope, does not qualify. If it cannot manage to replicate itself completely (as in: create another separate 'internet' capable of further replication) it is as good as a single human living on Mars. It's a short ride, one small mistake and goodbye Mr. Superintelligence. (I'm not claiming humans will be able to survive that though.)

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#58

Actually, if there was something that turned a thread into speech, that I could listen to while doing work around the house, might be useful.

This could be done in browser via native speechSynthesis API. Maybe there's already an extension out there.

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#59
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are spot on. We are so self-centered that we think an AI superintelligence will be something like a superintelligent-human-mind/person inside a computer, when most likely, it will be nothing like a human and probably completely unrecognizable to us. In fact, I'd argue it's already here and already taken over. Most of us are now enslaved by screens and the Internet, we are addicted to them, even if we don't want t…

> Can any single person turn off the internet or prevent everyone else from using their phones/screens for hours every day? Google "ICANN" https://deadline.com/2020/07/internet-down-outage-cloudflare... https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/25/21719396/amazon-web-serv...

Google: "I CAN"

Re: A bot that converts Reddit threads into ace attorney scenes

#60
post #53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are spot on. We are so self-centered that we think an AI superintelligence will be something like a superintelligent-human-mind/person inside a computer, when most likely, it will be nothing like a human and probably completely unrecognizable to us. In fact, I'd argue it's already here and already taken over. Most of us are now enslaved by screens and the Internet, we are addicted to them, even if we don't want t…

> Can any single person turn off the internet or prevent everyone else from using their phones/screens for hours every day? Google "ICANN" https://deadline.com/2020/07/internet-down-outage-cloudflare... https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/25/21719396/amazon-web-serv...

Are you implying Google did it on purpose to prevent this super-intelligence from taking over?

To me it seems like the opposite, the outage was untintentional and then humans worked really hard to fix it. It's almost as if we were the cells of the body of this super-intelligence.

Post reply on HN