Live data from Hacker News

Chrome Web Store payments deprecation

developer.chrome.com

51–60 of 175 posts

Re: Chrome Web Store payments deprecation

#51
Are they still going to call it a "Store" when you can't buy anything on it?

I always thought it was weird that my free extensions were distributed by a store. Expect Google to launch a new service with the same functionality and then deprecate the Chrome Web Store.

Re: Chrome Web Store payments deprecation

#52

Haha, this is so ridiculous and completely on-brand for Google at this point. I've run a Google Music extension for a few years now and would have absolutely no migration path since I don't have a backend -- but it doesn't matter since they're shutting down Google Music anyway! A related fun fact: accounting data exports for extensions have been broken for me (and I think all extension merchants?) since April 2018. I…

How does one get the attorney general to write a letter like this?

Re: Chrome Web Store payments deprecation

#53
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They're already drawn in. Epic sued Google too. But Epic doesn't have a Chrome extension, and Google Play Store payments aren't similarly deprecated.

Google isn't really like Apple in the monopolistic sense. You're free to install your own app store on a Gphone. Chrome extensions are a bit different because they have to be signed with another store by Google anyway.

Technically, you can sideload Chrome extensions with Developer mode, so I don't think that's much different from Android.

Re: Chrome Web Store payments deprecation

#54
post #48

The interesting thing here is that a commercial marketplace for browser extensions failed. That seems surprising - surely a marketplace for extensions to the most popular browser on the planet could bring in some revenue?! Is it just that nobody paid for things? Presumably they're going to keep running the chrome web store, so isn't a cut of paymens "free money" to them? Is there some big cost to this I'm not seeing,…

I dunno ... Google shuts things down independent of revenue metrics as far as I can tell. They seem to set a bar somewhere around "is this the next Gmail" and if the answer is no they shut it down regardless of how profitable it may be. They want a few giant businesses, not a hundred small ones. I wish they would look at spinning these things out because many of them would make entirely viable independent entities ev…

.. "will this get me promoted or should I work on something new?"

Re: Chrome Web Store payments deprecation

#55
post #22

Confirming over and over: https://medium.com/@steve.yegge/dear-google-cloud-your-depre...

OK, trying my hardest to view this deprecation in a positive light: The 5% commission was already minimal but by removing payments altogether, Google proves it has no interest in monetizing Chrome extensions as a platform.

Re: Chrome Web Store payments deprecation

#56
post #42

Yep. I remember paying for the license to publish a joke extension I've made for chrome. Now I won't be able to make my money back, haha. https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/crosstext/gnlobfhf...

fun fact: this won't work on facebook anymore. I made this so I can write bad jokes on my Facebook, after the third one, facebook wrote a script that undo what my script does. So I wrote a patch to disable facebook script first. The Facebook wrote another script that undo what my script does, again. Then I just gave up. I was a super poor student back then, no point in engaging in such nonsense.

I probably have the video showing this back and forth between me and facebook, if probably posted on my now deactivated facebook

Re: Chrome Web Store payments deprecation

#57

The interesting thing here is that a commercial marketplace for browser extensions failed. That seems surprising - surely a marketplace for extensions to the most popular browser on the planet could bring in some revenue?! Is it just that nobody paid for things? Presumably they're going to keep running the chrome web store, so isn't a cut of paymens "free money" to them? Is there some big cost to this I'm not seeing,…

I use Chrome since day 1 and today I learned you can buy extensions, that should give you some perspective.

Re: Chrome Web Store payments deprecation

#59
post #52

Haha, this is so ridiculous and completely on-brand for Google at this point. I've run a Google Music extension for a few years now and would have absolutely no migration path since I don't have a backend -- but it doesn't matter since they're shutting down Google Music anyway! A related fun fact: accounting data exports for extensions have been broken for me (and I think all extension merchants?) since April 2018. I…

How does one get the attorney general to write a letter like this?

On a recommendation from a friend I filed a complaint online at https://ag.ny.gov/internet/online-forms. I wrote up the situation and attached a pdf copy of the support interaction I'd had with Google.

It wasn't quick, but it did seem to work. Here's the timeline:

- May 2018: I contact Google about being unable to export my accounting data from last month

- November 2018: after nothing but "thank you for your patience" emails, I complain to the AG

- early February 2019: I get a letter in the mail from the AG saying they'd forwarded the complaint to Google

- late February 2019: Google finally gives me my data [edit: I'd had April originally, but that was a separate request].

Re: Chrome Web Store payments deprecation

#60
post #19

I love that this "deprecation timeline" includes March 27 where this forgotten about payment API randomly broke.

The cynic in me thinks that might have been them doing a "Scream test" - break something, see if anyone notices (enough), if not, continue with getting rid of it. If it causes a stir, pretend it was just a once off issue.
Post reply on HN