Live data from Hacker News

Microsoft confirms IE10 won't run on Vista, millions of IE9 users shrug

engadget.com

51–53 of 53 posts

Re: Microsoft confirms IE10 won't run on Vista, millions of IE9 users shrug

#51
post #2

IE9 not supporting XP at least had some sort of justification, regardless of whether it was a good decision. Vista was a large platform upgrade/rewrite, and they mentioned particular features IE9 was using that they didn't want to bother re-implementing for XP (graphics stack, security). But Win7 is not such a drastic upgrade over Vista (architecturally, anyways). So what's the explanation for this?

The explanation is probably, "We want to sell licenses for the latest version of Windows". Microsoft played the lock-in game too well and they can't even get their customers to upgrade to new versions of the same software. Since Windows is a one-time purchase, if no one is buying the new versions of Windows, Microsoft is making much money off of these new versions.

Is it just me, or can nobody else see this working in practice?

Upgrading to Windows 7 to get IE 10 seems like a classic "You're doing it wrong"!

Re: Microsoft confirms IE10 won't run on Vista, millions of IE9 users shrug

#52
post #2

IE9 not supporting XP at least had some sort of justification, regardless of whether it was a good decision. Vista was a large platform upgrade/rewrite, and they mentioned particular features IE9 was using that they didn't want to bother re-implementing for XP (graphics stack, security). But Win7 is not such a drastic upgrade over Vista (architecturally, anyways). So what's the explanation for this?

What's the justification for Safari 5 not supporting Tiger? Safari 5 came out 62 months after Tiger. If we assume that IE10 comes out in 12 months from today then IE10 will come out 65 months after Vista.

Apple does have one advantage: the vast majority of OSX users upgrade. While tons of people (most, even) are still using XP and Vista over 7.

Re: Microsoft confirms IE10 won't run on Vista, millions of IE9 users shrug

#53
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The explanation is probably, "We want to sell licenses for the latest version of Windows". Microsoft played the lock-in game too well and they can't even get their customers to upgrade to new versions of the same software. Since Windows is a one-time purchase, if no one is buying the new versions of Windows, Microsoft is making much money off of these new versions.

Is it just me, or can nobody else see this working in practice? Upgrading to Windows 7 to get IE 10 seems like a classic "You're doing it wrong"!

By itself, yes. But if there are 5 other MS products where the latest version is not supported on Vista, they start to add up.

It could be 3 successive IE releases, for example...

Post reply on HN