Live data from Hacker News

Who invented the lightbulb?

theness.com

51–57 of 57 posts

Re: Who invented the lightbulb?

#51
I gave a talk once at the then brand new science museum at La Vilette in Paris. A slightly chauvinistic pal from England came along and as we walked to the lecture hall he observed, sneeringly, “this is where the French pretend to have invented everything”.

I thought he was being ironic but it turned out he really assumed pretty much everything in the last 500 years or so had been invented in England.

I assume the equivalent belief is probably pretty widespread.

Re: Who invented the lightbulb?

#54
post #9

If questions like this become political within a US-specific persepctive, they can have an element of nationalism when considered with a more global perspective. Many people in the UK know the story of UK-based Joseph Swan developing his own bulb, patenting it, setting up a company and selling it, supplying homes and businesses such as The Savoy, and then a US marketer called Edison later coming along and taking cred…

> Not trying to take any particular sides, just trying to make a point that your country of origin can have an impact on what you learn (and perhaps also that this article is a little US-focussed).

That not only applies to location ( nations ) but also time. An example being copernicus. When the catholic church was all powerful and copernicus was "heretical" with his heliocenstrism, the poles rejected him and painted him as a german. When catholic power waned and heliocentrism won over geocentrism, the poles embraced copernicus as their son. So for a time, germans could claim that they invented heliocentrism.

Of course copernicus didn't invent the idea of heliocentrism either.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aristarchus_of_Samos

And it's highly likely aristarchus didn't invent the idea first either.

Re: Who invented the lightbulb?

#56
post #17
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

well... like the telephone: everyone in italy know that the inventor is not Bell, but Meucci

and everyone in italy know that marconi stole the idea of the radio receiver from bose's coherer?

Who in turn got the idea from David Edward Hughes (and others)

Re: Who invented the lightbulb?

#57

I really recommend "How Innovation Works" by Matt Ridley to better understand the history of different inventions and innovations. It also dispels the myth of the singular event of invention by a single person. Rather innovation is a process of compilation.

I would like to second - "How Innovation Works" by Matt Ridley is an excellent book. I see the kindle version is £1.99 on amazon.co.uk atm - what a bargain. Most innovations we all enjoy and cherish are a product of long chain of trial and error by different people at different times. Often the theory is understood poorly (if at all) at the time of the invention, and developed after. Luck plays a role in particular p…

Thanks. Now purchased.
Post reply on HN