Live data from Hacker News

Product Marketing for Engineers

github.com

51–60 of 89 posts

Re: Product Marketing for Engineers

#51
post #40

I saw a sales funnel for an app I built for a customer once. 99% people dropped before they even saw the app. I could have built the best app in the world, and no one would have ever known.

That's one hell of a leaky funnel. Did you ever figure out the underlying issue?

Re: Product Marketing for Engineers

#52
post #11

I’ve often found engineers really struggle to jump over their own shadows when it comes to marketing. Things like... - “Marketing is evil!” ... perhaps but it’s also a necessary evil if you want anyone using your product - “Build it and they will come” ... except they won’t unless you tell people - “I hate spam/push messages/ads therefor everyone else must do to” ... but engineers tend to be the grumpiest about this…

I'd love to be good at marketing, I'm just... not. I'm good at empathizing with users, but that doesn't help if you don't have any because you suck at marketing.

Re: Product Marketing for Engineers

#53

Looks useful as I'm just getting into that sort of stuff for my business [0] I experimented with two ad campaigns, on Facebook and on Reddit, both the cheapest options. Had some weird results from the FB one: most of the "reached" users were concentrated in Eastern Europe, even though my locations were set to the US, Canada and Europe. All in all, it didn't yield many clicks but for ~£10 I wasn't expecting much. Redd…

This seems like it could be a useful offering but "Makely" sounds like a parody of a tech business name; have you considered rebranding?

Re: Product Marketing for Engineers

#54
Really? https://github.com/LisaDziuba/Marketing-for-Engineers/issues...

Am I the only one that thinks it’s annoying that people feel compelled to announce their enthusiasm? I’ve always thought reddit comments along the lines of “have you an upvote” were annoying noise, but this seems a bit more egregious. Issues are supposed to be for reporting issues, it’s on the name! Not only did someone have to spend time to read this, and close it, but it crowds out actual issues.

Re: Product Marketing for Engineers

#55

Really? https://github.com/LisaDziuba/Marketing-for-Engineers/issues... Am I the only one that thinks it’s annoying that people feel compelled to announce their enthusiasm? I’ve always thought reddit comments along the lines of “have you an upvote” were annoying noise, but this seems a bit more egregious. Issues are supposed to be for reporting issues, it’s on the name! Not only did someone have to spend time to read…

This is inevitable when someone tries to turn forge hosting into social media (and succeeds at it).

Re: Product Marketing for Engineers

#56
post #53

Looks useful as I'm just getting into that sort of stuff for my business [0] I experimented with two ad campaigns, on Facebook and on Reddit, both the cheapest options. Had some weird results from the FB one: most of the "reached" users were concentrated in Eastern Europe, even though my locations were set to the US, Canada and Europe. All in all, it didn't yield many clicks but for ~£10 I wasn't expecting much. Redd…

This seems like it could be a useful offering but "Makely" sounds like a parody of a tech business name; have you considered rebranding?

Haha, I can see where you're coming from. Makely was actually a preliminary name that I used when I was still prototyping this and it just sort of stuck.

I have considered rebranding, but I am yet to think of something better. Makely has slowly grown on me. I'll be happy to listen to suggestions!

Re: Product Marketing for Engineers

#57

Looks useful as I'm just getting into that sort of stuff for my business [0] I experimented with two ad campaigns, on Facebook and on Reddit, both the cheapest options. Had some weird results from the FB one: most of the "reached" users were concentrated in Eastern Europe, even though my locations were set to the US, Canada and Europe. All in all, it didn't yield many clicks but for ~£10 I wasn't expecting much. Redd…

Makely looks nice! Thanks for sharing. I sent the link along to someone who was considering starting a 3D design business :) I haven't signed up myself, but how are you planning on solving the chicken/egg marketplace problem?

I'm glad you like it and thanks for spreading the word!

> how are you planning on solving the chicken/egg marketplace problem

The plan at the moment is to advertise whilst it's still in deveopment and get a healthy user base of mostly creators. It will take time; I don't expect it to blow up overnight.

I have worries when it comes to attracting enough "clients" because that's significantly harder to advertise to. To start off with, the demographic we'll be targeting will be general gaming and board game enthusiasts, as well as some of the "creative" communities that exist on the web.

Re: Product Marketing for Engineers

#58
post #11

I’ve often found engineers really struggle to jump over their own shadows when it comes to marketing. Things like... - “Marketing is evil!” ... perhaps but it’s also a necessary evil if you want anyone using your product - “Build it and they will come” ... except they won’t unless you tell people - “I hate spam/push messages/ads therefor everyone else must do to” ... but engineers tend to be the grumpiest about this…

The reason for the grumpiness is that, marketing or not, software works and exists. The opposite doesn't happen.

Cue in the stereotypical markethead rappresentation: vapid, buzzword filled, socially successful.

Re: Product Marketing for Engineers

#59

This is nice and fine, but I feel that the world needs more engineering for marketeers. Some of the marketing stuff that they pull out is so outrageulsy ridiculous (cf. zoom's infamous "end to end encryption") that we are afraid to talk about their products in polite company.

>Some of the marketing stuff that they pull out is so outrageulsy ridiculous

You said it here. Some.

Like some engineering endeavors are outrageously ridiculous. No?

Re: Product Marketing for Engineers

#60
post #40

I saw a sales funnel for an app I built for a customer once. 99% people dropped before they even saw the app. I could have built the best app in the world, and no one would have ever known.

That's one hell of a leaky funnel. Did you ever figure out the underlying issue?

Problem was the ads target audience was to broad.
Post reply on HN