Live data from Hacker News

Maps Reveal the Difference in How Cities Are Perceived by Tourists and Locals

archdaily.com

51–60 of 105 posts

Re: Maps Reveal the Difference in How Cities Are Perceived by Tourists and Locals

#51

It says "The red dots indicate photographs taken by tourists, while the blue dots show images taken by local residents" but what is the orange?

Yellow is can't be determined (because they haven't taken a picture anywhere for over a month).

https://www.cnet.com/news/the-rise-of-the-accidental-sensor/

Re: Maps Reveal the Difference in How Cities Are Perceived by Tourists and Locals

#52

As someone who lived in Paris for many years now, it's fascinating how the city has sort of three identities: 1. What outsiders think it's like 2. What they see when they encounter the city as tourists 3. What the city is like for a local You'd say this is true for any city but Paris in particular has concentrated so many stereotypes together that it's almost comical to see people's attitudes yo-yo so dramatically in…

I'm reminded of Paris Syndrome, which is phenomenon common with the Japanese, where they assume Paris is something it is not, and get angry and frustrated upon visiting. https://grapee.jp/en/99643 I'd say similar things about Texas, DC, and NYC, for that matter.

My European colleagues were distraught about DC and the White House in general. They couldn’t believe how small it was compared to European Palaces for Monarchs, ex rulers, etc.

They didn’t understand when I said it was probably the point. We fought against a British monarch, why would we build massive palaces for our non-monarch president? They said look all the power is in Congress their buildings are much bigger.

Re: Maps Reveal the Difference in How Cities Are Perceived by Tourists and Locals

#55
post #7

Living in semi-touristic district, it’s funny to see how locals views differ from tourists. We have a special term for it: local resident syndrome. It’s when someone asks you if there is something interesting to look at here, but you don’t know, despite living here since forever. Well, I can show you where that expensive nightclub is on the map, does it count? I also see people making selfies with decorative street e…

Those Seattle pig and San Francisco heart fiberglass art installations really messed things up touristicly. After that every city has to have some kind of pop symbol tourists could ID as of that city do they could take selfies with it.

That said, implicit in some of the commentary is that tourists miss the local aspect of s city they visit by remaining in tourist areas. My take is that is the whole point of most tourism. They don’t want to see the same humdrum stuff they have in their home cities, they don’t need to know about boring shitty areas or family residential areas. No, they want some foreign entertainment and feel. They want some levity and some pop on their holidays.

Re: Maps Reveal the Difference in How Cities Are Perceived by Tourists and Locals

#56

It’s always fun to quantify this. I can say that for certain I avoid the tourist things in my home city and my current adopted home city. I cannot remember the last time i was near them, actually.

But why? Tourist sights are tourist sites for a reason. The Tower of London is swarming with tourist, but its still genuinely fascinating. If only for Henry VIII's armoured codpiece.

Tourist sights are tourist sites for a reason.

I think there is more than a reason. Some are legitimately full of history or interest, like the Tower of London. Some might only appeal to a niche group of people whether you're a local or just visiting (As a fan of the Blues Brothers, I had to stop by the honorable Richard J. Daley Plaza in Chicago just to see where they got that Picasso). Some just have good marketing that the locals are in a better position to see through.

Re: Maps Reveal the Difference in How Cities Are Perceived by Tourists and Locals

#57
post #30

I feel like this is applicable on a smaller scale than tourist/locals as well. I have lived in the same place in the same city for 7 years now and I have almost never been to any of the good bars/restaurants close to me. I'm always surprised when friends who live other places in the city recommend me places that I've walked past a hundred times in my neighborhood but never went into, and vice versa. I wonder why it i…

When you're at home, do you go out to eat often? If so, how do you choose where to go? I'm sure the answer lies in one of these questions.

Re: Maps Reveal the Difference in How Cities Are Perceived by Tourists and Locals

#58
post #7

Living in semi-touristic district, it’s funny to see how locals views differ from tourists. We have a special term for it: local resident syndrome. It’s when someone asks you if there is something interesting to look at here, but you don’t know, despite living here since forever. Well, I can show you where that expensive nightclub is on the map, does it count? I also see people making selfies with decorative street e…

I also see people making selfies with decorative street elements (simple installations and/or statues) that were installed, say, a year ago, and really mean nothing, but are perceived as if they had a history.

How do you know how other people perceive these things?

Re: Maps Reveal the Difference in How Cities Are Perceived by Tourists and Locals

#59
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm reminded of Paris Syndrome, which is phenomenon common with the Japanese, where they assume Paris is something it is not, and get angry and frustrated upon visiting. https://grapee.jp/en/99643 I'd say similar things about Texas, DC, and NYC, for that matter.

My European colleagues were distraught about DC and the White House in general. They couldn’t believe how small it was compared to European Palaces for Monarchs, ex rulers, etc. They didn’t understand when I said it was probably the point. We fought against a British monarch, why would we build massive palaces for our non-monarch president? They said look all the power is in Congress their buildings are much bigger.

The common contrasting explanation is that DC is projecting power by limiting how ostentatious it is, but nevertheless restricting other buildings from being tall.

While the Capitol dome theory is a myth, the maximum height[1] allowed for building is set by law. It was due to safety concerns about then very new skyscrapers, but at the same time, the limit has persisted long after.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Height_of_Buildings_Act_of_191...

Re: Maps Reveal the Difference in How Cities Are Perceived by Tourists and Locals

#60
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm reminded of Paris Syndrome, which is phenomenon common with the Japanese, where they assume Paris is something it is not, and get angry and frustrated upon visiting. https://grapee.jp/en/99643 I'd say similar things about Texas, DC, and NYC, for that matter.

It is a funny article, but this line puts things in perspective: > Out of the million or so Japanese tourists that visit Paris each year, about 12 will fall prey to Paris syndrome.

“12 Japanese tourists let down by Paris visit each year” doesn’t quite have the same oomph.
Post reply on HN