Live data from Hacker News

Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

blog.google

51–60 of 142 posts

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#51

No tutorials on how to get started and the product could possibly be purged in another 3 years. Start with something like Gamemaker if you really want something that will be around for sometime.

> No tutorials on how to get started

The system indeed has a tutorial built in.

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#52
post #27

It will be good for a few quarters of it's existence before Google shuts it down, as is tradition.

this refrain has become the "first post!!1" of the HN community, every time google is posted about. what does "lolz teh g00gz will shut it down next week!" add to the conversation?

A fair warning to people who would otherwise get excited. A reminder to people to not tie to Google services, and always have a backup plan because they will get shut down when you least expect it.

It's also a way of sending a market signal. If enough people start hesitating with adoption and promotion of Google services, they might finally eventually notice something is wrong and change their ways.

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#53

Does anyone else remember an old "game" for making games? It would have been late 90s when I played it, and I remember we bought it on a CD. You could build little top down games in it, I think the example was a football game.

Games factory? Thanks to that game, me and my friends made many games without programming back in middle school.

https://www.softpedia.com/get/Others/Home-Education/The-Game...

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#54

Does anyone else remember an old "game" for making games? It would have been late 90s when I played it, and I remember we bought it on a CD. You could build little top down games in it, I think the example was a football game.

GameMaker? Now developed by Yoyo Games

https://www.yoyogames.com/gamemaker

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#56
post #2

It’s a shame that making simple games doesn’t require coding like it used to. For myself, and a lot of others I’m sure, games were a huge motivator to teach myself programming. Now kids won’t be as motivated to do that

I would have killed to have tools like Unity when I got into game programming. All of my hobby time was eaten up trying to wrangle OpenGL and C++ and crappy open source engines, and cobbling together a shitty physics engine, so I never got around to the actual game part. When I went back years later to prototype ideas in Unity, it was a breath of fresh air. However, in my struggles to get off the ground, I did learn…

Wait, you can’t leave us hanging about how font rendering was unexpectedly useful. What kind of fonts did you deal with later in life and why?

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#57
I was ready to be skeptical but this is pretty cool. If it were trying to replace Minecraft or games like it then it would be a tough sell, and you would have a hard time breaking into that community. But it looks like it's more powerful for the individual contributors, with the ability to make custom blocks/entities on the fly rather than just using the ones someone else coded up and made into a mod.

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#58
post #2

It’s a shame that making simple games doesn’t require coding like it used to. For myself, and a lot of others I’m sure, games were a huge motivator to teach myself programming. Now kids won’t be as motivated to do that

Yeah, I repeated that as a mantra when I was first learning to program and trying to make games. We all did, it was a common meme of our local game development scene.

And it's utter and complete nonsense. If what you want is to make a game, then these tools aren't half as bad, and at the level of simple games, unless you have some really novel mechanic, you're quite literally wasting time and effort coding it instead of using a game builder.

What drove this point home to me after more than a decade were two situations.

1) on a global game jam, the artist in our team got fed up waiting for us programmers after 3 or 4 hours, and did the prototype we're trying to build in 15 minutes flat, using Construct 2.

2) you too may be surprised to discover that some of the fun and highly acclaimed titles like Cook Serve Delicious or Nuclear Throne were made in Game Maker. I didn't even suspect it until I found it on-line (in the former case, because sources were available in Humble Bundle's Game Maker bundle).

There's value in hand-coding a game, and this is what I still like to do in simple cases, but it's often not the practical option. And if a game maker allows you to add custom code, then really there's no difference between this and Unity or Unreal Engine.

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#59

Seems nice. Anyone has an opinion on why Google built this? Do you think it is related to Stadia? Or just a company hobby turning well?

From another comment, it was released by their internal startup incubator. It's potentially not related to anything else at all inside Google, just a project a small team was able to put together with Google's money.

Re: Game Builder: Create 3D games with friends, no experience required

#60
post #46

Any word on when it will get Linux support?

I thought Steam could automatically load up Wine, or something like that?

Not at all. Linux support is developers effort and if you are serious about it you won't use wine.
Post reply on HN