Live data from Hacker News

Peddling the ‘Secrets’ to Getting Rich on Amazon

theatlantic.com

51–60 of 94 posts

Re: Peddling the ‘Secrets’ to Getting Rich on Amazon

#52

People forget that history repeats itself -- the ones that got richest during the California Gold Rush were the ones selling tools, unless you were lucky enough to hit a motherlode. So if someone is selling you an expensive tool that will help make you rich, ask yourself why they aren't using that same tool themselves. (and if the answer is "I have all the money I need, I just want to help other people... then ask wh…

This is the real "secret" that people seem to totally miss/willfully ignore. 4K is quite a lot for what is essentially pretty obvious stuff that I am sure a weekend of searching around could get you. Caveat emptor

Finding information is easy, filtering is the hard part.

Re: Peddling the ‘Secrets’ to Getting Rich on Amazon

#53
>The aerators kept breaking, and so Bjork and McDowell had to pay for returns.

Uhhh... People should know not to try to sell anything FBA that's fragile; Amazon never packages or handles fragile products correctly. Should have been covered in the webinar... obviously these people are just out to get a quick buck, not actually help others sell on Amazon. That and they partnered with a Chinese manufacturer that had minimum orders in the thousands... that seems like a ridiculous commitment for something that's essentially an experiment.

These people who fell for this seem like the same sorts of people who fall for MLMs...

I remember someone calling into Dave Ramsey's show saying they spent something like $60,000 on these "get rich seminars" going through different "levels" and didn't even make a penny. Unbelievable...

Re: Peddling the ‘Secrets’ to Getting Rich on Amazon

#54

People forget that history repeats itself -- the ones that got richest during the California Gold Rush were the ones selling tools, unless you were lucky enough to hit a motherlode. So if someone is selling you an expensive tool that will help make you rich, ask yourself why they aren't using that same tool themselves. (and if the answer is "I have all the money I need, I just want to help other people... then ask wh…

Just for the sake of argument, should all computer makers really be solving all problems computers can be used for?

No, of course not. Companies (and individuals) must specialize at some level. And I personally feel some of our largest companies have overstepped that line.

Re: Peddling the ‘Secrets’ to Getting Rich on Amazon

#55

> They’re frustrated with Amazon, which they say is making money off the failures of people like them. Wait what... I can't even. It's not Amazon's fault you bought something no one wanted then tried to sell it. You wanted easy money and it doesn't exist. You CHOSE to ship directly to Amazon so you didn't have to handle shipping, you CHOSE a quality item that kept breaking, they CHOSE to use Amazon, any they CHOSE to…

Is there really any money left to be made? Reselling from China on Amazon such a crowded space I don't know if it's possible to get in the game at this point without employing shady tactics. Especially now that the Chinese are selling direct on Amazon.

Re: Peddling the ‘Secrets’ to Getting Rich on Amazon

#56
Is "passive income" now synonymous with get-rich-quick schemes and fraud?

Sometimes I cringe when I see Ask HN posts with this term. Even though the answers are usually sincere and illuminating, it seems that the motivation for seeking out this type of information is usually to find an idea for an easy niche to monetize, which is what a lot of the consumers of these "Amazon expert" courses are after, too.

Re: Peddling the ‘Secrets’ to Getting Rich on Amazon

#57
post #21

But really, is this any different than these "coding academies" where you pay $10k to "learn to be a programmer in 30 days and get a great job making $100k+ a year"?

The only thing unusual about that sentence is 30 days.

Maybe 12 weeks is also unrealistic unless they accept people who already have experience. $100k is $60k after taxes, which might cover rent in San Francisco.

Re: Peddling the ‘Secrets’ to Getting Rich on Amazon

#58

> They’re frustrated with Amazon, which they say is making money off the failures of people like them. Wait what... I can't even. It's not Amazon's fault you bought something no one wanted then tried to sell it. You wanted easy money and it doesn't exist. You CHOSE to ship directly to Amazon so you didn't have to handle shipping, you CHOSE a quality item that kept breaking, they CHOSE to use Amazon, any they CHOSE to…

> it takes more research, time, and effort all of which they decided was beneath them

Or it's above them and they fell victim to a Dunning-Kruger situation?

Re: Peddling the ‘Secrets’ to Getting Rich on Amazon

#59
post #37
post #34

I don't know why people still believe that someone with a winning (money making) system is going to share that with others. If a system works that well, nobody is going to sell instructions on how to do it. Maybe they'll share the knowledge with a few friends or family, but they sure won't sell it. To sell "how to get rich" information clearly implies that the seller is not getting rich. If they were, and even if the…

There is the concept of franchises like McDonalds which seems to go against your point.

To expand, it makes sense in situations where the "expert" is unable to scale up any farther (lack of capital or labor come to mind) or cannot expand farther without assuming an uncomfortable amount of risk. The second possibility should set off alarm bells for small investors. (Case in point: many McDonald's franchisees struggle to break even while the McDonald's corporation rakes in a steady income.)

If someone really is "retired but wants to help people", I would expect to see the core educational content available for free (or near distribution cost) with the option to pay for one-on-one coaching/consulting services.

Re: Peddling the ‘Secrets’ to Getting Rich on Amazon

#60
post #50
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is the concept of franchises like McDonalds which seems to go against your point.

Running a franchise seems neither quick nor easy and usually requires a large upfront investment.

And since the franchisee is representing the franchise's brand they have incentive to help the franchisee succeed and only accept franchisees that are likely to succeed.

Not to mention the franchise collects commission on the franchisee's ongoing sales, not just a lump sum up front and say "you're on your own, have fun." It's quite a different ballgame altogether.

Post reply on HN