Live data from Hacker News

Colin O’Brady Completes Crossing of Antarctica with Final 32-Hour Push

nytimes.com

51–60 of 134 posts

Re: Colin O’Brady Completes Crossing of Antarctica with Final 32-Hour Push

#51

What is the definition of crossing Antarctica? It seems you have start at some point on the coast, go to the South Pole, then go to another point on the coast. But the South Pole isn't the midpoint. Nor are the two coastal points 180 degrees apart. Like what's the smallest angle that qualifies as a crossing? (If I hike along the France Spain border, is that hiking across Europe?) Not to say it's any easier, but ever…

His website has a map and discussion of the route:

https://www.colinobrady.com/theimpossiblefirst

Re: Colin O’Brady Completes Crossing of Antarctica with Final 32-Hour Push

#52
post #5

Just this week I read a story about Henry Worsley who died trying the same thing: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/02/12/the-white-dark... . After reading, I wonder if you have to a certain level of insanity for doing something like this.

This level of insanity is not as foreign as you might think. The feeling of accomplishment I get from climbing a mountain, finishing a marathon or a long bike trip is comparable to the feeling I get after taping out a chip, shipping a major software release or delivering first-of-a-kind hardware to a customer.

For some of us, getting Tetris to work in Conway's Game of Life is insanity. For other people, walking across a continent is insanity.

Re: Colin O’Brady Completes Crossing of Antarctica with Final 32-Hour Push

#53

What is the definition of crossing Antarctica? It seems you have start at some point on the coast, go to the South Pole, then go to another point on the coast. But the South Pole isn't the midpoint. Nor are the two coastal points 180 degrees apart. Like what's the smallest angle that qualifies as a crossing? (If I hike along the France Spain border, is that hiking across Europe?) Not to say it's any easier, but ever…

His website has a map and discussion of the route: https://www.colinobrady.com/theimpossiblefirst

That doesn't really explain the definition of crossing. If crossing a continent invokes going from one point to another, as one might reasonably assume, then why the detour to the South Pole? Why not simply go in a straight line between those points?

Re: Colin O’Brady Completes Crossing of Antarctica with Final 32-Hour Push

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

His website has a map and discussion of the route: https://www.colinobrady.com/theimpossiblefirst

That doesn't really explain the definition of crossing. If crossing a continent invokes going from one point to another, as one might reasonably assume, then why the detour to the South Pole? Why not simply go in a straight line between those points?

Because how many people have been to the south pole? It's an elite club and if you're already going most of the way there, why not get two cards punched instead of just one?

Re: Colin O’Brady Completes Crossing of Antarctica with Final 32-Hour Push

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

His website has a map and discussion of the route: https://www.colinobrady.com/theimpossiblefirst

That doesn't really explain the definition of crossing. If crossing a continent invokes going from one point to another, as one might reasonably assume, then why the detour to the South Pole? Why not simply go in a straight line between those points?

I don’t think the intention is to impress people by sneaking in the word “crossing.” I think it just means, well, walking across Antarctica a pretty long way with no outside support. That should be impressive enough. It’s not like it was easy because they didn’t choose the longest possible straight line through the South Pole.

Re: Colin O’Brady Completes Crossing of Antarctica with Final 32-Hour Push

#56
post #2

At first I was shocked by how large a sled he dragged. I use a much smaller sled (just a deer sled). Then I saw how smooth the terrain was at least where the photo was taken. Then I read that he was out for 53 days . And of course his conditions are far, far more grueling than I have ever faced (all in North America). So then I was shocked at how little he had with him!

I talked to a guy who tried to cross it once. To get the huge number of required calories in a compact form they drank olive oil. He didn’t like it and it sure sounds nasty.

O'brady describes his diet here:

https://www.instagram.com/p/BqOWpIMl7Si/?utm_source=ig_share...

7000 calories a day!

Re: Colin O’Brady Completes Crossing of Antarctica with Final 32-Hour Push

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

His website has a map and discussion of the route: https://www.colinobrady.com/theimpossiblefirst

That doesn't really explain the definition of crossing. If crossing a continent invokes going from one point to another, as one might reasonably assume, then why the detour to the South Pole? Why not simply go in a straight line between those points?

[deleted]

Re: Colin O’Brady Completes Crossing of Antarctica with Final 32-Hour Push

#58
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

well you go up and down some mountains, see strange ice formations that don't exist anywhere at all, get to tweet out sappy tweets every evening, go where no/few men/women have gone before and all.

You make it sound like a nice stroll in the park, not something that exhausts you to and beyond and your limit and tries to.kill and harm you every day.

[deleted]

Re: Colin O’Brady Completes Crossing of Antarctica with Final 32-Hour Push

#59

What is the definition of crossing Antarctica? It seems you have start at some point on the coast, go to the South Pole, then go to another point on the coast. But the South Pole isn't the midpoint. Nor are the two coastal points 180 degrees apart. Like what's the smallest angle that qualifies as a crossing? (If I hike along the France Spain border, is that hiking across Europe?) Not to say it's any easier, but ever…

You're right that it would make more sense if the route had to go through the midpoint of Antarctica (defined as the point that is farthest from any coast) rather than to the south pole. That remains un-done. For now, the "through the south pole" route is the longest trek that's been completed.

Re: Colin O’Brady Completes Crossing of Antarctica with Final 32-Hour Push

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

His website has a map and discussion of the route: https://www.colinobrady.com/theimpossiblefirst

That doesn't really explain the definition of crossing. If crossing a continent invokes going from one point to another, as one might reasonably assume, then why the detour to the South Pole? Why not simply go in a straight line between those points?

I feel like going to the south pole is part of the overall goal. Also this particular flavor of accomplishment has never been done before, and I imagine they're less concerned about time, thus being less concerned about crossing the exact shortest distance. At the same time, I would bet there are already per-established base stations at the start and finish locations. Just a hunch though.
Post reply on HN