Live data from Hacker News

Full Hacker News: single page with top 30 articles inlined

fullhn.com

51–60 of 72 posts

Re: Full Hacker News: single page with top 30 articles inlined

#51

Seems like nowadays one can submit a 2-hour app to HN and still get to the frontpage. And of course if you dare to post a negative opinion, embrace the downvotes (it’ll also happen with this comment). Man this place is crappy sometimes.

A 2-hour app is better than a 10-second complaint, isn't it?

Re: Full Hacker News: single page with top 30 articles inlined

#52
post #43

Title could be: "single page with [THE FULL ARTICLE TEXT OF] the top 30 stories" Feature-wise this is great, it's like an auto-inlined Safari reader version of all the articles. Unfortunately re-publishing other people's work (written article) is generally considered theft or a copyright violation. HOWEVER, things like safari reader exist, and I believe side-step the copyright issue by not storing or "publishing" the…

How does Pocket handle this? It has the same feature afterall.

Re: Full Hacker News: single page with top 30 articles inlined

#56
post #43

Title could be: "single page with [THE FULL ARTICLE TEXT OF] the top 30 stories" Feature-wise this is great, it's like an auto-inlined Safari reader version of all the articles. Unfortunately re-publishing other people's work (written article) is generally considered theft or a copyright violation. HOWEVER, things like safari reader exist, and I believe side-step the copyright issue by not storing or "publishing" the…

Search engines do it to some extent too when showing snippets. There must be some special provision saying that isn't copyright violation.

Wondering what did the author use here to extract content? edit: its php-redability, project is here https://github.com/mauricesvay/FullHackerNews

Re: Full Hacker News: single page with top 30 articles inlined

#58
post #43

Title could be: "single page with [THE FULL ARTICLE TEXT OF] the top 30 stories" Feature-wise this is great, it's like an auto-inlined Safari reader version of all the articles. Unfortunately re-publishing other people's work (written article) is generally considered theft or a copyright violation. HOWEVER, things like safari reader exist, and I believe side-step the copyright issue by not storing or "publishing" the…

Search engines do it to some extent too when showing snippets. There must be some special provision saying that isn't copyright violation. Wondering what did the author use here to extract content? edit: its php-redability, project is here https://github.com/mauricesvay/FullHackerNews

Snippets are more likely to be fair use. One of the fair use factor is how much of the original work you use.

Re: Full Hacker News: single page with top 30 articles inlined

#59
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think this every time I see one of these posts. I don’t want to demean their effort and good on them for building. But why am I seeing this on the front page?

Because people that are upvoting it enjoy HN and like to see all the various ways you might formulate its content presentation. Beyond merely altering HN, sites like that become general experiments in content presentation that others can study and learn from. This process of showing HN formulations now spans a decade and tends to change with the times, which again presents value.

That makes sense.

Re: Full Hacker News: single page with top 30 articles inlined

#60
post #44

I come to HN not just for the links to the articles, but more so for the comments. If you inline the articles, why not snap-shot the comments too?

Something like OP's page, but with a "tl;dr bot" style summary, and the top 5 comments in-lined, would be amazing as a Send-to-Kindle type thing.

I use Instapaper + the Send-to-Kindle feature to read things in bed each evening, and being able to read a summary of HN that day would be amazing.

Post reply on HN