Live data from Hacker News

Simone Giertz on her brain tumour [video]

youtube.com

51–60 of 78 posts

Re: Simone Giertz on her brain tumour [video]

#51
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

She has posted on twitter that she is staying in the US for treatment. https://twitter.com/SimoneGiertz/status/990983271705018368

That is because the US has the best treatment and medical care in the world. Kind of proves the point about universal healthcare not working.

You’re being sarcastic right?

Re: Simone Giertz on her brain tumour [video]

#52
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That is because the US has the best treatment and medical care in the world. Kind of proves the point about universal healthcare not working.

[deleted]

People not having access to care is not related to the quality of the care. The fact that she has completely free medical care in Sweden, but is staying in the US to have the surgery proves that the quality of the care in the US when you can afford it is the best in the world. You are misunderstanding what quality of care means.

Re: Simone Giertz on her brain tumour [video]

#53

It's good that her tumor isn't cancerous, but she's going to be out of action for at least a year. I see other people saying that she can make a full recovery, but this is not the type of thing you ever fully recover from. Two of my girlfriends had brain tumors, both in their 20s. It's life changing, if not life shattering.

Sen. John McCain returned to the senate 10 days after "minimally invasive" brain surgery above his left eye, and he is 81.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_McCain#Brain_tumor_diagno...

Re: Simone Giertz on her brain tumour [video]

#54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That is because the US has the best treatment and medical care in the world. Kind of proves the point about universal healthcare not working.

Nobody made that point and it definitely doesn't prove it. Edit: Also weird that you seemed to first imply that the U.S system wasn't great

I am implying that insurance is awful, the actual care if money is not an issue is the best in the world in the US.

Re: Simone Giertz on her brain tumour [video]

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That is because the US has the best treatment and medical care in the world. Kind of proves the point about universal healthcare not working.

Maybe she’s wealthy enough to be able to not go bankrupt for her treatment, and staying around friends and family and avoiding travel are all good ideas for someone with brain cancer?

Not quite how healthcare works in the US. Unless you consider having the money to cover your max out-of-pocket (between 1000-4500usd, depending on insurance plan) and copays (50-125usd) as "wealthy".

The situation you're referring to applies to the 11-12% of Americans who have no health insurance. An unfortunate situation that the US should work to rectify (ideally with a universal option), but hardly the third-world situation most Europeans envision.

Re: Simone Giertz on her brain tumour [video]

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe she’s wealthy enough to be able to not go bankrupt for her treatment, and staying around friends and family and avoiding travel are all good ideas for someone with brain cancer?

Not quite how healthcare works in the US. Unless you consider having the money to cover your max out-of-pocket (between 1000-4500usd, depending on insurance plan) and copays (50-125usd) as "wealthy". The situation you're referring to applies to the 11-12% of Americans who have no health insurance. An unfortunate situation that the US should work to rectify (ideally with a universal option), but hardly the third-world…

I don't know what plan you have, but my $400 a month plan max out of pocket is $10,000 $7,350 annual (resets each and every year).

Re: Simone Giertz on her brain tumour [video]

#58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe she’s wealthy enough to be able to not go bankrupt for her treatment, and staying around friends and family and avoiding travel are all good ideas for someone with brain cancer?

Not quite how healthcare works in the US. Unless you consider having the money to cover your max out-of-pocket (between 1000-4500usd, depending on insurance plan) and copays (50-125usd) as "wealthy". The situation you're referring to applies to the 11-12% of Americans who have no health insurance. An unfortunate situation that the US should work to rectify (ideally with a universal option), but hardly the third-world…

> Not quite how healthcare works in the US. Unless you consider having the money to cover your max out-of-pocket (between 1000-4500usd, depending on insurance plan) and copays (50-125usd) as "wealthy".

Max annual out of pocket includes copays, do you don't need to cover both separately, but 1000-4500 is not the range of out of pocket maximums. The limit for a bronze marketplace plan is $7,300 for an individual plan or $14,600 for a family plan; the average for bronze marketplace plans is about for $12,000 for a family plan. And that's for things the plan covers; there's obviously no maximum for services excluded from coverage.

Re: Simone Giertz on her brain tumour [video]

#59
Currently people in my life left and right get diagnosed with cancer and it’s awful.

I wonder what one can do to make sure to not run into the same surprise. I am guessing because of the many kinds of cancer that you can’t just do a “cancer checkup” twice a year?

Re: Simone Giertz on her brain tumour [video]

#60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not quite how healthcare works in the US. Unless you consider having the money to cover your max out-of-pocket (between 1000-4500usd, depending on insurance plan) and copays (50-125usd) as "wealthy". The situation you're referring to applies to the 11-12% of Americans who have no health insurance. An unfortunate situation that the US should work to rectify (ideally with a universal option), but hardly the third-world…

> Not quite how healthcare works in the US. Unless you consider having the money to cover your max out-of-pocket (between 1000-4500usd, depending on insurance plan) and copays (50-125usd) as "wealthy". Max annual out of pocket includes copays, do you don't need to cover both separately, but 1000-4500 is not the range of out of pocket maximums. The limit for a bronze marketplace plan is $7,300 for an individual plan o…

.
Post reply on HN