Live data from Hacker News

Shotcut: Free, open source, cross-platform video editor

shotcutapp.com

51–60 of 141 posts

Re: Shotcut: Free, open source, cross-platform video editor

#51

I used it recently to edit large video files around around 1h 1080p; Shotcut is rather slow and freezes often when editing big files. But nonetheless its a great project and I hope it will improve in the future.

I don't know if Shotcut supports it, but in almost all cases it makes sense to edit with smaller proxies rather than massive full-size video files. Obviously this gets truer if your footage is 4k or more, but it's still true of 1080p.

Re: Shotcut: Free, open source, cross-platform video editor

#52
Shotcut (on Linux at least) just doesn't work.

I've used pretty much all amateur video-making software for Windows and some for Mac, Screenflow, FinalCut Pro, etc.

The best by far is FinalCut Pro (Mac-only), because it automatically creates proxy files and allows you to edit everything in real time with no lag, even when adding complicated effects.

The situation on Linux is dismal. The only good one is https://kdenlive.org/. It's actually I'd say at par to FinalCut in terms of performance, although the UI could use some clean up. It's the one I use because the other ones would either keep crashing, or be impossibly slow.

Re: Shotcut: Free, open source, cross-platform video editor

#53

Shotcut (on Linux at least) just doesn't work. I've used pretty much all amateur video-making software for Windows and some for Mac, Screenflow, FinalCut Pro, etc. The best by far is FinalCut Pro (Mac-only), because it automatically creates proxy files and allows you to edit everything in real time with no lag, even when adding complicated effects. The situation on Linux is dismal. The only good one is https://kdenli…

The few times I had to edit video with Kdenlive, it was very prone to crashing. That was about a year ago, so it might have changed.

Re: Shotcut: Free, open source, cross-platform video editor

#54

Shotcut (on Linux at least) just doesn't work. I've used pretty much all amateur video-making software for Windows and some for Mac, Screenflow, FinalCut Pro, etc. The best by far is FinalCut Pro (Mac-only), because it automatically creates proxy files and allows you to edit everything in real time with no lag, even when adding complicated effects. The situation on Linux is dismal. The only good one is https://kdenli…

The few times I had to edit video with Kdenlive, it was very prone to crashing. That was about a year ago, so it might have changed.

I think Linux varies a lot according to distro and packages/libs installed, it might be that, too.

Shotcut wouldn't keep working with XFCE4 Xubuntu 16.04 for me. If I applied any heavier effect it would freeze, then crash.

Re: Shotcut: Free, open source, cross-platform video editor

#55

Shotcut (on Linux at least) just doesn't work. I've used pretty much all amateur video-making software for Windows and some for Mac, Screenflow, FinalCut Pro, etc. The best by far is FinalCut Pro (Mac-only), because it automatically creates proxy files and allows you to edit everything in real time with no lag, even when adding complicated effects. The situation on Linux is dismal. The only good one is https://kdenli…

The few times I had to edit video with Kdenlive, it was very prone to crashing. That was about a year ago, so it might have changed.

Kdenlive crashes _a lot_. But recently I discovered that it crashes much less if GPU effects are disabled and the binaries from their webpage (not from Debian, etc.) are used. Still it can be frustrating to use just because of the crashing, otherwise a quite nice program...

Re: Shotcut: Free, open source, cross-platform video editor

#56
post #38

How does it compare directly to Camtasia in a real world comparison? For example with Camtasia, you can click 1 button and have your desktop + audio + optional webcam all being recorded to your video project, and then you can hop in and edit it with a bunch of great tools and presets. This includes complex animations and tooltips with doing nothing more than dragging around a few sliders. Basically you can get up and…

OBS is fantastic for screencasting: https://obsproject.com/

Re: Shotcut: Free, open source, cross-platform video editor

#57
post #27

I would like to have a simple free video editor that can cut and append files together without re-encoding. It's doable with avidemux, but it is just pain to manage.

My use case is to cut segments from one video file and append the segments together. This way I can trim ads or parts I don't want.

The aged virtualdub does this as long as the container is avi (the codec could be avc/h.264 etc). I used avidemux to convert mp4 to avi without reencoding (just change the container format), then use virtualdub to trim it.

Actually I just write time stamps in a text file then use a groovy script to generate a script can be read by virtualdub, run virtualdub with the script to do the trimming.

It has worked for me for many years.

Re: Shotcut: Free, open source, cross-platform video editor

#58

Shotcut (on Linux at least) just doesn't work. I've used pretty much all amateur video-making software for Windows and some for Mac, Screenflow, FinalCut Pro, etc. The best by far is FinalCut Pro (Mac-only), because it automatically creates proxy files and allows you to edit everything in real time with no lag, even when adding complicated effects. The situation on Linux is dismal. The only good one is https://kdenli…

I recently used Lightworks on Linux. It worked fine. Quite a bit more powerful and hence complicated than the tools I used before.

It's proprietary and the free as in beer version is limited to 720p mp4 ("YouTube") export, which was sufficient for my use case.

Re: Shotcut: Free, open source, cross-platform video editor

#59
post #38

How does it compare directly to Camtasia in a real world comparison? For example with Camtasia, you can click 1 button and have your desktop + audio + optional webcam all being recorded to your video project, and then you can hop in and edit it with a bunch of great tools and presets. This includes complex animations and tooltips with doing nothing more than dragging around a few sliders. Basically you can get up and…

OBS is fantastic for screencasting: https://obsproject.com/

OBS is pretty much best in class for live streaming, but it's not a video editor. Both are much different use cases.

Re: Shotcut: Free, open source, cross-platform video editor

#60
post #21

For short video editing it is perfect. For large projects I prefer Blender.

Interesting. I had not realized Blender could be used for video editing too.

The problem with Blender is that its UI is completely different of the other editors. You'd have to invest a lot of time learning it.
Post reply on HN