Live data from Hacker News

I hate telephones

jameshfisher.com

51–60 of 449 posts

Re: I hate telephones

#51

I'd love it if my cell phone auto-screened calls from numbers not in my address book. Give them a special message that explains the only way they'll get through is to leave a message. Or that they can register their number in a public registry that fully explains who they are and then I can decide whether to take calls from that number.

Excellent idea, there's a huge market for new phone management apps it seems, what are we waiting for

Re: I hate telephones

#52

Sounds to me like this guy has an anxiety disorder that he's masking as a hatred of phones.

I have an anxiety disorder (GAD), so here's some personal anecdote...

My fear of phone is more among the line of "I might miss something _very_ important if I don't answer immediately." Unsolicited phone calls, and sometimes non-important phone calls make me very annoyed/angry to the point that sometimes I started yelling at caller over the phone. I know I shouldn't.

However, at the same time, I'm also scared of answering the phone from known or unknown callers since I _don't know_ what they're calling me for. Even such call is expected, I always assume they're to tell me a bad news. I'm fully aware it's absurd, but it's uncontrollable.

Re: I hate telephones

#53

Same for doorbell. I flat out won't answer the front door if someone rings it and I'm not expecting anyone.

People should send calling cards ("Hi, it's so-and-so, wish to call on you at your convenience") and wait for a response. Same for telephones (send an email/text message first).

Re: I hate telephones

#55

Same for doorbell. I flat out won't answer the front door if someone rings it and I'm not expecting anyone.

Same here. Anyone at my door who I don't expect is either proselytizing for their religion (looking at you Mormons and JWs), begging for money, or trying to sell me something.

Re: I hate telephones

#56

Sounds to me like this guy has an anxiety disorder that he's masking as a hatred of phones.

I hate phones and I'm an extrovert. I've cold-called people, asking for money, aka fund raising. So I know too well why strangers are calling me. If I recognize the soliciting campaign, I'll text back "How much?" But I only pick up the phone if someone's in my contacts. If I'm in the mood.

Re: I hate telephones

#57
post #38

Unsolicited or unexpected phone calls are annoying, but this guy has an anxiety disorder and should probably attend CBT or psychotherapy as it is obviously significantly impacting his life in a negative way. Also, text is not always a the best way of communicating- a lot of information is conveyed in someone’s voice which is often difficult to put on paper. It can also be way faster to speak to someone, particularly…

Have you considered not diagnosing mental illnesses in HN comments? Let alone offering "treatment advice" on a case you know nothing about, without having spoken to the person in question?

He spent the best part of a day compiling a spreadsheet of possible answers to a conversation, the wrote a lengthy blog post telling us about it. That is not normal.

Re: I hate telephones

#58

I hate telephones too, and I DON'T have an anxiety disorder please!!! I'm just not the guy always ready for a call. I rarely pick up the phone or open the door for a unknown call, and yes it can create stress. Quite often I am very focussed and balanced, one call can ruin that state. If you cannot find yourself in this, please don't create a disease out of it.

If a ringing phone or a knock on the door causes you stress, rather than diagnose I’ll simply say: it doesn’t have to be that way. One can be focused while simultaneously not jumping at the sound of a ringing phone.

Re: I hate telephones

#59

I'd love it if my cell phone auto-screened calls from numbers not in my address book. Give them a special message that explains the only way they'll get through is to leave a message. Or that they can register their number in a public registry that fully explains who they are and then I can decide whether to take calls from that number.

You can sort of do it with an iPhone. Put it on Do Not Disturb except for your contacts. But that will block alerts in addition to calls. I do use that setting at night when I'm traveling. Otherwise I end up sometimes getting junk calls in the middle of the night because of timezone differences.

Re: I hate telephones

#60
Phone for me is an intrusion when it's not very close people. I tend to hate phone as well but if the conventions around phoning changed like, you'd systematically agree through messaging on a certain moment to call etc I guess I could reconcile with the dreaded instrument.
Post reply on HN