Live data from Hacker News

Min – A smarter web browser

minbrowser.github.io

51–60 of 75 posts

Re: Min – A smarter web browser

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not like they're trying to cram in a music player or IDE in to an Electron app. This is a browser so I wouldn't expect the load to be substantially worse than running Chrome.

And you wouldn’t expect atom to use more memory than sublime, either.

This is different. Atom is a text editor implemented in a web browser engine. This is a web browser implemented in a web browser engine.

Re: Min – A smarter web browser

#52

I tried this a while back, and the only thing I liked better than the mainstream browsers was that it doesn't waste space at the top of the browser and thus would theoretically be a good fit for e.g. watching something in a small window in the corner of your screen while doing work. But in practice, there is some crazy minimum window size limitation and thus it's useless for the only use case I would have for it.

Chrome `--app` mode does the same thing.

Re: Min – A smarter web browser

#53

Based on Electron. So this is Chromium, but with less features? EDIT: It also claims less battery consumption. May I ask some proof?

A. FUCKING. ELECTRON. BROWSER. ಠ_ಠ Just so I don’t get this comment killed, here’s some text calmly explaining that electron is based off blink, and implementing a browser in it is like using a text editor’s scripting feature to reimplement the cursor.

More like using the cursor to reimplement the UI. Like... vim and a million other editors?

Firefox has been switching from their custom markup (XUL) to HTML for its UI, and you’ll find that the web inspector in Chrome, Safari and Firefox are already implemented in HTML/CSS/JS (don’t know about Edge).

Re: Min – A smarter web browser

#54

Based on Electron. So this is Chromium, but with less features? EDIT: It also claims less battery consumption. May I ask some proof?

A. FUCKING. ELECTRON. BROWSER. ಠ_ಠ Just so I don’t get this comment killed, here’s some text calmly explaining that electron is based off blink, and implementing a browser in it is like using a text editor’s scripting feature to reimplement the cursor.

Isn’t Vivaldi basically that as well? If you do not care about the rendering (as in, making a new engine isn’t your purpose). Then electron seems like a good way of developing a browser.

Re: Min – A smarter web browser

#55

Based on Electron. So this is Chromium, but with less features? EDIT: It also claims less battery consumption. May I ask some proof?

A. FUCKING. ELECTRON. BROWSER. ಠ_ಠ Just so I don’t get this comment killed, here’s some text calmly explaining that electron is based off blink, and implementing a browser in it is like using a text editor’s scripting feature to reimplement the cursor.

This is like using web rendering engine to implement a browser, which is not ridiculous at all.

The difference from chromium is that the browser ui is implemented using the web tech, instead of native, which is not unusual either.

Firefox have been using slightly modified version of html and javascript to implement the browser ui forever.

Vivaldi and brave browsers use the same method as well.

Re: Min – A smarter web browser

#57

Ignoring the general 'Electron seems a waste of resources' (with which I partially agree with) comments: Requires 'Ubuntu' or 'macOS'? I seem to know a lot of Electron based apps that run on other Linux distributions or - gasp - even Windows. Clicking on the 'Download anyway' link brings up the GitHub release tab. With, among others, a file called 'Min-v1.6.3-win32-x64.zip'.

Electron main selling point is being cross platform.

Having it only Ubuntu/macOS seems counter-intuitive.

Re: Min – A smarter web browser

#59

> and get suggestions before you even start typing I really don't want that!

I think there is a dissonance between smart personalized suggestion and being against tracking.

Which is the main downfall of DuckDuckGo they use as the smart bar search engine.

If you want good suggestions and smart personalization you need to track your user.

If you don't want to track your user for privacy concern, it's all good but then don't give user a product like suggestions that will always be subpar compared to someone else that is for user tracking.

Post reply on HN