Live data from Hacker News

The Most Hated Online Advertising Techniques

nngroup.com

51–60 of 93 posts

Re: The Most Hated Online Advertising Techniques

#51
post #5

Be interesting to compare with how prevalent the different ad types actually are, how effective they are, and how much money they typically cost. Preroll video may be more "annoying" than Related Links ad units, but they also pay a LOT more and are probably more effective any way you measure it.

Speaking as a developer. You may be paid by the impressions but how much you are paid depends on the CTRs. Nothing works for CTRs like targeting. The more data you can share about users, the better it is for you. All this other stuff probably contributes to user churn as much it does to your bottom line. This is one of the reasons that a lot of apps ask you for location permissions even when they don't need it.

Re: The Most Hated Online Advertising Techniques

#52

+---------------------------------------------------------+ | | | | | | | | | Don't want to miss out on more great | I thin| |olution must be tha| comments like this? | want to use .. Per| |cro payments aren't| +----------------------------------------------+ | one day become| | | | -- we can only h| | SIGN UP FOR OUR GREAT EMAIL DIGEST! | | | | | | | +----------------------------------------------+ | | | | | | I hat…

Pretty much gave up on reading wired.com because of this. Too annoying takes forever to load.

I've never seen it on wired.com, because I use uBlock Origin and NoScript. You don't have to put up with that shit either, if you don't want to.

Re: The Most Hated Online Advertising Techniques

#53
post #5

Be interesting to compare with how prevalent the different ad types actually are, how effective they are, and how much money they typically cost. Preroll video may be more "annoying" than Related Links ad units, but they also pay a LOT more and are probably more effective any way you measure it.

Speaking as a developer. You may be paid by the impressions but how much you are paid depends on the CTRs. Nothing works for CTRs like targeting. The more data you can share about users, the better it is for you. All this other stuff probably contributes to user churn as much it does to your bottom line. This is one of the reasons that a lot of apps ask you for location permissions even when they don't need it.

Sure, but the same exact ad running in the right rail will preform vastly differently if it's in a modal popup.

Re: The Most Hated Online Advertising Techniques

#54
BTW, if you aren't familiar with the Nielsen Norman Group, it's worth visiting their other work. It includes Don Norman (jnd.org, Design of Everyday Things), Jacob Nielsen of Alertbox UX fame, and Tog (Bruce Tognazzini) who started the Human Interface Group at Apple and made many of the loved (and hated) interface choices in Apple products for years. A very impressive team they've assembled.

Re: The Most Hated Online Advertising Techniques

#55
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sometimes the close button even tries to make you feel guilty about clicking it, like : "No, I'm not interested in learning about latest cloud technologies every week [x]" Or the famous "Not now" meaning "Fine, I will bother you again later anyway"

"Not now" is something even Google does quite frequently.

Like when you go to google.com with a non-google browser.

Re: The Most Hated Online Advertising Techniques

#57
Also, targeting became much worse than 2004, which makes me doubt that all this "deep learning on big data" even slightly works. Everywhere I see only ads for mobile games, hollywood movies, consumer loans, cars — and I hate all of these things.

Re: The Most Hated Online Advertising Techniques

#58
post #57

Also, targeting became much worse than 2004, which makes me doubt that all this "deep learning on big data" even slightly works. Everywhere I see only ads for mobile games, hollywood movies, consumer loans, cars — and I hate all of these things.

One thing I see quite frequently is ads for items I already bought. Not like "oh you just bought a T-Shirt, well let's show you another great T-Shirt", no no, it's "oh you just bought this T-Shirt, well let's show you the exact same T-Shirt in case you want to buy a second one completely identical".

Re: The Most Hated Online Advertising Techniques

#59
post #13

One of my favorites: modal ad, with large "Learn More" button to follow the ad, and a minuscule "x" button to get to the content, as if seeing the actual content was an afterthought.

I always wondered why they even put the "x" there.

Re: The Most Hated Online Advertising Techniques

#60
Most of them don't seem to realize how nagging users scale so badly so that it gets the opposite results (eg. driving people away). Just think if every page out there asked the user to signup to some services... this would make the Internet less usable than using pigeons. Why? because nagging users cannot scale. An user might accept to click a couple banners every dozen different servers he/she visits daily, but what if everyone employs the same practice? And if we agree that it must be kept to a minimum, who decides what site can nag the users and what cannot? The answer is that the practice must be abandoned because it does not scale.
Post reply on HN