Live data from Hacker News

We just released VLC 1.1.0

videolan.org

51–60 of 61 posts

Re: We just released VLC 1.1.0

#51
post #46

The Mac OS X version is 64 bit, which means it'll work with 64-bit HandBrake. Previously you had to use an odd prerelease build. This is what I was waiting for!

cool! but still no hardware acceleration for OpenCL it looks like.

Video hardware acceleration has nothing to do with, and can't be helped by, OpenCL. I'm just warning you in case you try to write it and fail.

Re: We just released VLC 1.1.0

#52

No disrespect to VLC but I just did a side by side comparison with MPC HC and VLC player and the MPC HC player looked much more clear - http://i.imgur.com/Mc2oS.jpg . Any reason behind this?

I use both VLC and MPC-HC on my machines. On the lower end computers I've noticed a large performance difference between the two: MPC-HC can crank out 720P on my 5year old laptops without hiccup, but VLC stutters all over the place. I've heard some recommendations on how to configure VLC to be more responsive, but the fact remains MPC-HC performs better "out-of-the-box" than VLC. I still keep VLC around for anything…

Of course, MPC-HC uses GPU while VLC didn't until this version.

Re: We just released VLC 1.1.0

#53
post #48

No disrespect to VLC but I just did a side by side comparison with MPC HC and VLC player and the MPC HC player looked much more clear - http://i.imgur.com/Mc2oS.jpg . Any reason behind this?

Do you have any of the sharpening shaders turned on in MPC? I'm not sure VLC has anything like that yet.

The issue here is not sharpening, but the colour output space, and yes MPC-HC uses shaders to do it, while VLC trusts the GPU so far.

And some nVidia GPUs have a wrong colourspace output, which makes the colour to be faded...

Re: We just released VLC 1.1.0

#54
post #40

No disrespect to VLC but I just did a side by side comparison with MPC HC and VLC player and the MPC HC player looked much more clear - http://i.imgur.com/Mc2oS.jpg . Any reason behind this?

I've noticed a difference in quality also. I compared mplayer and vlc, mplayer looked definitely better.

Very unlikely.

Here MPC-HC, uses shaders and special renderers, technologies that VLC doesn't use on Windows.

But Mplayer and VLC use the same technologies, same decoders, and same output modules technology (xv, x11 and plain d3d)

Re: We just released VLC 1.1.0

#55
jbk - Thank you (and the rest of your team members!)

Does anyone have links to who I should talk to to volunteer as an Intel gfx hw tester? Netflix+Silverlight+Win7 is using GPU acceleration for video on my netbook, it would be great to have VLC take advantage of the same.

Re: We just released VLC 1.1.0

#56
post #15

I don't see added support for the Broadcom HD decoder that Asus is shipping in some of their newer model Eee PCs (1005PR). Anyone know if there plans to add this? It would really help out HD decoding on the low-end platforms (esp since the cards aren't integrated, so they can be bought as add-ons as long as your low-end machine has a slot).

Not precisely an answer to your question, but it looks like there's a third-party library working on support for the Broadcom Crystal HD, which currently builds as a xine plugin: http://sourceforge.net/apps/trac/archvdr/browser/branches/li...

I know that the XBMC crew have already integrated support for it. There is a github repo for the drivers too.

Re: We just released VLC 1.1.0

#57
post #37
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

(I can explain if needed...) I'd personally be very interested in hearing some details about this, if you have a few moments to write something up (or even paste a few links to some mailing list posts or the like, somewhere that I can do some reading).

Well, yes. First, remember that VLC is not a media player. It is a framework, like GStreamer, QT or DS. It works in the same way, with modules/plug-ins/objects that are loaded when needed. For the matter of GPU/DSP decoding, you have two choices: either you do a codec module abstracted and independent from the rest of the modules or you plug a special codec module to a special renderer module (and violates your clean…

Ouch, it sounds like GPUs are a royal pain to work with. (Also: this little bit of perspective makes what you guys do seem even more awesome). Thanks for the details!

Re: We just released VLC 1.1.0

#59
This is great. This Player is amazing.

I hope ATI will contact you to overcome the limitation you encountered.

By the way, Will the hardware acceleration work the Portable Version (Made by Portable Apps)?

Moreover, someone mentioned a workaround to enable the Hardware Acceleration if I have SSE 4.1 enabled CPU. Could you say how?

Re: We just released VLC 1.1.0

#60
post #31
post #15

I don't see added support for the Broadcom HD decoder that Asus is shipping in some of their newer model Eee PCs (1005PR). Anyone know if there plans to add this? It would really help out HD decoding on the low-end platforms (esp since the cards aren't integrated, so they can be bought as add-ons as long as your low-end machine has a slot).

Well, simply because Broadcom doesn't use the standard APIs, which means one need to do a special plugin for it.

Couldn't an adapter/driver for VAAPI be written? Their kernel module is open-source and now community (I think it's currently a 'community of one') maintained.
Post reply on HN