Earlier quoted context omitted.
The real story of what happened during the DAO to me seemed like fast, responsive, and intelligent leadership. They had a problem, they asked the community how they would like it dealt with, and acted accordingly. Saying the founders were losing too much money so they hard forked it is a gross misrepresentation of the reality. It's like a Fox News representation of what actually happened.
It's completely the wrong way to handle this. To me, this "currency" is dead. There is no trust, other than if the creators lose more money on a venture, they'll "convince" the community to reverse it. I remember reading and playing around with it when it came out. It was raw, bare, and frankly awesome. The base tenant was that: "The Contract is the Code, and the Code is the Contract." It was a programmers no-man's l…
How to Learn Solidity: The Ultimate Ethereum Coding Guide
51–56 of 56 posts
Re: How to Learn Solidity: The Ultimate Ethereum Coding Guide
#52Earlier quoted context omitted.
It's completely the wrong way to handle this. To me, this "currency" is dead. There is no trust, other than if the creators lose more money on a venture, they'll "convince" the community to reverse it. I remember reading and playing around with it when it came out. It was raw, bare, and frankly awesome. The base tenant was that: "The Contract is the Code, and the Code is the Contract." It was a programmers no-man's l…
If it's dead then why are you here?
I believed that Ethereum initially had an interesting idea. I thought their system had little rigor in the way Bitcoin does... but I'm willing to look over pre-alpha stuff for the underlying concepts.
Tl;Dr. Showed up on top of HN. Greatly interested in the concept of compute-blockchain, but dissuaded of Ethereum specifically of company policy/choices.
Re: How to Learn Solidity: The Ultimate Ethereum Coding Guide
#53Earlier quoted context omitted.
People are not meant to work in factories. They're meant to own parts of factories and other productive enterprises. Ethereum reduces the barriers to entry to becoming a stakeholder in value created by enterprises. The cost to exchange a token is 1000X less than the cost to exchange a security. This is an orders of magnitude reduction in barriers to entry and expansion of liquidity. It means the economy can grow in a…
Do you mean people won't work in factories but instead sit around and collect profits, or do you mean people will work in factories but own them cooperatively, or that people will work but not in factories but in some other type of economic enterprises, or what? And could you give me a link where this is described in more detail, including addressing various possible objections?
I don't have any links about this. This is my own view on an ideal future. I haven't come across any objections to it.
Re: How to Learn Solidity: The Ultimate Ethereum Coding Guide
#54Earlier quoted context omitted.
Do you mean people won't work in factories but instead sit around and collect profits, or do you mean people will work in factories but own them cooperatively, or that people will work but not in factories but in some other type of economic enterprises, or what? And could you give me a link where this is described in more detail, including addressing various possible objections?
I mean people will sit around and collect profits. I don't have any links about this. This is my own view on an ideal future. I haven't come across any objections to it.
This is what I am talking about. Ethereum supporters think it is going to make the economy into an anarchist-libertarian techno-paradise, but they don't present specific ideas and write them up so they can be subjected to critical scrutiny. You know, lots of ideas seem great until you try to work them out.
My own thought is that economics starts with basic needs and desires, like for food, shelter, health care, internet access, and so on. Today these are provided largely by small and medium enterprises, and people earn their money working for them. I don't see how most of these things could be provided by DAPS, and so I conclude Ethereum isn't going to make much difference to the average person.
Re: How to Learn Solidity: The Ultimate Ethereum Coding Guide
#55Earlier quoted context omitted.
Unfortunately it's not an honest portrayal of events. Disclaimer: I was a DAO investor. The DAO held 5% of my Ether at the time of the attack. Having said that, it's not as simple as saying: I support the DAO refund because it was in my best interest. That doesn't necessarily follow, and it didn't necessarily follow for most of the other DAO investors. I still held 95% of my crypto $ in Ether. I would have been happy…
There is no morality on the blockchain. As far as legality goes, I think the attacker is in the clear because what matters is the code and not the intentions.
Re: How to Learn Solidity: The Ultimate Ethereum Coding Guide
#56Earlier quoted context omitted.
I mean people will sit around and collect profits. I don't have any links about this. This is my own view on an ideal future. I haven't come across any objections to it.
>I don't have any links about this. This is my own view on an ideal future. I haven't come across any objections to it. This is what I am talking about. Ethereum supporters think it is going to make the economy into an anarchist-libertarian techno-paradise, but they don't present specific ideas and write them up so they can be subjected to critical scrutiny. You know, lots of ideas seem great until you try to work th…
https://www.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/61lg8g/the_robo...
You're right that there are no complete road maps written out. But proponents of this vision can hardly be blamed for not being able to create a detailed plan for things they believe will be invented. It will necessarily be impossible to predict exactly what form the future will take. Yet we can make reasonable extrapolations based on the nature of knowledge, and the role knowledge plays in investment.