Live data from Hacker News

Facebook activated my dormant account and won’t let me deactivate it

smashcompany.com

51–60 of 165 posts

Re: Facebook activated my dormant account and won’t let me deactivate it

#51

Seriously, after 5 years they still have your account information? Are they completely nuts?

On Facebook, there's a difference between "deleting" and "deactivating" your account. OP did the latter, in which case it stays in the DB but is made invisible to everyone else. All you have to do to make it a normal, visible account again is simply log in. Deleting is a different matter.

Re: Facebook activated my dormant account and won’t let me deactivate it

#52
Noticed that they've started sending me notification emails about things my friends connected to my account that was deactivated for 4+ years.

I was worried it had been hacked and activated by someone so I logged back in. Nope, so turned off the emails and "deactivated" it again.

Re: Facebook activated my dormant account and won’t let me deactivate it

#53
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

and at the bottom of the page: > You can also try other challenges to confirm your identity.

The identity challenge does not matter: you shouldn't have to confirm your identity to protest against the reactivation of an account you intended to close. The point still stands: OP intended to close their account in 2012, and are now being signed up again without their consent.

Of course you should. Else anybody can close accounts that have been purposely reopened.

Re: Facebook activated my dormant account and won’t let me deactivate it

#54
post #20
post #3

What would the alternative be? Allow anyone to request that an account is deleted? Facebook needs some form of verification due to the password being breached (and its great that they are checking for that sort of thing)

Requiring the same standard of verification for activating an account. Of course, they want to make it easy so it's unlikely to happen...

If he knew his password he could deactivate the account using the same standard of verification as was used for reactivating it.

Re: Facebook activated my dormant account and won’t let me deactivate it

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They aren't aware of suspicious activity because they think OP reactivated his own account!

So supposedly OP was allowed to reactivate the account without any hassle at all, but then to actually sign in ID has to be shown? That is even more ridiculous since that just leaves the account in a limbo state for no reason at all. Should have asked for ID prior to reactivating if going down that road.

> So supposedly OP was allowed to reactivate the account without any hassle at all, but then to actually sign in ID has to be shown? That is even more ridiculous

Try to think about it without all that negative mindset. Someone quite obviously obtained the (careless) author's password from a leaked user database of another site. They used it to log on to FB and reactivate the account. That isn't suspicious, because the last login IP address FB had is 5+ years old and having a different one now is not unlikely. Then, the author logged on with his IP address - which was suspicious to FB, because they thought the legitimate owner of the account had recently logged on using a different IP address (perhaps even from a different country). In addition, it took him several attempts to get the password right. Therefore, they demanded some ID.

Re: Facebook activated my dormant account and won’t let me deactivate it

#56
post #51

Seriously, after 5 years they still have your account information? Are they completely nuts?

On Facebook, there's a difference between "deleting" and "deactivating" your account. OP did the latter, in which case it stays in the DB but is made invisible to everyone else. All you have to do to make it a normal, visible account again is simply log in. Deleting is a different matter.

I deactivated my account in 2010. At that point in time the only option was deactivating the account. Not sure what I should do now.

Re: Facebook activated my dormant account and won’t let me deactivate it

#57
I'd say upload some crap as the photo id and let the minions deactivate your account for 'abuse'

Edit: just saw that was done. Let them play their stupid game like they're important.

Does power hungry Mr Z thinks he's some kind of police to ask for a photo id?

Re: Facebook activated my dormant account and won’t let me deactivate it

#58
This is concerning since I had assumed the data contained in 'inactive' accounts would eventually be deleted. I closed my own account in 2011 because I found no benefit to having one. Given how difficult it was to close my account the first time around, I'm now expecting to receive a similar email. Why would they hold onto all this data for years after the account was closed? They're not going to be able to glean anything else from it.

If necessary, I'll pull a Data Protection Act request on these goons.

Re: Facebook activated my dormant account and won’t let me deactivate it

#59
Yet another situation that proves it's not reasonable to let users keep their account information/data for an extended period of time when they don't use the service.

FB should provide backup/restore functionality for account data and delete accounts after N months of inactivity. They should require e-mail confirmation for logins after N weeks of inactivity and any suspicious logins. The author of the article is lucky that he still owns his geocities.com e-mail address, many such old domains have been sold and re-used.

Inactive/Dead accounts are useful for bragging with account numbers, but for users they're just a risk and burden.

Re: Facebook activated my dormant account and won’t let me deactivate it

#60
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The identity challenge does not matter: you shouldn't have to confirm your identity to protest against the reactivation of an account you intended to close. The point still stands: OP intended to close their account in 2012, and are now being signed up again without their consent.

Of course you should. Else anybody can close accounts that have been purposely reopened.

No. Instead of reopening account on a whim require id when account is being reopened.
Post reply on HN