Live data from Hacker News

Asking for Feedback on Our Startup: Coordinatr.com

coordinatr.com

51–60 of 95 posts

Re: Asking for Feedback on Our Startup: Coordinatr.com

#51
post #37

i like it more than evite for sure. there are some little issues but i am sure you will work those out. some of the UE needs work like adding info to the profile. no biggies though. i am looking forward to see how the event ID can be use to show fotos, vids, friends, etc.

Thanks for the feedback! What exactly did you not like about adding info to the profile? Any other suggestions you can make?

Let us know what you think of the sharespace page once you get some content tagged.

Re: Asking for Feedback on Our Startup: Coordinatr.com

#52

PG says to get your site out early and often, so thats what we're trying to do. We're far from finished, but feel its about time to take the ultimate test, and show the news.yc crowd. Our Site: http://coordinatr.com is a site designed to give you the necessary tools to quickly and effectively coordinate plans with your friends, without any unnecessary garbage to slow you down. Check out our FAQ for more info: http://…

Congratulations on all your hard work. It's a nice looking, easy to use site. That said, here are a few issues. 1) It has a very silly name. The whole fad of misspelled words has run is course. I think it automatically associates your site with the whole concept of "yet another web2ish site", which simply won't last forever. 2) There is a serious lack of screenshots on the page. Show me what you do and how you do it,…

Not supporting Unicode or non-American addresses is not necessarily a mistake. It depends on who your target audience is. I know, it sucks for the rest of the world, but maybe it just encourages international startups.

Re: Asking for Feedback on Our Startup: Coordinatr.com

#53
post #50
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not sure how we would integrate with twitter. What are you thinking we could share between the two?

allow me to be alerted of events i am invited to, rsvp to events, and create events over sms, let all of my twitter friends see that I am attending X event could be a good way to spread virally if people see in their twitter feed 'susie is attending X ( coordinator.com/event/X )' doesn't necessarily have to be twitter just some kind of sms integration would be nice if u really want to be the evite of small events, i…

Good points, and we're building out sms as we go. We already have the infrastructure to accept input on specific events so we'll be turning that on in the not-to-distant future. Creating events from sms is a little more tricky...

Re: Asking for Feedback on Our Startup: Coordinatr.com

#54
1. Your name is so 2006. By choosing this name you immediately set yourself up as an also-ran instead of an innovator.

2. The first thing you did was ask me for e-mail and password. You did not give me a chance to try out your service. You did not give me a chance to see what it's about. You were unable to get me to type in my e-mail.

3. Your site is all about people and social events -- why are you using business-speak to sell it? Micro-events? Would a teenager or a college kid think that a "micro-event" is a cool place to be?

4. I didn't think your site was ugly until I read your "faq" asking why the site was so ugly. Then I was like .. hmm .. I think he's right ...

5. What determines if a user will switch from an existing system to a new system? if (valueAddFromNewSystem - painOfSwitchingToNewSystem) > (valueFromOldSystem * lazinessMultiplier), then people will switch. You have no control over the values of valueFromOldSystem or lazinessMultiplier. Here's my question to you: How do you think you are doing on the values of valueAddFromNewSystem and painOfSwitchingToNewSystem?

Re: Asking for Feedback on Our Startup: Coordinatr.com

#55
The site looks good. I don't know if these things were covered already, but I went through and made a list of things that I would change. I sent it to you on the "Feedback" form too.

Notes on Coordinator:

Home page after login: Text says "Sorry, you currently don't have any events listed."

No reason to be sorry. I would change to: "No events listed (or, You haven't planned anything yet!). Click here to add an event!" or something that provides a way to change the fact that there are not yet any events.

On creating an event: The date box doesn't have a default date shown. I can't see what today is. Maybe make the current day show up a different color or have days in the past grayed out.

On friends: Longer names get extended past the box representing friends, instead of wrapping or adjusting.

Contact Us link at the bottom of the page should bring me to a page with forms to fill out, not attempt to open outlook or whatever program I use for email. If I want to email you with these, provide your email address on the "Contact Us" page.

Last thing, the pages don't have a "What's next" button. Meaning, After I add friends, I'm brought back to the page to invite more friends. There's no "Thanks for adding friends. We'll let you know when they accept. Here's the button to go back to the home page."

Re: Asking for Feedback on Our Startup: Coordinatr.com

#56

The site looks good. I don't know if these things were covered already, but I went through and made a list of things that I would change. I sent it to you on the "Feedback" form too. Notes on Coordinator: Home page after login: Text says "Sorry, you currently don't have any events listed." No reason to be sorry. I would change to: "No events listed (or, You haven't planned anything yet!). Click here to add an event!"…

Just read your feedback from the site, but thanks for the follow up! The calendar stuff is getting fixed ASAP, as are the friend names. We will be following up on the other items in the coming week.

Thanks again for taking the time to provide your input. Please let us know if you have any other suggestions as you continue to use the site.

Re: Asking for Feedback on Our Startup: Coordinatr.com

#57
post #5

I like the instant feeback thing on the left - very slick! My only complaint is that it forces you to sign up if you want to view the event details. I can do this with Facebook already. I'd like to see more details in the "You're invited..." email. That way I could invite people like my parents (who vaguely understand email, but not how to sign up for this kind of service) to quick & easy events. Forcing a sign up to…

Yeah i like that and think it keeps out of the users way.

Re: Asking for Feedback on Our Startup: Coordinatr.com

#58
post #4

Here's a way you could get people to start inviting without registering. You let them go through the whole thing, and add their own address at the end. They hit send, but the mail to the other people doesn't actually go out until they've finished the registration. That way, they're more invested in actually going through with it than if they have to register to even get in.

Yeah I would like to see more of the site and service before I have to register. Could there be a test event area that shows the comments, photos, and all that and perhaps lets the guest add comments and such... this could be reset every hour, but quickly give me a better idea of the site.

Re: Asking for Feedback on Our Startup: Coordinatr.com

#59
post #4

Here's a way you could get people to start inviting without registering. You let them go through the whole thing, and add their own address at the end. They hit send, but the mail to the other people doesn't actually go out until they've finished the registration. That way, they're more invested in actually going through with it than if they have to register to even get in.

Yeah I would like to see more of the site and service before I have to register. Could there be a test event area that shows the comments, photos, and all that and perhaps lets the guest add comments and such... this could be reset every hour, but quickly give me a better idea of the site.

Re: Asking for Feedback on Our Startup: Coordinatr.com

#60
post #49

You spelled "coordinator" wrong

wow...thanks...that's really embarrassing...

Ha, I’m sorry. The name annoyed me too. However, keep in mind that the average web user probably has only heard of one “noun+r” website: Flickr. If you can withstand the heckling from the in-crowd, you probably don’t need to change your name, unless you think up something awesome.
Post reply on HN