Earlier quoted context omitted.
Jason, it be better served if you address the original points rather than side step them..
What's the point of responding if the trolls just vote you down? see: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1176362 This is becoming sad. Really... some folks need to get a life.
I think it's time to weigh in with the question I have asked you in just about every thread
When are we going to see the noindexing you promised?
From the latest round of commentary looks like some were implemented for a bit - then removed. Which now looks somewhat worse for you... (IMO anyway).
Still not hopeful of an answer though...