Live data from Hacker News

US transportation secretary announces drone registration requirement

transportation.gov

51–59 of 59 posts

Re: US transportation secretary announces drone registration requirement

#51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think that quadcopters used for FPV racing generally don't appear in the areas where drone identification would be a need.

I agree, but others may not... White House lawn anyone?

Because of those others we have this problem in the first place.

Re: US transportation secretary announces drone registration requirement

#52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Mid-tier stuff would be a world like Amateur Radio - modernized to be online or something as you've suggested. I generally agree with you, but I want to vent out about that amateur radio bit. Going on-line is something that makes it meaningless. Doing radio over real radio waves is playing with the limits physics throws at you. Doing it over the Internet is just throwing logs under your own feet because Skype isn't…

What I meant to suggest was that mid tier applications should be regulated like amateur radio; strict rules about what takes place, but anything goes within those confines. By online I meant the testing process could be done online.

Ah, I see :). Thanks for clarifying.

Re: US transportation secretary announces drone registration requirement

#53

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, we should regulate drones. Thing is, no one really flies "drones". People are just flying RC helicopters. But we call them drones and associate them with flying death machines and suddenly everyone is scared. RC has been around for the better part of 60 years and it's never caused a major problem. The only difference between then and now is that now they are much more controllable and a little cheaper, and so m…

Why would this make people turn to DIY kits? DIY drones also have to be registered.

That won't be enforceable.

Re: US transportation secretary announces drone registration requirement

#55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why would this make people turn to DIY kits? DIY drones also have to be registered.

That won't be enforceable.

I don't see why not. If an unlicensed drone is found operating off of the owner's private property, it's confiscated. Straightforward enforcement.

Re: US transportation secretary announces drone registration requirement

#56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That won't be enforceable.

I don't see why not. If an unlicensed drone is found operating off of the owner's private property, it's confiscated. Straightforward enforcement.

It's slightly more complicated, seeing as how shooting them down with nets is a bit difficult (although we may see widespread application of serious DEATH RAYS, excuse me, lasers for that (hey, I want the future that was promised to me in the '60s to come to pass)). There's also the ECM approach, or maybe even EMP.

Rather, follow the drone until it lands. If the owner is stupid enough to bring it back to him, you can go quite a bit further.

Re: US transportation secretary announces drone registration requirement

#57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That won't be enforceable.

I don't see why not. If an unlicensed drone is found operating off of the owner's private property, it's confiscated. Straightforward enforcement.

How would you find the drone owner and/or operator, exactly? I can see this being used to further erode the right to not be stopped and frisked without probable cause. Now, a drone flying overhead in a public place is probable cause to stop and search everybody in sight.

Re: US transportation secretary announces drone registration requirement

#58
post #23

Also https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10406261 .

That article was rumor/speculation a couple of days before this (the actual announcement). Good discussion in both places, but this one has the better info - thanks for keeping this one up.

Yes. When a developing story has significant new information, we don't count follow-ups as dupes.

Re: US transportation secretary announces drone registration requirement

#59
post #3

Drones should be licensed and/or registered, much the same way as cars are. There are places where you can drive an unregistered car without a driver's license. And that will be true of drones as well. There will be places where you can fly them unlimited. Just not in the common space defined by the government as such. That's what the government is for. "Drone ranch" here we come. I am a private pilot, so I appreciat…

> Also I think drones are super cool and access to them should be easy. But not free. Why not free? Surely their use should be regulated on the basis of scope and competency rather than cost. Use of drones in personal airspace ( a few metres above one's land ) within the boundaries of one's property should not be the concern of the Government. This would be the equivalent of driving an unlicensed car on one's propert…

Agreed. But it takes money to run testing. So that's really where I was going. If the barrier to entry is a $40 online quiz, is that going to stop anyone? Not likely. But it would allow the government to pay for that online curriculum.
Post reply on HN