Live data from Hacker News

Someone bought 'Google.com' from Google for one minute

finance.yahoo.com

51–60 of 100 posts

Re: Someone bought 'Google.com' from Google for one minute

#51

Mods can you please change to the source URL instead? (Not that I'm a fan of linkedin...) https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/i-purchased-domain-googlecom-... Edit: Here's a mirror for those that happen to have linkedin.com nullrouted in hosts or something: https://archive.is/HKPhn

We didn't do that earlier because it seemed like the current article added more info. Is that wrong?

Re: Someone bought 'Google.com' from Google for one minute

#52

Apparently this happened in 1999 with Microsoft's Passport.com as well [1], and again later with hotmail.co.uk [2]. While I understand that snafus like this can happen, I don't understand why the new owner would simply hand back the domain for essentially no compensation (especially in the case of hotmail.co.uk - this appeared to be a clean transfer of an expired domain). If they let the domain expire, it's fair game…

[deleted]

Re: Someone bought 'Google.com' from Google for one minute

#53

Apparently this happened in 1999 with Microsoft's Passport.com as well [1], and again later with hotmail.co.uk [2]. While I understand that snafus like this can happen, I don't understand why the new owner would simply hand back the domain for essentially no compensation (especially in the case of hotmail.co.uk - this appeared to be a clean transfer of an expired domain). If they let the domain expire, it's fair game…

Hotmail.co.uk currently has an expiry date of 23-Oct-2015, only three weeks away. I hope they don't forget to renew it this time...

Google.com should be fine until 2020, but I randomly looked up some of their ccTLDs and a lot of them are set to expire in less than a year. Google.co.uk has only four months left.

I wonder why large companies with deep pockets don't just register all of their domains for the maximum duration. There are a few ccTLDs that only allow 1-2 year renewals, but those are few and far between. Most domains can be renewed for 5-10 years at a time.

Re: Someone bought 'Google.com' from Google for one minute

#54
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If a company can reasonably show they own a trademark for a name in a region and should be awarded a domain, registrars will give away the domain. There has been plenty of cases where even old domains were taken away.

You are not awarded a domain name simply because you hold a trademark. There is evidence that domains have been awarded to trademark holders after a UDRP hearing and the trademark holder contested the validity of the registration. Read the UDRP guidelines [0]. There is also the counterpoint of the case of Nissan Motor Co vs. Nissan Computer Corp [1] where Nissan Motors owns the trademarks but have not been granted ni…

> where Nissan Motors owns the trademarks but have not been granted nissan.com.

Just to clarify, Nissan Computers also holds trademarks but in a difference field of commerce.

Just like Volkswagen and Canon both hold trademarks on Eos.

Re: Someone bought 'Google.com' from Google for one minute

#56
post #55

On the 20.09, I received a totally legit invoice from invoice@google.com (99.99€ Candyclub - Bag of Gems). The sender is invoice@google.com, but no names, no other personal information. I thought it was somewhat strange, and reported it, but no answer.

It's extemely simple to fake the sender of email. That's what probably happened.

Re: Someone bought 'Google.com' from Google for one minute

#57

He never actually owned it. This was just a bug in the Google domains control panel. The source of truth (I believe ICANN) would never showed a change of ownership.

I wonder how common it is to have such a bug? I would have though the type of functions would be bullet proof.

Re: Someone bought 'Google.com' from Google for one minute

#58
post #53

Apparently this happened in 1999 with Microsoft's Passport.com as well [1], and again later with hotmail.co.uk [2]. While I understand that snafus like this can happen, I don't understand why the new owner would simply hand back the domain for essentially no compensation (especially in the case of hotmail.co.uk - this appeared to be a clean transfer of an expired domain). If they let the domain expire, it's fair game…

Hotmail.co.uk currently has an expiry date of 23-Oct-2015, only three weeks away. I hope they don't forget to renew it this time... Google.com should be fine until 2020, but I randomly looked up some of their ccTLDs and a lot of them are set to expire in less than a year. Google.co.uk has only four months left. I wonder why large companies with deep pockets don't just register all of their domains for the maximum dur…

The oddity of the situation is that the longer you register a domain for, the more likely you are to forget about it's renewal..

However, most big companies use someone like Netnames, MarkMonitor, etc, who simply wouldn't let a domain drop, even if nobody asked them to renew it - instead they'll renew it themselves, keep it active, and simply add it to the next invoice.

Post reply on HN