Live data from Hacker News

Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

news.ycombinator.com

51–60 of 61 posts

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#51
so for weekly planning I surely use paper. I use a pad sort of designed for this and then modify it slightly to make it last longer: http://imgur.com/vmoQhYG,6RKCKV7,EqJgFLr,6fJgCn3

For projects, future ideas, thoughts of things I might do some day, I use a notebook and designate a few pages per item. I also click in pages, printouts, etc for that idea to remind me of things.

http://imgur.com/vmoQhYG,6RKCKV7,EqJgFLr,6fJgCn3#1

http://imgur.com/vmoQhYG,6RKCKV7,EqJgFLr,6fJgCn3#2

http://imgur.com/vmoQhYG,6RKCKV7,EqJgFLr,6fJgCn3#3

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#52
post #25

Meetings! I always make sure I have a pen/pencil and notebook/piece of paper when I show up for an in-person meeting. Maybe it's just me, but if I'm trying to explain an idea to someone and they're busy tapping away at their keyboard it really bugs me. Are they making notes on what I'm saying? Or are they checking in on HN? Ditto for the rare occasion when I'm in a dull meeting with a laptop - it's really difficult f…

Maybe it's just me, but if I'm trying to explain an idea to someone and they're busy scribbling away on their paper it really bugs me. Are they making notes on what I'm saying? Or are they doodling?

But really, I agree that handwritten notes can be less distracting. Interestingly, typing notes on a touch-screen tablet can be less distracting, and the single-app limitation helps avoid external distractions as well.

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#53
I use notebooks and pens for all of my note-taking.

Pulling out a laptop is too slow, cumbersome, and not practical in all situations. My notebooks are slim and discreet.

My notebooks do not need to be recharged.

My notebooks are designed to hold ink and can last for hundreds of years in the right conditions. Physics won't change much in that time. Computers and file formats will.

My notebooks can be easily recycled when I do not wish to keep them anymore. My laptop is expensive to recycle and there is a non-trivial amount of materials within it that are not recoverable and must simply be stored somewhere...

A pen and paper is the most intuitive interface we have for recording thought. It's entirely free-form and adapts to how I wish to use it without any programming or maintaining complicated digital formats. It exists as a single artifact.

I won't be interrupted mid-stream by a hardware failure, power-outage and I won't lose my work to corruption.

My notebook doesn't phone home to the NSA (yet) or the cloud.

With a good method of organization I can find my notes without much difficulty. Sure I can tag, search, and sort through the streams of bytes I write out on a disk but I rarely find use for such functionality. I'm sure I can keep a database of my books if this becomes an issue.

My thoughts exist in a physical artifact. This gives me a sense of permanence and will certainly leave evidence of my passing when I'm gone. Someone will have to pick up that stack of books and do something with it. Digital files can simply be deleted. Time-stamps and some bytes in an archive don't seem to have the same effect.

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#55
post #52
post #25

Meetings! I always make sure I have a pen/pencil and notebook/piece of paper when I show up for an in-person meeting. Maybe it's just me, but if I'm trying to explain an idea to someone and they're busy tapping away at their keyboard it really bugs me. Are they making notes on what I'm saying? Or are they checking in on HN? Ditto for the rare occasion when I'm in a dull meeting with a laptop - it's really difficult f…

Maybe it's just me, but if I'm trying to explain an idea to someone and they're busy scribbling away on their paper it really bugs me. Are they making notes on what I'm saying? Or are they doodling? But really, I agree that handwritten notes can be less distracting. Interestingly, typing notes on a touch-screen tablet can be less distracting, and the single-app limitation helps avoid external distractions as well.

That's an interesting point about the tablets - I don't think that would bother me so much. Maybe my laptop paranoia is related to the screen being hidden... Not that I would (or probably could) look at someone else's screen as they type, but having a horizontal note taking surface seems less like you're hiding away from the conversation. Or maybe I'm just over thinking it now.

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#56
post #2

I have an easier time remembering things I've written down. Actually, that's not entirely correct: I remember more of the tohughts I had when writing something down. Which might actually be more important. (Except when those thoughts are "this is boring, please kill me")

I feel that the symbols we draw when we write on paper have more impact than pressing buttons.

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#57
I find that when I write things down, even if I never go back to my notes, I remember and process the information in much greater capacity. Sometimes at SCRUM I'll even write down other people's updates that I deem important just to solidify the information better. It doesn't help that my handwriting from the time of High School was virtually unintelligible which caused me to adopt fountain pens and a form of cursive which fixed it somewhat.

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#58
post #55
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe it's just me, but if I'm trying to explain an idea to someone and they're busy scribbling away on their paper it really bugs me. Are they making notes on what I'm saying? Or are they doodling? But really, I agree that handwritten notes can be less distracting. Interestingly, typing notes on a touch-screen tablet can be less distracting, and the single-app limitation helps avoid external distractions as well.

That's an interesting point about the tablets - I don't think that would bother me so much. Maybe my laptop paranoia is related to the screen being hidden... Not that I would (or probably could) look at someone else's screen as they type, but having a horizontal note taking surface seems less like you're hiding away from the conversation. Or maybe I'm just over thinking it now.

The tablet/phablet/even phone bothered me as much.

I had a manager always checking his emails when we we're in a meeting. It makes the meeting more painful for everyone involved, as the person you're talking too is focusing on something else.

Doodling or scribbling does not bother me, as if someone is doodling, either they don't need to be listening, or it helps them process the info.

As for someone typing the minutes of a meeting, you can easily tell if they are doing their job, or checking in on HN, so that doesn't bother me at all either.

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#59
Even though typing normal text is faster, noting by hand doesn't use as much brain resources so it's possible to listen and note at the same time. Keying occupies abstract mind to the point you cannot process words with the same depth of understanding. Thinking / designing is also MUCH easier in front of a plank page than in front of screen & keyboard.

Therefore I am working on an app for note taking:

A bit like if google docs had a baby with OneNote

- vector graphics/drawings created by freehand / writing http://write-live.com/d/dba21681-8d3f-4fbe-8b4b-e5c1983df934

http://write-live.com/d/8f9b7846-a7b9-4e5c-b704-dad9aa87d14e

- unlimited* levels of zoom http://docs.write-live.com/WriteliveServer/webview.html?d=34...

- draw on a tablet, view on tablet / web http://write-live.com/d/538254c5-7d31-41f2-83bb-bcd0a7cee7ab

Re: Ask: Do you still find any benefits in using handwriting?

#60
i still use a notepad for my daily tasks and random note taking. i feel like there's not a single good note taking app for phones -- most of the don't sync to other platforms or, when they sync, the interface is god awful (i'm looking at you evernote and your editor that works like shit).

also, i feel like whenever i write something, it's easier to remember.

Post reply on HN