Live data from Hacker News

AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

nelson.cloud

481–490 of 493 posts

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#481
post #479

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What if you go through a couple of hours prompting and thinking to get to right image? What is the cutoff to "lazy" or "zero value"?

What if you played Pachinko for two hours? Even if you won two dollars, you basically wasted your time.

So regardless of effort and result, AI use for image creation is wasted time for you?

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#482
post #463
post #8

To me there are different motivations to include imagery and some of them are just fine with AI generation. If the imagery actually goes to the substance of helping to illustrate or explain the actual content then it seems very superficial to reject it based on how it was generated. In fact it is kind of stupid to insist someone slavishly draw something by hand that could have been done an easier way. The problem com…

> In fact it is kind of stupid to insist someone slavishly draw something by hand that could have been done an easier way. That is not at all what the author wrote. They said they would rather see a shitty hand drawing than an AI image, they’re not “insisting” you make a hand drawn image. You could just as well use one of the thousands of free stock photos out there just like blogs have been doing for years before AI…

Or, more likely, they just lifted copyright protected photos from somewhere on the web without even attribution,

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#483
post #427

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's pretty neat, actually. If you use Gemini's Nano Banana with a photo reference, it's pretty good at keeping most of the things that matter. I walk down 4th Street daily and that's pretty much what it looks like near Berry St. And the thing I'm trying to remember is not, say, her athleisure or his white jacket. I'm trying to remember a couple with a dog with the man carrying a bag and a garbage grabber. This notio…

I think you would find learning to draw extremely rewarding

Knowing how to, perhaps. Learning how to, sadly not. But my wife is an artist / creative director so there’s some adjacency there.

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#484
post #482
post #463

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> In fact it is kind of stupid to insist someone slavishly draw something by hand that could have been done an easier way. That is not at all what the author wrote. They said they would rather see a shitty hand drawing than an AI image, they’re not “insisting” you make a hand drawn image. You could just as well use one of the thousands of free stock photos out there just like blogs have been doing for years before AI…

Or, more likely, they just lifted copyright protected photos from somewhere on the web without even attribution,

No doubt many (I don’t think you can conclusively say “more likely”) did. There’s a crapton of blogposts out there and no one has verified them all. That doesn’t matter one iota for the argument in the submission, though. And it doesn’t really serve as any kind of defence either, when we all know generative AI is trained on a massive corpus of images without permission or compensation, to a much larger scale and much larger impact. Go ask image authors and artists which one they’d prefer: having all their works stolen to feed generative AI or having random bloggers using a single image in a blogpost. At least the latter have a good chance of being attributed to their authors (and if they’re not at the start, they will if the post gets popular enough and gets backlash).

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#485

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Putting aside your desire to debate whether photography is art or not. AI jpegs are not photography, because no photons were involved in the AI halucinations.

There's no debate over whether photography is art or not, and that's the point. Photons are neither here nor there. The AI debate will be settled the same way and for the same reasons.

What does that even mean??

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#486

I just sat through my first fully AI-generated presentation. The content was as bland and straight down the middle as possible. The slides were all generated by a standard design - a mix of text blocks, bullets, fonts, colors. The whole thing was packed with information and completely worthless. I’m 100% convinced that before too long we’re all going to be allergic to this low effort crap, and craving actual people w…

same here. our org just hired a new guy and he just did his first presentation, blatantly AI-generated. he said everything that had to be said on the first slid, then wasted 20 minutes going in circles.

llm writing style sounds so wrong once you say it out loud.

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#489

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The most important thing to keep in mind, when considering AI images for helping to illustrate or explain the actual content, is that AI-generated images have a big trust problem. Take a look at the Google Image Search results for 'Engine Diagram' https://www.google.com/search?q=Engine+Diagram&tbm=isch In the first row I get two correct-looking diagrams, then a load of AI-generated ones. Three cylinder heads for four…

To be fair, the problems you describe existed before AI, though I concede it has gotten worse. What baffles me is why anyone would think it a good idea to post and host these images? What’s that upside?

No human drawing an engine would have called an oil pan a crank shaft. A thing that in no way resembles a crank or a shaft.

Re: AI-Generated Images Discourage Me from Reading Your Blog

#490

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Last Christmas I caught our municipality (I'm from Greece) posting announcements about Christmas events on brochures that were choke full of obvious AI-generated images with Santa Claus, deer, trees, etc. and my first reaction was wondering exactly how hard would it have been if they were to hire artist(s) from our region, even if it was volunteer work, to have them promote their work instead. That's what a community…

> wondering exactly how hard would it have been if they were to hire artist(s) approximately infinitely more hard, considering using AI is 0 hard.

And hiring and billing are nearly infinitely hard unless you already have a routine set up for it.
Post reply on HN