Live data from Hacker News

I deleted my social media accounts

asylumsquare.com

481–490 of 500 posts

Re: I deleted my social media accounts

#481

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> IMO, it's not "normal" to keep up with acquaintances and people from past times. Fully recognising that you said "IMO", I'll say that keeping up with acquaintances and people from the past is normal in my culture. Social media helps to make that more direct and easier to manage than the gossipy grapevine of yore. What's normal depends on your culture and context, of course, and I suspect that's not true in yours —…

if the goal is easier to manage and more direct, I'd argue it's not that important. Is your culture 20 years old? What did they do before? There are lots of things in the world where the work required IS the value. Think of a hand written note from your CEO; is it still valuable if it was their assistant and a picture of the signature? "keeping in touch" is not inheriently valuable; it's the effort required that make…

> Is your culture 20 years old? What did they do before?

Our people barely left our homelands, our pā and marae, for fear of them being stolen by pākeha-let governments who urbanised the rest of us into poverty.

Now that people in my culture are reconnecting with the importance of whakapapa for whānau, hapū, and iwi, which is a far wider set of people than just one’s immediate family in typical anglospherical thought, there has to be a way to reincorporate all the urbanised people who live far away. Social media, at least initially, provides that.

But thank you for your “is your culture only 20 years old” crack. It’s always refreshing to have the needs of my culture explained to me by someone from without it with an air of armchair authority, as though I or we don’t know what’s good for ourselves to meet our own needs.

Re: I deleted my social media accounts

#482
Has anyone pursued ADA accessibility claims against social media platforms? Their algorithms seem clearly predatory toward ADHD users. Basic accommodations like 'focus mode' should be required, just like other accessibility features.

Re: I deleted my social media accounts

#483
post #408

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This kind of comment always makes me wonder, are the people doing this doing well financially to afford cutting off all those "loose" connections with people like that? Because I couldn't imagine just destroying these relationships for no reason when I myself have benefited vastly from keeping them alive, even if barely communicating at all with these people. I think this advice is generally harmful to networking as…

1. LinkedIn. 2. Keep the other accounts, just in case. 3. How exactly are remote connections helping? In the Western world, for example, people you haven't interacted with for months and months in real life for sure won't help you financially. For jobs stuff like LinkedIn is probably better, plus regular chats on 1 instant messenger. You don't need Instagram to keep up with them.

GP deleted their LinkedIn account too.

With GitHub and Discord, these 3 are really hard to boycott for programmers (even more to publicly shame people for using them). And yet, we must dissent.

Re: I deleted my social media accounts

#484

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Right but it's not 20+ years ago. 20+ years ago when my family visited relatives abroad, our relatives would get to the airport and often have to wait for our delayed flight because they had no way of knowing and half the day would be lost. If your flight arrived early then you just waited. That was normal. Now we update each other over a web messenger, arrive at our destination, hop onto the free WiFi, then wait unt…

What has that got to do with social media? Instant messaging and group chat, I’d argue, are distinct services / protocols / products vis-à-vis social media. Strained analogies are weird. I like to call them sieved analogies, the other definition of strained. I strained your analogy and threw out the dross.

If GP has an issue with Zuckerberg => Meta, they might have an issue with WhatsApp too.

The "protocols vs platforms" struggle is more relevant than ever.

(I am surprised that GP doesn't seem to have heard of Mastodon?)

Re: I deleted my social media accounts

#485

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If someone relies on broadcast notifications to communicate, whether it be by snail mail, SMS, email, megaphone, or otherwise, maybe it is not really worth hearing? To me, it seems like if someone has so many friends or is so busy that they need to manage their life using this strategy, you probably aren't going to have much of a connection anyway.

Let us just say that not all friendships, even the ones that start out strong, end up having the same depth to them because of the loss of shared context (e.g. moving out of the same city for jobs, new responsibilities caused by marriage etc.) In such cases, there's still some reason for the two people involved to at least have a general idea of what's going on in other people's lives, and even reach out should there…

I find it weird that after scrolling through hundreds of messages here nobody mentioned blogs.

You would think that this one place where you would specifically find out about huge life events like deaths / births ?!

Re: I deleted my social media accounts

#486
post #38

This advice to quit social media is always a hit on HN. When I was 10 years younger I read the same thing on HN, was thoroughly convinced and quit social media. I even followed the advice of trying to stay in touch by email. Sure. Turns out that a lot of people I knew posted huge life updates that I completely missed out on. I asked them why they didn’t tell me and they were confused. They said the posted it on socia…

It’s funny, a few groups I belong to solely use FB. One group is for the preservation of weatern history and a friend digitizes and uploads thousands of pictures (if not 10s of rhoughsands) yearly. The only actual digital copies are on FB. It bugs me that he won’t archive elsewhere. The reason is fb is a commons and an additional backup would be a magnitude more work. I’ve offered to buy hard drives.

But Facebook is almost, but not quite entirely unlike commons...

Re: I deleted my social media accounts

#487

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What if I told you Hacker News is social media?

Rather like minded nerds than fear mongering, fake, AI generated, influencer, 'look at how amazing my life is', 'buy this', new age spirituality 'let go of what doesn't serve you' narcissistic brainwashing the algo machines are pushing. I like technology. I like making things I love and others can enjoy. I like when others make something they think is cool and love and enjoy and I can enjoy them too. That's why this…

But "Share" is just cruft around a link, don't you share HN links ??

(I don't really think that HN is not exactly social media either - since poster ego is de-emphasized so much (not as much as on 4chan of course), we don't even have avatars here ! - but HN sure is addictive ! speaking of...

Re: I deleted my social media accounts

#488

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>And finally: Ordering. Non-chronological ordering makes no sense, because everything is random (probably not, somehow maximizes engagement for users very different from me, I guess). So I can’t even scroll for the stuff I want to see. Does https://www.facebook.com/?sk=h_chr not work anymore? It should surface the chronological feed without reels and other recommended slop.

I love you! This does exactly what I want! It makes FB usable again!

...np, I guess.

To be honest, I'm actually disappointed in myself for helping fb retain a user

Re: I deleted my social media accounts

#489
post #304
post #189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Indeed and in the olden times a lot of these life events would have been announced in the local newspaper. But these days, I don’t even know where to even buy a newspaper, let alone make sure everyone is reading it and keeping up with local news. So social media it is, which sucks because they’re extremely edited and filtered out by the algorithm.

For the people who you care about, you can contact them directly and set up a time to meet to catch up. Or catch up over text or email. Or start a messaging group with mutual friends and keep each other up to date that way. My feeling is that if you only get updates about someone's life via their blasts on social media, you're not really friends. So why do you need to hear about all that stuff?

Right. You post it on social media to the exact same reason you would post it in the newspaper.

And you would have to understand socialization if you wanted to know why people published life events to the newspaper - births, deaths, graduations, marriages, etc.

Not everything in the world is for your bestest friends. It’s OK to not have close friends.

Re: I deleted my social media accounts

#490

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Rather like minded nerds than fear mongering, fake, AI generated, influencer, 'look at how amazing my life is', 'buy this', new age spirituality 'let go of what doesn't serve you' narcissistic brainwashing the algo machines are pushing. I like technology. I like making things I love and others can enjoy. I like when others make something they think is cool and love and enjoy and I can enjoy them too. That's why this…

HN, famously devoid of narcissistic personalities and 'look how amazing my life is' and 'buy this' posting

I mean, where else can I go
Post reply on HN