Live data from Hacker News

Grand jury subpoena for Signal user data, Central District of California

signal.org

481–490 of 618 posts

Re: Grand jury subpoena for Signal user data, Central District of California

#481

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It's an answer to the question of "Why do we see different representation of these groups on the height spectrum?" But we already know that, by and large. It's genetics. And the thing we know about genes is that they align very poorly with "races". It's like grouping animals by color. Then you discover that brown animals are bigger than red animals, because bears are brown and bears are big whereas cardinals are re…

But there are groupings of people by genetic markers which correlate to linguistic/cultural origin. These aren't "races" per se but they are a valid and interesting taxonomy of people. And unsurprisingly given they are determined by genetic distance, these groups tend to have a more homogenous physical appearance. When we're talking about IQ, asking "why is does it differ across identifiable groups of people?" seems…

>If you take two populations of otherwise identical people and then isolate them from each other, they'll diverge over time. Maybe the land is different, or the weather, and some genes are better adapted to one place or the other so they become more common there.

By these logic every form of life it's the same since all evolved from the same unicellular organisms.

And yet my cat doesn't have leaves while my plant I keep in the pot doesn't meow.

Re: Grand jury subpoena for Signal user data, Central District of California

#482
Whenever I read things like this, I think about Crypto AG.

Solid impenetrable encryption from a neutral and privacy obsessed country. All a careful front for the CIA. The encryption was solid as far as I know but they the CIA had a back door.

If there was a backdoor into the system somehow, it would be perfect to have stories such as the above to recruit criminals or even foreign intelligence to adopt it.

As far as I know Signal is 100% legit and deliveres what they promise. and I use it myself.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2020/world/national-...

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/feb/11/crypto-ag-ci...

Re: Grand jury subpoena for Signal user data, Central District of California

#483

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Freedom of speech is such a bizarre thing in USA. I understand citizens need the right to voice their opinion without fear of government repression; but citizens shouldn't believe they have the right to insult and behave antisocially to other citizens. Any kind of white supremacist behavior is not something to be treasured as freedom, because that enables their harmful behavior against other citizens.

Maybe try thinking about it for a moment instead of resorting to the boring heuristic of assuming Americans are dumb zealots treasuring rights because they are brainwashed. People like you need to stop saying things like "I understand citizens need the right to voice their opinion without fear of government repression" because this is exactly the opposite of what you want. You want views that you consider objectionab…

But proponents of censorship will argue that there is bad censorship and there is good censorship.

Re: Grand jury subpoena for Signal user data, Central District of California

#484

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The state can shut down anything in theory. In practice it is much harder in a liberal democracy to shut down a network where operators are numerous, interchangable and have low capital requirements.

like drugs, prostitution, and myriad of other small time victim-less crimes?

Is the fentanyl death rate or trafficking of underage girls harmless?

Re: Grand jury subpoena for Signal user data, Central District of California

#485
post #462

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>There are probably more trolls pretending to be Nazis than there are actual Nazis. "We are what we pretend to be." --- Kurt Vonnegut

Cute, but trivially falsifiable. Wearing a Freddy Krueger mask on Halloween doesn't make you Freddy Krueger. And to the extent that it is true, it implies that we should stop using Nazis as the boogeyman. Because trolls are going to use whatever will get a rise out of people. Best not have it be this that they summon up.

>Cute, but trivially falsifiable. Wearing a Freddy Krueger mask on Halloween doesn't make you Freddy Krueger.

That is true enough for most, but not all.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Gonzalez_(spree_kille...

Daniel clearly could not separate the Freddy mask from fiction and made it a tragic reality.

Re: Grand jury subpoena for Signal user data, Central District of California

#486

Beautiful. That's how you do it. I actually believe that law enforcement has the legal right to subpoena information, with a judge's consent, while investigating criminal activity. This is exactly the solution to that problem. These platforms should want to know as little about you as possible.

It’s a very small thing, but ~I suspect that~ “Unix timestamp” means they actually send the epoch number, without even bothering to do the conversion to Gregorian data format.

PS: I didn’t notice the attachement. Yup, that’s _exactly_ what they send. Curious whether the suspect could recognise their creation date and know that they are being investigated that way--and whether that exposes Signal.

Re: Grand jury subpoena for Signal user data, Central District of California

#487

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which race? The US interred Japanese people during WW2. I hear that we interred people from central and south America for the last 5+ years, too. We're not a hundred years from anything except gaslights.

> Which race? Are you actually serious? You don’t know which race the US discriminated against in the past 100 years? The answer is black people aka African-Americans (as well as Chinese but that’s just outside the 100 years) [1] You do realise that black people did not have freedom of speech for almost all of America’s history? The idea that America is some bastion of free speech is utter nonsense, when you consider…

Are you actually serious? You don’t know which race the US discriminated against in the past 100 years?

Japanese people.

Who got their expensive real estate in places like Santa Monica seized during WW2 and were placed in camps?

Re: Grand jury subpoena for Signal user data, Central District of California

#488
post #285

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Since several people are asking why the ACLU isn't what it once was, let me answer that. In 1978, the ACLU successfully defended the right of neo-Nazis to march in the predominantly Jewish town of Skokie, Illinois. This action reflected their commitment to free speech, regardless of how offensive the speech might be. The movie "Skokie" and documentary "Mighty Ira" are based on this event-- I highly recommend them bec…

Freedom of speech is such a bizarre thing in USA. I understand citizens need the right to voice their opinion without fear of government repression; but citizens shouldn't believe they have the right to insult and behave antisocially to other citizens. Any kind of white supremacist behavior is not something to be treasured as freedom, because that enables their harmful behavior against other citizens.

Can you define what “white supremacist behavior” is? I’ve heard that leveraged against African immigrants due to their meteoric success.

Re: Grand jury subpoena for Signal user data, Central District of California

#489

While I applaud Signal's response I expect this entire event (subpoena and response) will be provided as one of the exhibits to congress by the Department of Justice to justify their request that it be unlawful to provide such services. The DoJ will say, "See, here is this horrible crime we are investigating and because this company chose to make it impossible for law enforcement, with a warrant and a subpoena to get…

Nothing any company can do about that. Spying programs and laws will only worsen unless people really voice their concerns and elect the right people.

I think general public doesn't have anything against being spied. They are already convinced that it is for their own good and for catching the bad guys. They are sure they have nothing to fear.

Re: Grand jury subpoena for Signal user data, Central District of California

#490

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm surprised the FBI has tried to get a custom keyboard into the Play Store yet, or asked Google to add a key logger to the stock one. Sure, the legality is blury at the moment , but it's just a matter of changing some laws and then that becomes legal.

They could just product a service that masquerades as a grammar checker provider. Come to think of it, that'd be the perfect place to go to demand a wiretap - at least one such popular "LY" service already exists. I'm still shaking my head at what many regular users will agree to..

I’m curious whether there’s a big overlap between people that the FBI is interested in and people who care about grammar. That’s not a flippant response: I’m genuinely curious if that is part of a shift towards white collar crimes (which could be welcome) and more generally criminal psychology.

I’ve been watching _The Wire_ and Idris Elba’s character sounds like a good overlap, but he feels very unusual (in fiction)--and definitely too careful about OpSec to use that kind of service.

More generally, there’s a lot of anecdotic evidence between problematic behaviour and low-level spelling details: one that is apparently better documented now is a correlation between insurance fraud and whether you capitalise properly the name of your employer on registration form.

Post reply on HN