if it were true that indeed was legal to rewrite and relicense open source code, would that also be true for non-open source code? as in, could someone do a similar rewrite of their employers proprietary code and release it publicly?
Malus – Clean Room as a Service
461–470 of 566 posts
Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service
#462Poe's Law just smacked me upside the head on this one. Hard.
Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service
#463I bet someone has already made this service for real.
Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service
#464Is this a joke, or is it the real deal?
Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service
#465I wish we'd distinguish between bullshit and clearly identified things that _may_ be future threats. The linked post contains a whopping lie - "What does it mean for the open source ecosystem that 90% of our open source supply chain can currently be recreated in seconds with today's AI agents" It can't. Not even close. Please, do show a working clean-room implementation of a major opensource package. (Not left-pad) W…
Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service
#466Earlier quoted context omitted.
This unwritten distinction exists only to allow targeted enforcement in service of harassment and oppression. There is no upside (even if getting away with speeding feels good). We should strive to enforce all laws 100% of the time as that is the only fair option. If a law being enforced 100% of the time causes problems then rethink the law (i.e. raise the speed limit, or design the road slower).
A system that solves for absolute compliance in every individual case does not result in the emergence of a fairer society. There are numerous cases, both in history and in fiction, that demonstrate as much.
Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service
#467Earlier quoted context omitted.
It's described on the web page but it's by having 2 agents. One has access to the code and one doesn't.
Are they the same model? Not that it matters, I just think the joke is more fun if they are different.
Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service
#468Earlier quoted context omitted.
We should welcome more precise law enforcement. Imperfect enforcement is too easy for law enforcement officers to turn into selective enforcement. By choosing who to go after, law enforcement gets the unearned power to change the law however they want, enforcing unwritten rules of their choosing. Having law enforcement make the laws is bad. The big caveat, though, is that when enforcement becomes more accurate, the r…
To add some context - > Imperfect enforcement is too easy for law enforcement officers to turn into selective enforcement. By choosing who to go after, law enforcement gets the unearned power This is by design, in an American context of building a free society. By default, you are allowed to do whatever you like to do in a free society. To constrain behavior through law, first a legislator must decide that it should…
I think there’s a difference between the marketing brochure and reality.
Re: Malus – Clean Room as a Service
#469Earlier quoted context omitted.
I almost lost it, didn't realize it was satire until I came back to these comments
This site is not satire. You can actually pay on Stripe and it will create code for you. The site is written with satirical language but it is a real service.