Live data from Hacker News

The end of the manual transmission is near?

popularmechanics.com

461–470 of 875 posts

Re: The end of the manual transmission is near?

#461

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because they're not classified as passenger vehicles, so they don't have to meet the same standards.

Insanity in one sentence.

Indeed, it should be the actual use that governs this. If you use it as a passenger vehicle, it's a passenger vehicle. If you use it on a farm then it's a farm vehicle.

Re: The end of the manual transmission is near?

#462

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There already were a few before, but now Dodge must have done something "right" because there really are many RAMs around. Those things are so ridiculous for Paris, that I'm pretty sure they don't even fit through some streets. Hell, my father used to have a fairly common French sedan that would sometimes need a lot of maneuvering through the public garage ramps, and would barely fit in the parking slots.

In NL, a RAM can be bought as a company car, effectively dodging road tax. (50 euro vs 200 euro per month). For comparison, you pay 100 euro per month for a tiny car if it runs on diesel (these were 'green' and exempt from road tax 10 years ago). Or between 30 and 70 per month for gasoline cars.

Every landscaper seems to have at least one of them.

Re: The end of the manual transmission is near?

#463

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could you point me to the car manufacturer that puts explosive charges in their cars? Asking for a friend... who is myself.

All of them. It's called an airbag.

Seatbelt tensioners too.

Re: The end of the manual transmission is near?

#464

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The Mustang and Camaro were the size of a full size sedan today , if not bigger This is verifiably false with three minutes of searching, which I did on my cellphone as I sit by a campfire. As an owner of both a 1965 Mustang and a 2015 Explorer, the difference in size between these vehicles is comical. I've rented a 2020 Camry that was larger in every dimension. It got great gas mileage, but small it was not. 1967…

Perhaps I remember the mustang as larger than it was because my next car was significantly smaller, a 240z, but it is at the large end of the compact cars, which have been getting larger themselves as of late, as tends to happen. Actually, most the popular cars have gotten much larger in recent decades. In 2002, the Camry was much closer in size to the Mustang, still about 6" longer, but skinnier. I'm not sure why yo…

Almost all European and Japanese cars from that era are significantly smaller than the American cars targeting the same segment of the market.

Re: The end of the manual transmission is near?

#465
Have we properly considered the effect on Hollywood? No car chase is complete without the timely down-shift, the roar of the engine and (usually) the massive fireball when the villain drives into a wall. With EVs/automatic transmission they're going to have to think of something else!

Re: The end of the manual transmission is near?

#466
I always found it strange how people in the UK prefer driving manual transmissions, there's always talk of liking the "feeling" and "control" when driving, this is coming from people who are not enthusiasts and don't even like driving sometimes. 90% of driving tests in the UK are done in manual transmission cars[1]. Taking your driving test in an automatic means that you are not allowed to drive a manual[2].

After living in the US for a few years, I'd never go back to a manual car. I view driving as a chore more than a pleasure and I can't wait for them to be fully self driving.

It definitely seems to be more luxury cars over here that are automatic, and the cars for the everyman seem to still be manual.

[1]: https://www.wearemarmalade.co.uk/driver-hub/news/is-learning... [2]: https://www.gov.uk/driving-licence-categories#category-b-aut...

Re: The end of the manual transmission is near?

#467
post #188

I’ll stay manual until I go electric. Every time I’ve tried automatic transmissions I had the feeling that the computer was struggling to figure out what I’m gonna do (upshift, downshift, accelerate slowly, accelerate agressively?) based on the limited input available. It always felt annoying compared to the direct control with a manual.

Which automatic have you tried most recently? I suspect it’s somewhat older than you may think, because even moderate quality automatics don’t often have that kind of constant gear hunting anymore. The ZF Friedrichshafen 8HP was a game changer for autos that don’t feel terrible but also relatively affordable, and they are everywhere now.

Most recent was a 2021 BMW 330i. Before that a 2019 Renault Clio RS Line.

Re: The end of the manual transmission is near?

#468
post #465

Have we properly considered the effect on Hollywood? No car chase is complete without the timely down-shift, the roar of the engine and (usually) the massive fireball when the villain drives into a wall. With EVs/automatic transmission they're going to have to think of something else!

Thankfully heroes and villains in action movies always drive immaculately restored 70s muscle cars, so for the time being they'll be able to keep using a gear stick.

Re: The end of the manual transmission is near?

#470
post #466

I always found it strange how people in the UK prefer driving manual transmissions, there's always talk of liking the "feeling" and "control" when driving, this is coming from people who are not enthusiasts and don't even like driving sometimes. 90% of driving tests in the UK are done in manual transmission cars[1]. Taking your driving test in an automatic means that you are not allowed to drive a manual[2]. After li…

Folks are less lazy this side of the pond ;)
Post reply on HN