Live data from Hacker News

GitLab announces workforce reduction and end of their CREDIT values

about.gitlab.com

441–450 of 750 posts

Re: GitLab announces workforce reduction and end of their CREDIT values

#442
post #350
post #11

A lot of the conclusions they're drawing in this post about the "agentic era" seem quite misguided and some don't really seem to make sense. I have no doubt GitLab has too many employees and can benefit from being a more focused company, but it's tiring reading these layoff posts so chock full of buzzwords. I guess they're desperately hoping if they prognosticate about AI enough it will placate the investors.

The memo also says they're eliminating a lot of middle management tiers which has been a theme for a lot of companies recently. It's also been a theme historically. Really has nothing to do with AI. It's just the classic executive view that they are paying people who sit in meetings and write emails instead of writing code. Blissfully unaware that meetings and emails are how big organizations function.

Your argument doesn't make sense. They literally explained why they are doing it. They are looking to remove who can't or won't keep up with ai. That can be managers but also engineers. That's what most companies right now are doing.

Re: GitLab announces workforce reduction and end of their CREDIT values

#443

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You'd be surprised how far you can get with self-hosted Gitea.

Can highly recommend it. Gitea issues, PRs and actions all work as expected.

And they have a suspiciously well-appointed MCP server.

Re: GitLab announces workforce reduction and end of their CREDIT values

#444

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Can highly recommend it. Gitea issues, PRs and actions all work as expected.

My bar for self-hosting something isn’t “these base standard feature works”, they had fucking better. I get self-hosting got for security, compliance, and retention reasons, but for almost everything else it seems questionable for any use I would consider normal.

I self-host because I'm not training some model for free with our and our customers' proprietary code.

Re: GitLab announces workforce reduction and end of their CREDIT values

#445

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's literally text autocomplete. You can dress it up however you want but it takes input text and outputs the most likely next sequence.

> It's literally text autocomplete. You can dress it up however you want but it takes input text and outputs the most likely next sequence. Last year this level of ignorance and cluelessness was amusing. Nowadays it's just sad and disappointing. It's like looking at a computer and downplaying it as something that just flips switches on and off.

Ahh, are we there yet? Has non-deterministic computer use eroded your mind so much that you are starting to question the binary system? You know, the insight that computers are something that flips switches on and off is rather old, and I have heard it uttered (although slightly humorously) several times already, nobody ever raising any eyebrow hearing it.

Re: GitLab announces workforce reduction and end of their CREDIT values

#446
post #230

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's literally text autocomplete. You can dress it up however you want but it takes input text and outputs the most likely next sequence.

Reminds me of when microwaves first came out. Investors decided to go all in on "vibe cooking" (lit. cooking with vibrations) complete with microwave ranges (no conventional oven), until the public wizened up to the fact that there was in fact no cooking (Maillard reaction) involved in their vibe cooking. Took about 15-20 years but microwaves finally took their rightful place as a utility appliance rather than what t…

I like this analogy. Maybe microwaves put a few line cooks out of the job, but it didn't replace traditional cooking at all.

Re: GitLab announces workforce reduction and end of their CREDIT values

#447

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Calling it text autocomplete is played out and really just makes you look bad at this point.

It's literally text autocomplete. You can dress it up however you want but it takes input text and outputs the most likely next sequence.

Your brain is also an autocomplete at this point. Notice how you write each word, one after the other, flawlessly

Re: GitLab announces workforce reduction and end of their CREDIT values

#448

Earlier quoted context omitted.

there’s a familiar saying “Markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent.” i think that applies here as well. everyone (customers) want AI; investors demand it. it may eventually calm down but i’m sure many companies will be left behind and ultimately fade away if they don’t keep up until then.

I don't think anything is going to calm down. Models will only get better with time, not worse. Demand will keep raising.

Of course they're not going to get worse. That would be absurd. The rate of progress will slow down though.

Re: GitLab announces workforce reduction and end of their CREDIT values

#449
post #442
post #350

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The memo also says they're eliminating a lot of middle management tiers which has been a theme for a lot of companies recently. It's also been a theme historically. Really has nothing to do with AI. It's just the classic executive view that they are paying people who sit in meetings and write emails instead of writing code. Blissfully unaware that meetings and emails are how big organizations function.

Your argument doesn't make sense. They literally explained why they are doing it. They are looking to remove who can't or won't keep up with ai. That can be managers but also engineers. That's what most companies right now are doing.

Right but naturally that's not actually why they're doing it. In actuality, it's a layoff - they did not go through and analyze which employees are "keeping up" and which aren't, don't be so naive.

This, like virtually all layoffs, is for economic reasons. Of course you can't say that because that reflects poorly on your growth and makes your investors uneasy and yadda yadda yadda. But what do investors like? Hm? AI!

Oh! Oh!!! This is strategic, you see, so we can use even more AI, yes yes that's right mhm.

Re: GitLab announces workforce reduction and end of their CREDIT values

#450
post #11

A lot of the conclusions they're drawing in this post about the "agentic era" seem quite misguided and some don't really seem to make sense. I have no doubt GitLab has too many employees and can benefit from being a more focused company, but it's tiring reading these layoff posts so chock full of buzzwords. I guess they're desperately hoping if they prognosticate about AI enough it will placate the investors.

Let these people keep betting their companies, futures and net competency on text autocomplete. The future is bright for me and everyone else that isn't falling for it.

My comment is the autocompletion to your prompt.
Post reply on HN