Live data from Hacker News

The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

wsj.com

441–450 of 577 posts

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#441
post #63
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wikileaks believed at the time that Clinton was ready to send a drone to get rid of Assange. Between due process and a drone attack, I take due process any day.

That's an obviously absurd belief given he's in an embassy. The USA has done a lot of insane shit but that would be a ridiculous line to cross to eliminate a single "criminal."

Plenty of absurd shit coming true in the world in the past years. I won't put it past them.

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#442

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Very interesting. Because she was in the room that meant she sent the team to kill Bin Laden? By your logic and the parent poster's logic ~13 people aside from the President and the laptops and coffee cups were also just as responsible for sending the team to kill him.

Are you really questioning the idea that the Secretary of State had a hand in approving a CIA-led assassination mission when there's literally pictures of her watching it go down?

You edited your comment to change what you said. You originally did not say that she had a 'hand in approving'. Why would you change it to make it seem like you were talking about something else that you didn't originally say?

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#443

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Citizenship isn't usually relevant to prosecution, unless it's for something like treason. The US prosecutes foreigners for hacking crimes committed outside of the country as well.

This is bad. Because other countries might take the same approach. What if China, Iran or Russia will start prosecuting US citizens for posts on the Internet that are against their laws? Like critisizing Communist Party? I don't see the difference between US prosecuting Assange and China prosecuting those who, being infinitely malignant, publish illegal, misleading information about Communist Party or Tiananmen squar…

> Because other countries might take the same approach

They do.

> What if China, Iran or Russia will start prosecuting US citizens for posts on the Internet that are against their laws?

They...do. Well, not necessarily posts on the internet specifically, but...

And, in some cases, not just the “appear before a court with counsel to answer charges with some simulation of due process” way of addressing crimes against their laws. Consider, e.g., the fatwa against the author, editors, and publishers of The Satanic Verses, whose targets were neither Iranian citizens nor operating in Iran.

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#444

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Jeez, what's with the Wikipedia links all the time? People drive by, throw a term around, and leave. How am I committing gaslighting? Am I rearranging the furniture in your house while you're away or something?

I should not have said that second part. To break it down, can you please explain to me which war crimes you are referring to, and how they are related to the beginning of this thread?

Probably referring to those Manning exposed thru Wikileaks.

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#445

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Also wapo is pretty much all political propaganda of some sort now. It’s been getting worse by the day since Bezos bought it for some reason.

I'm betting you think Fox news is the epitome of news stations, as well.

No it is actually much worse than the WaPo but does so in a more obvious way.

Both are very sorry excuses for journalism.

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#446
post #433
post #239

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Russia airing the dirty laundry through a side channel is MUCH more benevolent than the other things (like blackmailing our world leaders) they could do with this. I don't think all of Wikileaks' revelations are from Russia, but even if they all are - and Russia had selfish motivations - it was a benevolent act toward the world. Truth is power, and revealing the truth to the powerless is never an evil act.

So you'd have no problem with your neighbor hacking and dumping your entire inbox online for the whole world to see?

There is a difference between individuals and governments. Public servants like politicians choose to enter the public space willingly, and must be held accountable and responsible. The only safe way for a government to hold power is via transparancy and auditability. Of course those to whom we relinquish the power of life and death should be held to a different standard of lower privacy. Having the government secretly spying on private citizens is such a disgusting and dangerous reversal of how it should be, and your comparison is completely off base.

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#447

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Also wapo is pretty much all political propaganda of some sort now. It’s been getting worse by the day since Bezos bought it for some reason.

Nonsense. The Washington Post remains one of the best publications in the US. I certainly trust it more than Russian propaganda outlets such as Wikileaks.

It is interesting that in Russia people who criticise Putin and expose corruption are often called American agents who are paid by US Department of State (Department of State is an incarnation of evil for propaganda) to weaken our country.

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#448

[clears throat] USA killed hundreds of thousands of Iraqi civillians and is now jailing the whistleblowers [cough]

Americans (and I sadly speak for all 300mm+ of us) no longer give a flying fuck about illegal wars or mass murder. There is no peace movement, there won’t be ever again. Citizens will ignore the wars and entertain them selves by rage posting about either the red or blue team

People don't want wars, but they feel powerless to change things. And these feelings of powerlessness and hopelessness are perpetuated among society and create a self-defeating attitude.

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#449
post #429
post #303

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The problem with posting "proof" here is that it's always unclear where to start. Do you accept that Guccifer 2.0 was a Russian agent? If not, then it's going to be a long post. If you do, then Guccifer 2.0 himself claimed he gave the leaks to Wikileaks[1]. Wikileaks tweeted the same information[2]. Which part is in question here exactly? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guccifer_2.0#cite_note-:5-7 [2] https://twitt…

(To preempt: I'm not complaining, I have lots of imaginary HN points) The voting on this is amazing. It's gone from +3 to -2 to 0 and back up and down a few times in just a couple of hours. It'd be really, really interesting to see the patterns of what else voters are voting for. I don't think this comment is particularly controversial (it's a direct response, doesn't attempt to interprete the evidence, made it clear…

Supporting Assange or expressing skepticism about the Russia narrative on HN is a good way to get shadow banned, but it depends a lot in which mod gets involved.

Re: The US Is Preparing to Prosecute Julian Assange

#450

[clears throat] USA killed hundreds of thousands of Iraqi civillians and is now jailing the whistleblowers [cough]

Americans (and I sadly speak for all 300mm+ of us) no longer give a flying fuck about illegal wars or mass murder. There is no peace movement, there won’t be ever again. Citizens will ignore the wars and entertain them selves by rage posting about either the red or blue team

> There is no peace movement, there won’t be ever again.

There's no draft, nobody feels any personal danger so they don't care - the peace movement of the 1960s was a direct result of young white men fearing the draft, deciding that made them an oppressed group, and looking to the recently successful black civil rights battles as inspiration to start marching and occupying places.

Now, they just fear brown people in their neighborhoods, bombings by people who dress funny and write in squiggles, and international pedophile rings - things that, if anything, threaten them even less than wars they will never see. Some of them fear that wars and mass imprisonment will end, because they're employed in the industries that supply those things.

Post reply on HN