Live data from Hacker News

Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

reuters.com

431–440 of 561 posts

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#431

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On a work computer? No there shouldn't and isn't.

This is Stockholm syndrome. Sure, you can enforce zero privacy on work computers, it will just lead to shitty work culture and lowered productivity.

I don't see how people using a work computer exclusively for work would lead to a shitty work culture, let alone lowered productivity.

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#432

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't think we have sweeping regulations about it, at least in California. Most companies I've worked at have a policy of some "reasonable personal use" being permitted. The concern is usually focused on the other way around: Companies do not want their IP on your personal machines. They can certainly look at whatever is on their own machines, however, regardless if it is your personal data or not. One large caveat…

It is even worse in France: if you code open source "on the side" of you work, at home, the company which employs you may claim the copyrights of it. I had to add explicit exclusion of this claim of copyrights in my job contracts to protect my personal work. That was a few years back, dunno if that was fixed.

AFAIK it's the same in the USA, that's why one of the first questions when interviewing with a company is to ask them about their moonlighting policy if you do want to work on a side project.

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#433

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a naive take on this. Do you think it stops with just metamates(lmao that’s what they call themselves) being surveilled? Nope. This is the exact type of thing that software IC’s should reject in solidarity. Being happy with BadCompanyX trampling employee expectations directly allows for GoodCompanyY to enact the same policies.

> This is the exact type of thing that software IC’s should reject in solidarity. Yes. Which includes quitting, en masse, from any company that does this. Meta ought to find it impossible to employ anyone with a policy like this.

I thought mass quitting in solidarity would happen when programmers realize how their work is used to train AI and replace them. How many quit because of that? Doesn't seem like many.

Apparently, money wins over principles for 99% of us. How is this different and how are we better than Meta employees?

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#434
post #357

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Couldn't have happened to a more deserving group of people. My irony detector is sparking so badly I think it's about to blow.

I know right, so much pain and horror has been unleashed in the world by Meta… I have zero sympathy for their employees. Someone should’ve said no to developing this tech in the first place but here we are.

Former meta employee.

It's not like people have an unlimited number of places to work, even if they have Meta on their resume. Many of my colleagues (and myself included) had struggled in the job market in the past before landing at Meta. If it's work for Meta, or suffer more tumult in the hiring market; it's easy to understand why many might decide to take the offer even with the moral implications. I used to bring up politics in the office with coworkers and many people are simply unaware of the consequences of the company's products. There are a few different categories that these people fall into, but the main ones I saw in the office:

1) Chinese H1B holders who are happy to be working in the US at all, and generally apolitical (or view anything as better than the status quo of where they come from)

2) Just normal people who are interested in their own lives and have never been trained to think about the world in a big picture way (some overlap between 1&2 exist of course)

It's very western of us to always be tracking the conseqentiality of our actions even when we're just the cog in a wheel at BigCo. I think that it's the right thing to do, but this sort of reasoning largely absent in eastern cultures, or even for some in the west—even among those who are well educated. It's kind of hard to blame individuals when they either are rightfully consumed by worrying about their own welfare or are for whatever reason not as seminally hyperaware or woke as we can be in the west. Growing up I liked imposing my political philosophies onto everyone; maturity is understanding that even objectively righteous values are only useful for the right types of minds.

On the contrary, once someone has truly been made aware of the ramifications of their actions; it's more difficult for me to extend my sympathy to them. I consider mark and priscilla to be fully implicated based on their exposure to the harm that they're actively, willingly, knowingly causing. Other employees may never get that memo, though, people obviously avoid political talk in the workplace.

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#435
post #226

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hint: it’s also fiction

I wish. Check out colleagues.ai as the Chinese equivalent of the programme.

That domain is for sale. This whole thread sounds like one of these "I sell ai agents as a saas and make 30k/month" stories.

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#436
post #429

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As much as it's funny to dunk on meta this type of surveillance is becoming the norm. Failed start ups are selling all their emails, chats, commits, etc for companies to train on. Most job offers now come with statements about how you don't have right to your likeness, or your personal network I think most people assume that's for photo ops, but ... Yea. I expect more and more of this. products and product features r…

> Most job offers now come with statements about how you don't have right to your likeness [citation needed]

[deleted]

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#438

Yesterday I was doomscrolling computer vision related stuff on LinkedIn. I hate it, but often looking for freelancing ops in CV. A video appeared in my feed of some South Asian laborers sewing in a garment factory. All of them had cameras mounted on their heads. Otherwise, they looked exactly like you’d imagine beleaguered sweatshop workers would look. Exhausted, dull expressions looking into the camera as whoever wa…

> Yesterday I was doomscrolling computer vision related stuff on LinkedIn

blink twice if you need help

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#439
So, back in 2021, I supervised a student project where we aimed to simulate human interaction with the browser. Obviously, we needed data on human interaction. After discussion, we ruled out collecting data from a group because:

- the project was time constrained, so hardly any time, and

- there were serious ethical questions which could never be addressed well within the allotted time for this project

So we ended up discarding the idea of collecting data from a representative group, even before we got to the point of asking "how do you do handle that ethically". We ended up collecting data from 1 subject. The student in question, indeed. He handled the data from which he derived heuristics that simulated the data. The collected data therefore never left the student's hands.

Silly us, we should have just not bothered and collected it from anyone and anywhere. Apparently.

In all seriousness, this callous and complete disregard for ethical questions offends me so very much.

Re: Meta to start capturing employee mouse movements, keystrokes for AI training

#440
post #354

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Idk in the US but in France you are allowed to have personal data on your work computer. Though you have to label it as personal (like creating a « Personal » folder or label and your employer can still access it in case of suspicion but he must do it in your physical presence and accompanied with a witness, generally a representative of the employees. So you theoretically don’t have full privacy on this computer but…

[flagged]

Ignoring the rest of your comment, what the hell did de Gaulle do to you?
Post reply on HN