Live data from Hacker News

The internet is an SEO landfill

docs.sendwithses.com

431–438 of 438 posts

Re: The internet is an SEO landfill

#431
post #322

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There’s an extension that redirects to old reddit.

You can opt out of the redesign in settings. I don't know how long that will last. Sometimes it shows the new one, but it's rare.

Yep, I’m aware of that. But the OP said they aren’t logged in. My tip was in response to that.

Re: The internet is an SEO landfill

#432

Earlier quoted context omitted.

More precisely ‘the web shown in the front page of google results’

Is Bing or DuckDuckGo not affected by this problem also? Just asking..

not much different, however it is google's first page that sets the standards for SEO tricks.

Re: The internet is an SEO landfill

#433
post #108

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Make it an easy-to-click report button and pretty much every site whose politics I disagree with will get a downvote... every article by a person I disagree with as well. The question is: how useful is that to the search engine, or indeed to myself?

> pretty much every site whose politics I disagree with will get a downvote If this happens to all sites, wouldn't only the poorer sites stand out? I don't see why one strand of politics would be significantly more likely to downvote.

The more extreme the politics the more able you are to rally the troops for report bombing. You can see this on sites like YouTube.

Re: The internet is an SEO landfill

#434

This post is just flat out wrong. We are not using tricks when we tell you to create content. We are telling you what Google considers quality. Tricks are for blackhats and they can work and there is nothing wrong with that, but what you are talking bout is actual white hat SEO that Google demands from sites to be considered quality enough to rank. And the "it's easy" garbage. Go ahead. Let us know how easy it is whe…

It sounds like you know a lot on this topic and have good information to contribute, but could you please read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here? For example, the rule that asks you to edit out the name-calling ("garbage", "bovine feces") is an important one.

Re: The internet is an SEO landfill

#435

I just wish search engines would let me block sites. There are maybe a dozen SEO land grabs in my domain that are trashing my search results and provide no value.

Google used to do this, but removed it at some point. As others have noted the same effect is achieveable with browser extensions.

I miss blocking w3schools, now i tend to append `mdn` to my searches.

Re: The internet is an SEO landfill

#436
Would suggest that SEO is just one of many tactics to acquire users. I bet that from this article - you'll get waaaay more customers for your early stage product than ranking on google would have gotten you at this early stage.

I used to be obsessed with SEO - now I realize that many companies, search just isn't the best way to acquire customers. I saw this - currently investing in SEO and moving up the rankings steadily because long term - it feels like a great source of brand awareness.

Re: The internet is an SEO landfill

#437
There are bad actors in every industry. Good job generalizing here. I’m one of those “bottom feeders” you wrote about to promote your service.

I’m sorry you got conned by a snake oil salesman. It sounds like your BS detector is broken. It’s a shame you didn’t do a bit more research to find a credible SEO service (or learn to do it the right way yourself).

"Good SEO” isn’t about “tricking search engines”. It’s about empathy for the user, and has a strong UX component.

If you're creating hollow content, or a poor experience otherwise, why would you expect users to convert, let alone come back to the site or tell a friend about it?

My SEO philosophy/approach is to gain a solid understanding of the intent behind a query/problem, and then create the best experience possible to address/answer that query. When you do a better job at answering the user question than the other sites out there, and your "UX metrics", (i.e. bounce rate, time on site) validate this experience, you're on the right path.

It's obviously more complicated than this, but that's where I start.

“Good SEO” is a long-term bet. “Tricks” that get you ranking on the first page are useless if search visitors bounce from your site once they realize your content is rubbish. Will AI-generated content create a best-in-class experience for a user? I have a hard time believing that it would.

Anyway, I hope you’re enjoying your free traffic.

Re: The internet is an SEO landfill

#438

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google used to do this, but removed it at some point. As others have noted the same effect is achieveable with browser extensions.

I miss blocking w3schools, now i tend to append `mdn` to my searches.

Likewise.
Post reply on HN