Live data from Hacker News

Helium Browser

helium.computer

421–430 of 561 posts

Re: Helium Browser

#421
post #189

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hopefully the Ladybird browser will become a viable choice soon

I hope that not. Or at least, get out of the control of the controversial person behind it. If I would put all the eggs on a basket, I will prefer Servo.

What's the controversy you are referring to?

Re: Helium Browser

#422

I'm less interested in privacy browsers that just use Chromium and then slap some chrome around it. Instead, what I want is a browser that actively blocks annoying page behaviors . For example, I want a browser that makes all text on a page selectable, prevents a page from trapping right-click, prevents a page from accessing the clipboard, ect, ect.

That browser is Safari, configured with the option to open all pages in reader mode.

Re: Helium Browser

#423

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wait, what? What did he do?

In 2021 he once rejected a PR from a new contributer, which was to change the documentation from using the word "he" to "they".

Was it an actual new contributor or a drive by PR by someone who has no interest in contributing anything but their ideology?

Because there is nothing wrong in protecting your project from ideologues who do a drive by PR just to further their cause.

There is nothing wrong in preventing your project from being used as an vehicle for someone else's ideology.

Re: Helium Browser

#424

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The last thing Google would want is the web to turn into a Chrome platform. Unlike with Microsoft or even Apple, their source of revenue is web, and they they are doing everything in their capacity for this platform to win. This is exactly why they open-sourced most of Chrome and almost fully finance Chrome's biggest competitor.

>Unlike with Microsoft or even Apple, their source of revenue is web, and they they are doing everything in their capacity for this platform to win. I feel like there's a missing step in the argument here. Yes Google's revenue comes from the web, yes Chromium being open source and paying for search deals are a hedge against anti trust, but why does it follow that they wouldn't want to dominate the browser space? They…

>But the issue is that Chromium as a body decides whether commits make it into the browser and the decision making body is an invite only group of full time Google developers.

Not if you fork it.

Re: Helium Browser

#425

> Helium is based on Chromium > Best privacy by default Sorry, pass... Even with un-googled Chromium I do not think these statements are self-consistent. We need browsers that do not allow Google to control the ecosystem. We need legitimate competition. So what, our choices are Firefox (Gecko), Safari (WebKit), and Ladybird? Personally I go with Firefox on most devices and Orion (WebKit) on my iPhone and iPad. > Heli…

Orion as well (by the Kagi people), not available on linux yet but there is a roadmap: web-kit based.

I liked it when I used macOS but now I work primarily in a windows/fedora environment.

Re: Helium Browser

#426

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree with you here. I want a viable non-Chromium browser. But even if that existed, I also think a practical Chromium browser is important to have access to. I'm a developer and I use the web, so sometimes I just need Chromium. I think that will continue to be necessary for at least 10 years. And I think the landscape of Chromium browsers is very bad. As a minimum, I want adblocking, low- or no-telemetry, timely s…

> I agree with you here. I want a viable non-Chromium browser. It doesn't look like you do. Firefox has worked for me across 7 different employers in the last 15 years with no problems, and yet you haven't switched to it. Actions speak louder than words. There is a viable alternative. You aren't using it.

You are making assumptions about me which are not correct. I am not using Firefox because it has bugs which made it stop working as web browser for me. I have had breaking problems with Firefox on every platform I've used it on.

On desktop (multiple Linuxes, Windows 7 and 10, and MacOS) I run into problems which I spend hours trying to fix, until I give up and go back to a Chromium browser. On iPadOS and iOS, it would crash when using arrowkeys to navigate URL history(or something like that, if I remember correctly. Been awhile). I had another issue with it on Android, the details of which I'd forgotten. I don't even use the sync features- these are just independent bugs.

Every time I tried to switch to Firefox, it's a time sink that ends with a broken install. I used Firefox as my primary browser in the early 00s through to ~2010. I tried to switch back every few years between 2017 and 2023.

The recent bad new changes (forced built-in advertising, new worse ToS, forced AI stuff) make me uninterested in spending more time on Firefox. I'm happy it works for you, but we are not the same person, and Firefox is entirely nonviable for me.

Re: Helium Browser

#427

> Helium is based on Chromium > Best privacy by default Sorry, pass... Even with un-googled Chromium I do not think these statements are self-consistent. We need browsers that do not allow Google to control the ecosystem. We need legitimate competition. So what, our choices are Firefox (Gecko), Safari (WebKit), and Ladybird? Personally I go with Firefox on most devices and Orion (WebKit) on my iPhone and iPad. > Heli…

I agree with you here. I want a viable non-Chromium browser. But even if that existed, I also think a practical Chromium browser is important to have access to. I'm a developer and I use the web, so sometimes I just need Chromium. I think that will continue to be necessary for at least 10 years. And I think the landscape of Chromium browsers is very bad. As a minimum, I want adblocking, low- or no-telemetry, timely s…

its not MacOS only. just installed on windows

Re: Helium Browser

#428

> Helium is based on Chromium > Best privacy by default Sorry, pass... Even with un-googled Chromium I do not think these statements are self-consistent. We need browsers that do not allow Google to control the ecosystem. We need legitimate competition. So what, our choices are Firefox (Gecko), Safari (WebKit), and Ladybird? Personally I go with Firefox on most devices and Orion (WebKit) on my iPhone and iPad. > Heli…

Palemoon still exists... https://www.palemoon.org/

Re: Helium Browser

#429
post #86

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What makes you think that Apple respects your privacy any more than Google and Microsoft? The marketing brochure?

Apple has released several privacy features, their slogan is “Privacy. That’s Apple.”, and they make their money from hardware. Even if not a perfect company it’s sure as hell a better bet than MS or google.

So it's just the marketing pamphlet.

Re: Helium Browser

#430

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I agree with you here. I want a viable non-Chromium browser. It doesn't look like you do. Firefox has worked for me across 7 different employers in the last 15 years with no problems, and yet you haven't switched to it. Actions speak louder than words. There is a viable alternative. You aren't using it.

You are making assumptions about me which are not correct. I am not using Firefox because it has bugs which made it stop working as web browser for me. I have had breaking problems with Firefox on every platform I've used it on. On desktop (multiple Linuxes, Windows 7 and 10, and MacOS) I run into problems which I spend hours trying to fix, until I give up and go back to a Chromium browser. On iPadOS and iOS, it woul…

> On desktop (multiple Linuxes, Windows 7 and 10, and MacOS) I run into problems which I spend hours trying to fix, until I give up and go back to a Chromium browser. On iPadOS and iOS, it would crash when using arrowkeys to navigate URL history(or something like that, if I remember correctly. Been awhile). I had another issue with it on Android, the details of which I'd forgotten. I don't even use the sync features- these are just independent bugs.

And yet I, and a few hundreds of thousands of others, have used it on all of those platforms. Even at FAANGs.

If it's only breaking for you, and you alone, you can see why the rest of us are skeptical that it really is that broken.

Post reply on HN