Live data from Hacker News

DOGE has 'god mode' access to government data

theatlantic.com

421–430 of 1001 posts

Re: DOGE has 'god mode' access to government data

#421
post #201

IMHO it's a bit of a shame that the productivity and efficiency gains that computing and cybernetics can bring to complex systems -- including government -- are always tainted and currently championed by anti-social elites that use them to break apart these collective machines. Bureaucracies are a common good, and it should be in everyone's interest to apply state-of-the-art system engineering to make them as valuabl…

Bureaucracy is always risk averse. Without outside intervention, they will always try to operate as before.

This is the point: A well functioning bureaucracy allows for repeatable predictable outcomes

Re: DOGE has 'god mode' access to government data

#423

So how is this any different from all the random employees who might have access to this data as part of their jobs? I would understand if there was this sort of scrutiny over every federal employee but as it stands I never know who has access to my data and if they can be trusted.

> So how is this any different from all the random employees who might have access to this data as part of their jobs? Are you asking why it's any different a non-American billionaire who has multipole government contracts having access to your data any different than Joe Bob who was hired and vetted by those same people unlike the other guy?

> a non-American billionaire

This is false.

Elon Musk has South African, Canadian, and US citizenship. Let's not play the xenophobia card.

Re: DOGE has 'god mode' access to government data

#424
post #384

Well, it is a government agency tasked with audits. Why shouldn't it have root access?

Your employer is being audited. An unaccompanied stranger wearing a visitor pass comes up to your desk. He says "Hello I'm the password security auditor, tell me your password so I can make sure it's secure" Will your company fail the audit if don't hand over the information? Or will your company fail the audit if if you do hand it over?

You've clearly never been audited by the federal government.

In the case of the IRS, generally, you must hand over the data they request or you go to jail.

Whether or not it's behind a password protected internal system is irrelevant. Everything is potentially material to any conspiracy to commit tax fraud.

I see no reason why the Federal government itself, which works for us, should not be subject to reciprocal treatment.

Re: DOGE has 'god mode' access to government data

#425

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This isnt a dig at you but something i have noticed over the last few weeks. People keep saying X/Y wont be able to do something because of rules, laws, requirements and i have to keep reminding people rules/laws are only as good as those willing to enforce them

fair point! i guess it does sound like an inept democrat lol. though you don't wanna fuck with the fbi https://le.fbi.gov/cjis-division/cjis-security-policy-resour...

The FBI reports to the president. They aren't going to stop anything.

Re: DOGE has 'god mode' access to government data

#426

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> IMHO it's a bit of a shame that the productivity and efficiency gains that computing and cybernetics can bring to complex systems They're just firing people at random, they haven't discovered any innovative new way to make systems more efficient. ("at random" is a bit generous and ignores the retaliation against political adversaries)

It's not "at random". Every shuttered department had been investigating one of Elmo's properties...

[flagged]

Re: DOGE has 'god mode' access to government data

#427
post #30

I find it wild that apparently there is no law onto which government workers can cling to refuse these requests. Is it all just based on conventions, goodwill and culture?

Why do you want them to refuse audit requests? There is no upside to hiding egregious government waste other than paying politicians via kickbacks more than what is legally mandated.

For auditing, you keep the data intact. you keep the people around in case if anything you don't understand or can't find

Change the data, Firing everybody , leave no way to contact them, this is not auditing.

Re: DOGE has 'god mode' access to government data

#428
post #320

Related to a comment on a now-flagged subthread: can anyone who believes that DOGE is uncovering fraud please post a reliable reference that gives a specific example of fraud uncovered by DOGE? To be clear, this should be a third-party analysis of some credibility, not DOGE's or Musk's twitter feed or "receipts" website which shows cancelled contracts with no clear link to fraudulent activity.

The claims of fraud are a pretext for going into the agencies and making the partisan changes they wanted to make anyway. There's no point asking for a detailed discussion because the whole plan is to use the discussion of fraud as cover for the thing they're actually doing.

I think wired nailed it:

"This is incompetence born of self-confidence. It’s a familiar Silicon Valley mindset, the reason startups are forever reinventing a bus, or a bodega, or mail. It’s the implacable certainty that if you’re smart at one thing you must be smart at all of the things."

"And if you don’t believe in the public good? You sprint through the ruination. You metastasize from agency to agency, leveling the maximum allowable destruction under the law. DOGE’s costly, embarrassing mistakes are a byproduct of reckless nihilism; if artificial intelligence can sell you a pizza, of course it can future-proof the General Services Administration.

https://www.wired.com/story/doge-incompetence-mistakes-featu...

Re: DOGE has 'god mode' access to government data

#429

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your employer is being audited. An unaccompanied stranger wearing a visitor pass comes up to your desk. He says "Hello I'm the password security auditor, tell me your password so I can make sure it's secure" Will your company fail the audit if don't hand over the information? Or will your company fail the audit if if you do hand it over?

You've clearly never been audited by the federal government. In the case of the IRS, generally, you must hand over the data they request or you go to jail. Whether or not it's behind a password protected internal system is irrelevant. Everything is potentially material to any conspiracy to commit tax fraud. I see no reason why the Federal government itself, which works for us, should not be subject to reciprocal trea…

Big difference between the IRS and random friends of the President. Congressional Acts is one

Re: DOGE has 'god mode' access to government data

#430
post #382

Federal level government is not a startup Breaking things will destroy lives if not literally kill people If it was this "easy" someone would have made a proposal years ago even if it was turned down And Congress, not ANY President controls spending We do not elect Kings in this country, there was an entire very brutal war to make it that way This data is going to leak if it's not copied already into insecure sources…

Well put and straight to the point.
Post reply on HN