Live data from Hacker News

Why Canada Should Join the EU

economist.com

421–430 of 823 posts

Re: Why Canada Should Join the EU

#421

EU needs to clear out its own backyard first, kick Hungary out... Orban has brought nothing but chaos and costs. After that, why not? Turkey has been in discussion for ages and is barely in Europe. Also, South Africa might be interesting in the future if they can see eye to eye on political and economic issues.

South Africa has currently so warm relations with Russia that Hungary is the only EU country that would not block its accession in this surreal scenario.

Re: Why Canada Should Join the EU

#422
post #401
post #370

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even my immigrant friends in Canada think there are too many immigrants.

Quote from a Chinese friend of mine form over the holidays (currently in Canada on a work visa, applying for a PR shortly, started as an exchange student in highschool): “I really like coming back to [jmb99’s hometown], it’s all white people. Nice change from Toronto.” Definitely a common sentiment.

I hadn't been to Toronto in years until recently. We went to some parks (i.e. Parks Canada / Provincial Parks) around.

Little did I know that you now have to register online to book your visit. You used to just go and pay cash at the entrance and that's it. This time you had to have an account and prove identity by logging in through your bank account for example, before they'd even let you purchase said ticket.

We didn't really think much of it until later on but then it struck us: All, and I mean, literally all of the people we saw looked "Indian" (some may have been Pakistani etc. but you get what I'm trying to say). We were actually taken by surprise at one place, when we saw a bunch of (non-Indian) Asians in one of the parks. And once we saw a white couple. The Algonquin was completely booked and overflowing. Like you wouldn't even be able to just park and hike illegally.

All of the Parks Canada staff was White or (non-Indian) Asian.

Re: Why Canada Should Join the EU

#424

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Astroturfing does not equal botting, although I wouldn’t be surprised if there were many bot farms active on Reddit. The platform is virtually designed to be manipulated now, awards being an egregious example. Here’s an article about one such astroturfing campaign from folks who do not share my political tendencies: https://thefederalist.com/2024/10/29/busted-the-inside-story...

It's not surprising that Reddit leans left on average, but what really deserves attention now is that the sentiment seems to be shifting in the other direction.

I am a bit of an oddball in that I believe all instances and forms of unrealized hallucination deserve attention (though not equal attention).

To be clear: I am not surprised when bias exists in hallucinations, it's kind of a defining characteristic.

Re: Why Canada Should Join the EU

#425

no thanks, we don't need the next thierry to have an expanded fief to "regulate". if anything, canada should model itself closer to the states with more personal freedoms and less regulation. there is a lot of land and resources to develop, the politicians need to just stop trying to maintain the status quo and aggressively try to develop all the land we have. the idea that we can't is a loser's mentality.

Your malevolent childs-ego-inflated-to-national 'winners vs losers' notion will inevitably, if not expunged, make losers of us all. My 'us' is of course unimaginable to your minuscule 'me'.

[flagged]

Re: Why Canada Should Join the EU

#426
post #388

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Canada could have imported as many young educated people as it wanted from Eastern European countries, Russia, former USSR members etc. What happens in reality is they can't get enough points due to some truly moronic rules. Yet somehow we mostly have people from other parts of the world whose main specialty is food delivery.

[flagged]

[flagged]

Re: Why Canada Should Join the EU

#427

Canada needs people? I thought the recent controversy is all about Canada having too many people and the pro immigration government also taking a more tempered immigration stance?

Canada does not have the infrastructure to support more people. Housing costs are out of control, healthcare is in a terrible state, etc. If those things were resolved first before bringing people in and straining the already strained infrastructure throughout the country then there wouldn't be nearly the pushback that is happening right now.

Re: Why Canada Should Join the EU

#428

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> it’s been a net negative for taxpayers This analysis[1] from the Cato Institute found the opposite: “immigrants pay more in taxes than they consume in benefits”. [1] https://www.cato.org/blog/fiscal-impact-immigration-united-s...

The House budget committee disagrees: https://budget.house.gov/imo/media/doc/the_cost_of_illegal_i... $150.7B yearly cost even after accounting for the tax revenue they supposedly bring.

The article is about illegal immigration while the rest of the thread is about legal immigration.

Isn't it clear to everyone that the kind of people the government doesn't want in the country don't bring benefits to the country? And if they cheated on their way into the country, what does it imply about their integrity and their future tendency to cheat on taxes as well?

Re: Why Canada Should Join the EU

#429
post #388

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Canada could have imported as many young educated people as it wanted from Eastern European countries, Russia, former USSR members etc. What happens in reality is they can't get enough points due to some truly moronic rules. Yet somehow we mostly have people from other parts of the world whose main specialty is food delivery.

canada is very protective of its regulated fields. if you didn't graduate in the US or Canada, it's very hard for an immigrant to become a vet/dentist/doctor/lawyer/engineer/accountant/etc. So these people end up in a rut where they are either delivering food, or stuck in an entry level job forever

From my experience those intelligent people who for whatever reasons can not get back to their original occupation still doing rather well in other fields. I am in Canada since the beginning of 90s. have many immigrant friends, most of them are well off.

Re: Why Canada Should Join the EU

#430
post #156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Canada has a population of 40 million in a land area larger than the USA. That's hardly "too many people". Too many people in a handful of dense urban centers maybe, but overall the country is basically empty.

> overall the country is basically empty. Because much of the landmass is uninhabitable. For instance, Nunavut is about 20% larger than Alaska, yet has less than one tenth its population - because most of the province is tundra. Even building a road through it is iffy - a city? Forget it.

Most of Canada is habitable. If you meant "comfortable to live", then draw a 100 miles radius circle centered on any existing comfortable Canadian city and see how much of it is actually developed.
Post reply on HN