Live data from Hacker News

I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

blog.joinmastodon.org

401–410 of 497 posts

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#401

This is an indescribably devastating loss for a project that, whatever its imperfections, can fairly lay claim to the most intellectually consistent and sincere adherence to FOSS, privacy, and decentralization of any major social media project. Eugene has proven a spectacular and indispensable developer, and I don't know that Mastodon has the ability to move on without him. I want to praise Eugen but the uncomfortabl…

Eugen*

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#402

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

Opinions like this give rise to fascism. You can not talk about how we want to protect children and where the boundaries are because some lunatics immediately accuse anybody of harming THE CHILDREN. If someone is romantically into kids this is not socially accepted in most cultures, but someone merely being attracted without following up with actions does not harm any kids.

[flagged]

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#403
post #357

Decentralisation on Mastodon is an illusion. For me a truly decentralised thing is where I am a node that transmits and can receive transmissions, like radios. When there has to be a server that's being administrated by somebody, this already puts me in a position where I depend on the people who own the server. This means that if for any reason these people don't like me, they can simply ban me and that's it. Basica…

Even Eugen himself set to position of labelling opposite opinions (1) and censorship. Fediverse, in Mastodon way, actually feeds social bubbles. (1) https://ibb.co/qY082NjX

That's what puzzles me. In the fediverse where you can mute anyone on the user level, admins feel the urge to ban those who they see as bad actors.

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#404
post #355

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Its impossible to think you agree with 97% of any group without assuming everyone from that group thinks the same way. Even people from just one country don't think the same way due to color of skin, if we were to assume the point is only about americans.

They didn’t say “agree with” they said “97% similar views.” This seems like a pretty informal measurement, and we don’t have much insight into what it really means.

Feels like a lot of y'alls feelings are getting in the way of what I was saying here. Slow down and read carefully. You all should try thinking about this in perhaps Venn diagrams or something.

There are Black people on Mastodon, myself included. In my interactions with them, to me, it appears as of the (very tiny) subset of Black folks who are also on Mastodon, I have observed and interacted with them on views and issues about the world.

Presuming, for example, they vote - we would vote similarly. We would support the same causes, we would likely react similarly to things in real life -- and yet...etc see above.

Point being, it's not like I was in with like Black MAGA or some other group who I'd be unlikely to associate.

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#405
post #313

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> interacting with Black folks with whom I share probably like 97% similar views on just about everything Maybe because you say things like that? In what world is people's skin color related to their views?

Of the group of black people, he found a group where he shared 97% of views. I think in the US there is 'black culture' and having a black skin, and I understand your point that skin color should not be assumed to be related to a view. But I don't think that's implied here.

was literally saying the opposite

that's WHY I said "with whom I shared views" and not BLACK PEOPLE GENERALLY.

so many feelings people get into.

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#406
post #395

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I used to make so much fun of RMS in the late 90s. Then I met him and my entire view on that man changed. He absolutely is doing the world a favor and it would benefit everyone to think long and hard what a world would be like without GNU today

He's also an interesting study in having principles - a purist approach is rare, honestly confusing to most people and actually rather effective in a Cassandra-style way if watched closely. Quite effective in terms of outcomes too, it's really deceptive how much of an impact he managed to have because the part of the brain that judges success and failure seems to key off charisma and social proof rather than doing a…

A few years ago there were some "personalities" that very much agitated against Stallman. Without generalizing too much it is these people you probably should keep a very, very large distance to. Toxic is likely an understatement.

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#407

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> liable for hosting all those federated messages. Mastodon do not permanently stores these messages. They are cached, and evicted after some time. I linked to a video some time ago, and now that link is unreachable because it's expired. The URL contained "/cache/", and I didn't understand what it meant until my video died.

That's true, but while they're cached, if someone else could see them , they're hosted, and you're liable for hosting them. I understand that Mastodon has a "local feed", and even if you're its sole user, if you don't block anonymous readers from access, that means someone could technically see a message by someone else that you're subscribed to, take umbrage at it, and sue you for making it available on your server,…

> Would it still be possible to participate in conversations, would people still be able to subscribe to you?

Yes. I follow several remote users who default to "unlisted" posts. (To be honest, I don't know if they're unlisted or follower-only posts -- I can't tell.)

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#408

Looks like the inmates won again: Without linking to the posts, Rochko also mentioned that “a particularly bad interaction with a user last summer” led him to realize it was time to “step back and find a healthier relationship with the project.” It also drove the decision to restructure Mastodon.

That's been my personal experience with Mastodon and other "fediverse" projects; they don't really fix the central problem with modern social media, the godawful culture. I'm sure there are "nice" instances out there, but I gave up after trying 2-3 and having flashbacks to regular twitter from 7-8 years ago. No thanks

> they don't really fix the central problem with modern social media, the godawful culture.

That's just human culture, or more accurately, human nature. If you gather a bunch of anonymous strangers online in one place and let them run free, they'll likely make a mess of things.

Perhaps it's an unpopular opinion here, but I think that HN culture for example is horrendous.

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#409
post #357

Decentralisation on Mastodon is an illusion. For me a truly decentralised thing is where I am a node that transmits and can receive transmissions, like radios. When there has to be a server that's being administrated by somebody, this already puts me in a position where I depend on the people who own the server. This means that if for any reason these people don't like me, they can simply ban me and that's it. Basica…

> For me a truly decentralised thing is where I am a node that transmits and can receive transmissions, like radios.

That sounds like Nostr. My understanding is your node is the nostr relay. Your nostr client can publish messages to your relay. Any "subscribed" clients or relays can then access and forward the message from your relay.

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#410

This is an indescribably devastating loss for a project that, whatever its imperfections, can fairly lay claim to the most intellectually consistent and sincere adherence to FOSS, privacy, and decentralization of any major social media project. Eugene has proven a spectacular and indispensable developer, and I don't know that Mastodon has the ability to move on without him. I want to praise Eugen but the uncomfortabl…

Even Stallman signed up. Let that sink in.

It was one of his assistants that signed him up. Pedantic but he himself has never actually used it
Post reply on HN