Live data from Hacker News

Sign up for a first look at GitHub Desktop

desktop.github.com

41–43 of 43 posts

Re: Sign up for a first look at GitHub Desktop

#42
post #20
post #12

Just signed up. My git functionality is at a level of "can do all of the basic jank easily but need to Google everything else", which I'm super comfortable with, in all honesty. The only thing I really want out of a GUI is a visual diff/comparison tool before pushes. Does anyone have any recommendations for something along these lines?

Source Tree ( https://www.sourcetreeapp.com/ ) is great. Good visual layout of your diffs at any given point with the ability to stage/discard/unstage specific lines from within the program.

For me, Source Tree is very unusable and doesn't make any sense. Maybe I'm approaching it wrong?

It feels like there wasn't much thought about user stories and ux: every git operation was given a button or menu item. Sort of the MS Word phenomenon. Their screenshot on its home page is overwhelming, just like the design of their apps: a hundred items all vying for your attention.

In contrast, GitHub's app for Mac is immediately useful: it makes the 80/20 of git work easy.

Re: Sign up for a first look at GitHub Desktop

#43
post #12

Just signed up. My git functionality is at a level of "can do all of the basic jank easily but need to Google everything else", which I'm super comfortable with, in all honesty. The only thing I really want out of a GUI is a visual diff/comparison tool before pushes. Does anyone have any recommendations for something along these lines?

While you're waiting for access to the Desktop preview, check out the current GitHub for Mac ( https://mac.github.com/ ) and GitHub for Windows ( https://windows.github.com/ ). I use GHfM everyday in tandem with CLI, and the basic visual diffing is great.

GitHub for Mac is awesome; I depend on it for my work along with gitsh for certain tasks.

But when installing it on a fresh machine the other day, I couldn't find a link to it from the GitHub site (as a longged in user). I needed to go back out to Google to get the URL. Made me wonder if it's going to be dropped or unsupported.

Post reply on HN