Live data from Hacker News

USCIS Completes the H-1B Cap Random Selection Process for FY 2016

uscis.gov

41–50 of 114 posts

Re: USCIS Completes the H-1B Cap Random Selection Process for FY 2016

#41

When do they reach out to people if their application has been selected in the lottery or not?

It can take months. Got my approval in August.

Is approval notice the same as getting picked up in lottery? I think you can get picked up in a lottery but approval is not guaranteed.

Re: USCIS Completes the H-1B Cap Random Selection Process for FY 2016

#42

When do they reach out to people if their application has been selected in the lottery or not?

From the way I understand it cases with premium processing should here back until May 11. From what I've heard, others "before October" (one company doing consulting for H-1Bs expects these until August 15).

Re: USCIS Completes the H-1B Cap Random Selection Process for FY 2016

#43
IMHO, fix this by replacing the 'random' with 'highest salary' (or total comp). Just go down from the top.

- It would alleviate (though probably not solve) the downward pressure on salaries.

- It would ensure that companies are well motivated to find domestic workers since they would, theoretically, be cheaper.

- It would ensure that H-1B's go to the people who would add the most value to the economy (or else the company would be less competitive due to overpaying).

- It would favor the most talented foreigners rather than putting them in a random lottery with new grads.

- It would allocate the H-1B's to the companies that need them most (since they're offering the most money)

- It would maximize the future tax take of the US government (maximum income => maximum taxes paid)

Ironically, this might have prevented me from getting my own H-1B as I got it fairly early in my career.

Re: USCIS Completes the H-1B Cap Random Selection Process for FY 2016

#44

Can someone translate to human language?

In the good old days, it wasn't so easy to hire a foreigner that studied computer science in an American university: They'd get an automatic 1 year practical training visa, and if after a few months you saw that they were a good hire, you'd sponsor them for an H1-B, and eventually a green card. That's how many senior people that were born overseas got to their spots.

Now, thanks to low quotas, and some rather unsavory consultancy companies, the H1-B program has now become useless for this purpose, as you have less than a 50/50 chance of getting an H1-B approved, just due to quotas. So while an honest company that wants to hire a good developer will not be OK with the delays and the low percentages of hiring someone in those conditions, a mill that interviews thousands of people and will place them in third party customers as consultants will gladly just keep flooding the market with applicants that probably will not get anywhere.

TL;DR The H1-B program used to be defensible, and maybe useful. The way it works now, it only works for companies who abuse it.

Re: USCIS Completes the H-1B Cap Random Selection Process for FY 2016

#46
I'm originally from France, came to the U.S. for undergraduate studies in 2010. My first year here, I fell in love and started dating an American student, and have been dating her ever since. Similarly, I fell in love with the United States, and wish to spend my life here. Currently, I am currently on OPT, applied for the H1-B process this year with my great SF company, and now am waiting to hear back about my 28% chance of getting a visa...

I'm not trying to scam the U.S., or cheat Americans out of a job, and my company is paying me the same amount as the americans who started at the same time as me. Instead, I want to be an American, and be a part of this country. Despite this, I am now at risk of being deported if I don't get the visa, and having to leave behind my whole life here, and my girlfriend here who I intend to spend the rest of my life with.

The worst part about this is that I am completely powerless, and at the whim of chance.

Re: USCIS Completes the H-1B Cap Random Selection Process for FY 2016

#48

OK and why is this the top of HN? Because of the number of applications? The number of applications is slightly higher than last year, but still I fail to understand why it is on the top, because this same thing was happening for the last 4+ years. My application was picked up in the year 2013, so I have been following both HN and the USCIS at that time. Never saw it make top of HN.

I'm neither an immigrant nor an employer, but I care. In the comments I learned a fair bit about issues with my countries immigration policies which I did not already know.

Re: USCIS Completes the H-1B Cap Random Selection Process for FY 2016

#49

This is the process I went throught back in 2005 to get a job in IT after graduating in Business in Poland: 1. Got a position with an Indian company that promised a job after paid training ($5k) 2. After 3-month long training they totally and completely faked my resume. I.e. included 5-years experience, fake credentials, fake references. 3. Got me a job with large, large bank. 4. Got half my salary for 6-months. 5. A…

May be it's not 90% but I have a friend who experienced the same thing, she gave up after 2 weeks once she realized the lie. I honestly think the US government is lazy in this aspect. It's not that hard to track down those consultancies. Not relevant but that reminds me of the tax case where an unemployed girl filed for $2M tax return and got the money (only got caught later when she lost her card).

Re: USCIS Completes the H-1B Cap Random Selection Process for FY 2016

#50

Why this is important: Because if a tech company wants to hire a foreigner, the visa process (regardless of skill^1) is basically worse than a coin toss. Which means companies have a much more limited pool of applicants. And let's be real, this country doesn't have nearly enough STEM professionals to meet demand. 1)Exceptions: Master's degree (another lottery), extraordinary ability (pretty tough).

> let's be real, this country doesn't have nearly enough STEM professionals to meet demand

... at current salaries.

Post reply on HN