Live data from Hacker News

I'll Accept Anything – Accepting every pull request submitted

github.com

41–50 of 106 posts

Re: I'll Accept Anything – Accepting every pull request submitted

#41

This is the Wikipedia approach to software development. Why does it seem absurd for software yet it seems to work (perhaps inefficiently) for Wikipedia? What if Linus made the Linux master repository world-writable? If Wikipedia required edits to be reviewed by other editors, they would probably be thwarted with fake editor accounts.

Wikipedia articles have topics, this does not.

Re: I'll Accept Anything – Accepting every pull request submitted

#42
post #36
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why does it seem absurd for software yet it seems to work (perhaps inefficiently) for Wikipedia? Mostly because software is deeply interconnected - every file will call something within another one. Wikipedia will link to another file, but never depends upon the content within it.

That got me thinking, I wonder if you can make a redirect loop or a mega redirect loop that would OOM wikipedia?

No, redirects on Wikipedia bottom out after a depth of 2.

Re: I'll Accept Anything – Accepting every pull request submitted

#43

This is the Wikipedia approach to software development. Why does it seem absurd for software yet it seems to work (perhaps inefficiently) for Wikipedia? What if Linus made the Linux master repository world-writable? If Wikipedia required edits to be reviewed by other editors, they would probably be thwarted with fake editor accounts.

I think it seems more a TwitchPlaysPokemon approach to software.

Re: I'll Accept Anything – Accepting every pull request submitted

#44
post #21
post #4

Someone has already submitted a pull request changing the readme so that it says he'll accept nothing. However, I think this can be rejected under the "don't be a dick" rule.

Well I was planning on a .gitignore that ignored everything. Now I feel like that might qualify as a dick move :(

It would barely affect anybody. Confuse at max.

Re: I'll Accept Anything – Accepting every pull request submitted

#45

This is the Wikipedia approach to software development. Why does it seem absurd for software yet it seems to work (perhaps inefficiently) for Wikipedia? What if Linus made the Linux master repository world-writable? If Wikipedia required edits to be reviewed by other editors, they would probably be thwarted with fake editor accounts.

It is not the Wikipedia approach. Github, not the project, is more analagous to Wikipedia. A project is self contained with references to other projects, as is a page. A repository or a wiki is a collection of these. Wikipedia doesn't really accept anything. Additionally, it has a culture, guidelines and de facto moderators. A political structure has arisen within Wikipedia, but a cursory look misses that. In those ways, it is similar to open source development and the Linux kernel.

Edit: missed a comma

Re: I'll Accept Anything – Accepting every pull request submitted

#46
post #11
post #3

this might be a joke, but this is a serious problem i have as well. i want to create something, but i don't know what to do.. there is nothing i need that is not already done, or at least thats why i think.

I have like 20 drafts of things I'll never work on because of lack of time but that I think are pretty good ideas. Fraom games to programming tools including network tools, educational applications, etc... What are your areas of expertise and interest?

Publish your ideas in a repo? That way people can help refine them.

Re: I'll Accept Anything – Accepting every pull request submitted

#47
post #32

This is the Wikipedia approach to software development. Why does it seem absurd for software yet it seems to work (perhaps inefficiently) for Wikipedia? What if Linus made the Linux master repository world-writable? If Wikipedia required edits to be reviewed by other editors, they would probably be thwarted with fake editor accounts.

Why does it seem absurd for software yet it seems to work (perhaps inefficiently) for Wikipedia? Mostly because software is deeply interconnected - every file will call something within another one. Wikipedia will link to another file, but never depends upon the content within it.

Wikipedia templates are often very interconnected.

But they often have those protected.

Re: I'll Accept Anything – Accepting every pull request submitted

#48
Dear OP:

https://github.com/samsquire/ideas

http://gamedev.stackexchange.com/questions/854/what-are-good...

http://suckless.org/project_ideas

http://www.weekendhacker.net

http://wiki.osdev.org/Expanded_Main_Page / http://littleosbook.github.io/book.pdf

Enjoy!

Re: I'll Accept Anything – Accepting every pull request submitted

#49
post #30
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> - Group purchasing for work - what if you wanted to break the cost of a Foosball table up over a group of people. It's cheap if you have enough people involved. It's called an office manager. Combined with an expense account for the company. > - App for finding which stores are open at 11pm (or on Sunday in places where most things are closed on Sunday) It's called Foursquare. Bonus, it does this for a radius aroun…

>> - Group purchasing for work > It's called an office manager. No office manager I've ever had would purchase anything and then seek divided reimbursement from individuals in the office.

If the purchase is for the workplace, even something recreational for the employees, the company should pay for it. There should be a fun-budget for such things. Group purchasing is still an interesting idea, I just don't think the example's a great one.

Re: I'll Accept Anything – Accepting every pull request submitted

#50
post #3

this might be a joke, but this is a serious problem i have as well. i want to create something, but i don't know what to do.. there is nothing i need that is not already done, or at least thats why i think.

Solve your own minor problem.

For me it would be be searching in source for anything that is built in release not debug mode.

Or more generally a better local search solution for source code. Powerful enough to find what I need without resorting to regex.

Post reply on HN