Live data from Hacker News

FCC Chairman: This Is How We Will Ensure Net Neutrality

wired.com

41–50 of 437 posts

Re: FCC Chairman: This Is How We Will Ensure Net Neutrality

#41
post #26

So as someone who has been lightly following the debate, and is not familiar with the FCC's process, what are the next steps to actually start enforcing mobile and landline broadband as Title II? I also wonder how long it will take for the reclassification to become enforceable, and how long the existing companies will have to "become compliant".

I am keenly interested in this as well and hoping desperately that it does not involve the United States Congress.

Re: FCC Chairman: This Is How We Will Ensure Net Neutrality

#43
post #22
post #4

No last mile unbundling: does it mean that every operator has to deploy its own cable from street to home?

That's my (rather depressing) understanding. I still dream of a non-profit or municipal cable plant, serviced by multiple ISPs. The last mile is a natural monopoly, and we need to stop pretending otherwise.

This. This is the most cogent description of what we need. A common resource that is provided to multiple Telco's but owned by the local community.

Re: FCC Chairman: This Is How We Will Ensure Net Neutrality

#44
post #33
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They don't have a veto-proof majority.

Congress only needs a simple majority to prevent a bill from being passed in the first place. It will never hit the President's desk.

The implication is that the simple majority in congress would be against these regulations and pass a bill to stop them. However, if the President supports these regulations promulgated under existing statutory authority, he would veto any new bill that revoked that authority.

Re: FCC Chairman: This Is How We Will Ensure Net Neutrality

#45
I violated Responsible Reading Of The Internet Rule #1 and accidentally looked at the comments. I am having a hard time reconciling the vehement anti-net-neutrality anti-government hair-on-fire screaming there with the reasoned discussion and general attitude here---I would have thought the majority of readers of Wired would be of similar mind to HN readers.

Re: FCC Chairman: This Is How We Will Ensure Net Neutrality

#46
post #30

Using this authority, I am submitting to my colleagues the strongest open internet protections ever proposed by the FCC. These enforceable, bright-line rules will ban paid prioritization, and the blocking and throttling of lawful content and services. I propose to fully apply—for the first time ever—those bright-line rules to mobile broadband. My proposal assures the rights of internet users to go where they want, wh…

These enforceable, bright-line rules will ban paid prioritization, and the blocking and throttling of lawful content and services of 'lawful content and services'. I don't mean to ruin a good thing, but is it implied here that ISPs may become the gatekeepers? I don't want what happened to YouTube (automatic content blocking because it's "unlawful") to take place with the general internet. One of the most important as…

Title 2 has a provision that says providers of "an interactive computer service" can't be held liable for their attempts to block access to obscenities or other objectionable content.

Re: FCC Chairman: This Is How We Will Ensure Net Neutrality

#47
post #12

Well, I believe this kicks off the biggest lobbying effort seen in a long time to get this to not happen. I certainly hope that the US internet gets Title II.

The lobbying has been in full effect for a year, looks like they already lost this one.

Re: FCC Chairman: This Is How We Will Ensure Net Neutrality

#48
post #22
post #4

No last mile unbundling: does it mean that every operator has to deploy its own cable from street to home?

That's my (rather depressing) understanding. I still dream of a non-profit or municipal cable plant, serviced by multiple ISPs. The last mile is a natural monopoly, and we need to stop pretending otherwise.

I'm hoping that political organizations promoting net neutrality, now expand their attention to this issue or some other way to spur real competition in the last mile.

Re: FCC Chairman: This Is How We Will Ensure Net Neutrality

#49

This looks much better than what I feared. I'm glad they're just not regulating it under Title II, but are modernizing it: For example, there will be no rate regulation, no tariffs, no last-mile unbundling.

From an outsiders perspective, the last mile in unfeeling is the only bit that matters, market forces can resolve everything else, but it's not really possible to lay a dozen sets of last mile infrastructure.

Re: FCC Chairman: This Is How We Will Ensure Net Neutrality

#50

Using this authority, I am submitting to my colleagues the strongest open internet protections ever proposed by the FCC. These enforceable, bright-line rules will ban paid prioritization, and the blocking and throttling of lawful content and services. I propose to fully apply—for the first time ever—those bright-line rules to mobile broadband. My proposal assures the rights of internet users to go where they want, wh…

On first read, this appears to be the best and most pragmatic of all possible proposals. I'm nervous about its reception and subsequent tearing-down, but this is an FCC I can get behind.
Post reply on HN