Live data from Hacker News

Introducing Snapcash

blog.snapchat.com

41–50 of 207 posts

Re: Introducing Snapcash

#41
post #6

This kind of thing will be the death of Venmo, and makes me wonder why they haven't moved faster. An app that already has your social network will have more success adding friend payments than your friend payments app trying to add a social network.

OTOH, a payment app can grow pretty organically. It doesn't matter that I'm not "friends" with my friend Joe on Venmo if I don't need to send him money.

Re: Introducing Snapcash

#44
I have been a long time user of Venmo and have tried to get a number of my friends on it but most of my friends consider entering their routing/account numbers (if they even know what those are...) into an app and waiting a couple days too much work. They even consider Square Cash too much of a hassle but I can see all of those same friends using Snapcash without issue. I consider Venmo to be the best in this space currently (But come on! Allow using debit cards to receive money already!) and I don't mind the 1-3 day delay in cashing out but I will still enter my debit card in snapchat cause at the end of the day I'm going to use the service that allows me to pay and get paid by the highest number of friends.

Re: Introducing Snapcash

#45
post #25

50% of snapchat users are under 18 [1]. which this video seems to clearly target (production style is fun, quirky, light hearted, even the actors are young). Yet they require a debit card and the use to be 18+. I guess they are hoping their young users stick with it for a few more years. [1] http://www.statista.com/statistics/315398/snapchat-user-age-...

In fairness, the other 50% of Snapchat users is quite a large number of people.

I'm assuming their VC-backers are hoping to see traction without waiting for the underage half of the user base to grow up, and are really hoping it doesn't become the fun, friction-free and ephemeral way for that demographic to send their friends funds from their parents' bank account.

Re: Introducing Snapcash

#46
post #2

I love this because it looks just as simple as Venmo, but I don't need to convince people to download the app.

You don't need to download anything to use Venmo, you can use their website.

I think "download" was a shorthand for "sign-up". Signing up for a payments service is pretty friction-ful.

Re: Introducing Snapcash

#47
post #14

Square loses something like 25 cents per Square Cash transaction [1], and now they want more transactions? I wonder if Snapchat is paying those fees, and if so how they think they're going to make that money back from their users. [1] http://qz.com/248572/squares-search-for-a-viable-business-mo...

Given they will have the debit card saved, perhaps Snapchat is thinking it will be much easier to offer products to their users in the future.

Re: Introducing Snapcash

#48
Whats that old jwz quote: "Every program attempts to expand until it can read mail. Those programs which cannot so expand are replaced by ones which can."

I think there is a corollary too, though I cannot attribute it: "Every social media site attempts to expand until it becomes a bank. Those companies which cannot so expand are replaced by ones which can."

Re: Introducing Snapcash

#50
post #32

I think the primary challenge is convincing users that it's secure. Snapchat has a relatively poor reputation in security (whether that's deserved or not), and everyone I know just uses Venmo. Venmo has Facebook integration, so if you're Facebook friends, it's really easy to send money. It seems like integrating into a platform that's supposed to be ethereal is a weird fit, but who knows -- maybe it'll catch on.

Even if the users of snapchat were particularly concerned with the security of this feature, they alleviated that concern in the post by stating that all of the financial security will be handled by Square which is building it's reputation of security in mobile payments.

I'd like to see a venn diagram of Snapchat users and people who actually know who/what Square is
Post reply on HN