Live data from Hacker News

Fatal Dose – Radiation Deaths linked to AECL Computer Errors (1994)

ccnr.org

41–42 of 42 posts

Re: Fatal Dose – Radiation Deaths linked to AECL Computer Errors (1994)

#41
post #3

Thanks, I hadn't read this before. For those that haven't read it, here's Levesons article on the Therac-25: http://sunnyday.mit.edu/papers/therac.pdf

This one made me think about public outrage against tobacco companies. One minor theme in this article is that AECL denied knowledge of any reports of Therac-25 malfunctions even when, looking at a timeline of publicly-known events, such ignorance might be described as "implausible". They don't seem to have been punished for this, and while I agree that it isn't laudable I also agree that it's not the greatest infrac…

Didn't the tobacco companies also spend money to discredit scientists and peer-reviewed articles and seed misinformation about the real risks of smoking, all while they were sitting on that mortality data? I think that was the real problem.

Re: Fatal Dose – Radiation Deaths linked to AECL Computer Errors (1994)

#42
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This one made me think about public outrage against tobacco companies. One minor theme in this article is that AECL denied knowledge of any reports of Therac-25 malfunctions even when, looking at a timeline of publicly-known events, such ignorance might be described as "implausible". They don't seem to have been punished for this, and while I agree that it isn't laudable I also agree that it's not the greatest infrac…

Didn't the tobacco companies also spend money to discredit scientists and peer-reviewed articles and seed misinformation about the real risks of smoking, all while they were sitting on that mortality data? I think that was the real problem.

All of what you've said is also legal today.
Post reply on HN