Live data from Hacker News

Why We Cancelled Our Kickstarter And Funded It Ourselves

needwant.com

41–50 of 77 posts

Re: Why We Cancelled Our Kickstarter And Funded It Ourselves

#41
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ditto. How about in this thread? I was watched the video waiting for some big reveal, but was sort of let down by the offering. The site says more about the notebook's quality than the OCR/digitization, which is what I was more interested in.

Why would an scanning service even get into the notebook business? There are a LOT of different notebooks to choose from out there, and for anyone who cares enough to use this service in the first place, it's probably a pretty personal decision what notebook to use. I checked out their webapp. "Try it out. No registration required." Then you click and it brings you to a login page. It took me a second to realize that…

> Why would an scanning service even get into the notebook business?

Because they are producing special notebooks that work with their business model, that have the proper bindings so they can easily get the pages out of them. For example, They probably even have a machine that does it for them, or special tools. Furthermore, it allows the cost to be consistent, otherwise they would have to charge per page and the user might not be aware of how many pages are in their notebook, so they might not know the cost ahead of time. I have a notebook at home and I can't even fathom a guess as to how many pages it is, I am sure that the sticker or whatever was on it when I bought it told me, but that is long gone. It also allows them to only process orders that are cost effective for them - minimum page requirements, consistent cost, pages that are optimal for their scanners, they know exactly what is going to come in, known cost of shipping so they can know exactly the amount of postage they have to pay, etc.

Re: Why We Cancelled Our Kickstarter And Funded It Ourselves

#42
It doesn't look like they were going to make their funding goal. I know that a lot of money comes in on the final 2-3 days, but unless they had a pile of friends and family ready to throw in, the projections don't look good.

They also say that they decided to cancel just 10 days into the campaign, but it looks like they actually cancelled on Nov 14th (day 24) with just 7 days remaining (and at less than 50% funded).

None of that invalidates what they've written and what they gained from running a Kickstarter, but it seems like they're spinning it that they killed what was going to be a successful campaign.

http://www.kicktraq.com/projects/marshallhaas/201552485/#cha...

Re: Why We Cancelled Our Kickstarter And Funded It Ourselves

#43
post #18

What about confidentiality and privacy? Love it, but some of my notes are highly confidential. Obviously, I could use a separate notebook, but is there any thought towards privacy or assurance from these guys that no one is reading these notebooks when they're digitized? The video makes it look like a fairly manual process. Ordered one anyway to try it out.

You should never release highly confidential documents to unapproved entities, even if they pinky swear they won't read them. Almost certainly violates your NDA if you signed one.

Re: Why We Cancelled Our Kickstarter And Funded It Ourselves

#44

I wonder if the notebooks are stripped to bare sheets, scanned and then re-built as a new notebook with proper bindings for sending back. I don't see any other way of doing this that would keep it efficient.

Maybe we should go back to scrolls. In the future, users will simply feed their Draft scroll into their printer, like how punch-tapes were fed into the mainframes of old.

Re: Why We Cancelled Our Kickstarter And Funded It Ourselves

#45
post #4

Get all of the hype and exposure that a Kickstarter campaign gives without having to pay them their cut. Makes sense.

Do you really think the cancellation was premeditated? That's what your comment seems to imply.

Is that the only factor that matters (whether it was premeditated)? The ultimate effect is still that KS doesn't get a cut.

Re: Why We Cancelled Our Kickstarter And Funded It Ourselves

#46

I wonder if the notebooks are stripped to bare sheets, scanned and then re-built as a new notebook with proper bindings for sending back. I don't see any other way of doing this that would keep it efficient.

The article does cover this.

They mention that they realized users wanted the notebooks back, but I didn't see any details on how they would do this. It's left as a problem to solve.

Re: Why We Cancelled Our Kickstarter And Funded It Ourselves

#47
post #38

I use notebooks, notepads, blanks sheets of paper, Japanese A5 and A5 notepads, and Pilot Frixion erasable pens. I do mostly writing, and also diagramming (I'm a software developer) with the odd doodle and 3-d house. I'm very picky about pens, very picky about paper. I also definitely want to keep my notebooks. I do not want all this stuff digitized. At all. What I do digitize, I convert carefully, taking care to cra…

I am very sorry for down voting you, it was a complete accident, my mouse slipped, and now I can't undo my action.

No worries, I upvoted it for you.

Re: Why We Cancelled Our Kickstarter And Funded It Ourselves

#48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article does cover this.

They mention that they realized users wanted the notebooks back, but I didn't see any details on how they would do this. It's left as a problem to solve.

They solved it. Mod Notebooks gives you the option to have your notebook back.

The reason they couldn't do it was because the company doing the scanning could not scan it non-destructively. Very likely, they just switched to another company.

Re: Why We Cancelled Our Kickstarter And Funded It Ourselves

#50

>"We’d kill the subscription model..." I tend to be wary of any service with ongoing running costs sold as a one-time fee. As long as new sales exceed the cost of servicing the existing population everything is fine. Once that relationship reverses all bets are off. That said, I like this idea and $25 is a better price point that I would have expected.

> I tend to be wary of any service with ongoing running costs sold as a one-time fee Well, they aren't really charging a one time fee, they're charging per notebook.

>"Well, they aren't really charging a one time fee, they're charging per notebook."

Sure, a one time fee per notebook. The "per" doesn't make it a different model.

Post reply on HN