Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Dinosaur asteroid 'sent life to Mars'

bbc.co.uk

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

41–47 of 47 posts

Re: Dinosaur asteroid 'sent life to Mars'

#41

Post by ChuckMcM »

flinty wrote: post #34
ChuckMcM wrote: post #4

I have this vision of dinosaur astronauts, clinging to the rock that has been ejected into space, on their way to Mars to establish a new life there. I have always found the pan-spermia theories interesting. It still doesn't answer the 'where first' question but it allows for many places to share similar lifeforms without requiring a recreation of an improbable event in all of them. Of course it would be really weird…

So kind of like the stargate SG1 plot line where instead of the ancients spreading life across the universe using stargates you have meteros doing the work

I guess that would make planets meteorsexuals.

(sorry I couldn't resist)

Re: Dinosaur asteroid 'sent life to Mars'

#43

Post by mtdewcmu »

mathattack wrote: post #36
ChuckMcM wrote: post #4

I have this vision of dinosaur astronauts, clinging to the rock that has been ejected into space, on their way to Mars to establish a new life there. I have always found the pan-spermia theories interesting. It still doesn't answer the 'where first' question but it allows for many places to share similar lifeforms without requiring a recreation of an improbable event in all of them. Of course it would be really weird…

Given the right similar starting conditions in the DNA... It could be interesting. What surprises me is that life can survive these trips. A rock ejected from the Earth would have to have tremendous heat during the escape velocity. Science is fascinating.

That's what I was thinking. That piece of rock must be very hot as it's flying out into space from a violent explosion. At least, that's how I picture it. It seems odd that the article was concerned about the danger of space itself, but never mentioned the exit from earth.

Science is very fascinating, but this phenomenon of life successfully leaving earth and arriving on other planets has never been demonstrated, so it's more idle speculation than science.

Re: Dinosaur asteroid 'sent life to Mars'

#44

Post by mathattack »

mtdewcmu wrote: post #43
mathattack wrote: post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Given the right similar starting conditions in the DNA... It could be interesting. What surprises me is that life can survive these trips. A rock ejected from the Earth would have to have tremendous heat during the escape velocity. Science is fascinating.

That's what I was thinking. That piece of rock must be very hot as it's flying out into space from a violent explosion. At least, that's how I picture it. It seems odd that the article was concerned about the danger of space itself, but never mentioned the exit from earth. Science is very fascinating, but this phenomenon of life successfully leaving earth and arriving on other planets has never been demonstrated, so…

I think they've at least seen them survive in space. I recall reading stories of microbes surviving near absolute zero. Bacteria and spores could survive a lot, but I would think they would have to be inside a mighty big rock to survive the heat.

Re: Dinosaur asteroid 'sent life to Mars'

#45

Post by mtdewcmu »

mathattack wrote: post #44
mtdewcmu wrote: post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's what I was thinking. That piece of rock must be very hot as it's flying out into space from a violent explosion. At least, that's how I picture it. It seems odd that the article was concerned about the danger of space itself, but never mentioned the exit from earth. Science is very fascinating, but this phenomenon of life successfully leaving earth and arriving on other planets has never been demonstrated, so…

I think they've at least seen them survive in space. I recall reading stories of microbes surviving near absolute zero. Bacteria and spores could survive a lot, but I would think they would have to be inside a mighty big rock to survive the heat.

Some microscopic organisms are said to have survived exposure to space. But just because some of the pieces have been shown to be plausible, doesn't justify accepting the entire scenario.

Re: Dinosaur asteroid 'sent life to Mars'

#46

Post by mathattack »

mtdewcmu wrote: post #45
mathattack wrote: post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think they've at least seen them survive in space. I recall reading stories of microbes surviving near absolute zero. Bacteria and spores could survive a lot, but I would think they would have to be inside a mighty big rock to survive the heat.

Some microscopic organisms are said to have survived exposure to space. But just because some of the pieces have been shown to be plausible, doesn't justify accepting the entire scenario.

I agree with you.

I think this is a good statistics exercise too. What's more likely? That life emerges spontaneously in multiple spots of space, or that life survives inter-planetary (and perhaps inter-solar system) journeys?

Re: Dinosaur asteroid 'sent life to Mars'

#47

Post by mtdewcmu »

mathattack wrote: post #46
mtdewcmu wrote: post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Some microscopic organisms are said to have survived exposure to space. But just because some of the pieces have been shown to be plausible, doesn't justify accepting the entire scenario.

I agree with you. I think this is a good statistics exercise too. What's more likely? That life emerges spontaneously in multiple spots of space, or that life survives inter-planetary (and perhaps inter-solar system) journeys?

You couldn't possibly answer that.
Post reply on HN