Live data from Hacker News

Wounded QR Codes

datagenetics.com

41–50 of 52 posts

Re: Wounded QR Codes

#41
QR codes are great for augmenting ads, booklets and other stuff, but if you want reliable readability, you shouldn't go with more than a simple color change, in my experience.

I was tasked with creating QR codes for certificates (every certificate leads to a unique page for the certificate number on the website, for security and more information since the certificates were small and made to be pretty instead of useful).

We ended up with Level M golden (more like dark yellow) colored QR codes in the corner - using higher error correction is actually detrimental the smaller you go, and backgrounds, embossing or any kind of advanced design would lead to it being very hard to read - it's better to have a plain ugly QR code that is immediately scannable with any device than a pretty one that is unreadable (just imagine your buyers trying to scan the damn thing five times in a row then give up in frustration).

But the client really liked the idea (and the results), and I am still surprised that so many people don't even consider this nowadays...

Re: Wounded QR Codes

#42
post #39

One thing that still bugs me about QR code error correction is the lack of support for codes with inverted color schemes. Unless I'm mistaken, this feature should be relatively simple to implement (ie. checking for two patterns) yet most of the applications I know fail at reading an inverted code (ie google goggles).

What purpose do inverted colors serve? Is there some use of QR codes that is poorly served by the standard scheme but better served by an inverted one?

Re: Wounded QR Codes

#43
Cool! I hand painted a QR code[0] in about .75x.75" onto a painting my father did for a friend and while working on it I spent about an hour or two implementing different codes of varying complexity in pencil to see how far I could go before it would get corrupted. It actually works[1] but it's on the wall in a music venue so unfortunately it takes a few extra seconds for some people's phones to adjust to the lower light.

[0] http://conundrum.us/cmhpolka.html [1] http://zxing.org/w/decode

Re: Wounded QR Codes

#44
post #4

I was able to properly scan "Spray painted code" and "ripped by gap" with the RedLaser iPhone app. Don't let the last one get you down.

Yes -- me too. Using RedLaser, I was able to scan 5 (low contrast), 9 (missing position square), 11 (vertical gap), 25 (warp drive), and 29 and 30 (ant invasion). I was not able to scan 17 (extreme tilt) or 23 (dizziness). This points out how important the software is.

"These are not the pixels you are looking for." Choice.

Re: Wounded QR Codes

#45
post #26
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can also embed higher-res images in QR codes without breaking them. http://cgv.cs.nthu.edu.tw/Projects/Recreational_Graphics/Hal...

Anyone know of a publicly available implementation of this?

[deleted]

Re: Wounded QR Codes

#46
post #26
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can also embed higher-res images in QR codes without breaking them. http://cgv.cs.nthu.edu.tw/Projects/Recreational_Graphics/Hal...

Anyone know of a publicly available implementation of this?

http://vecg.cs.ucl.ac.uk/Projects/SmartGeometry/halftone_QR/...

http://140.114.79.59:99/halftoneQRC.aspx

Re: Wounded QR Codes

#47
Does anyone have a sense of what percentage of the smartphone-owning population actually knows what QR codes are and would bother to scan them? I'm as technically savvy as your average HN reader I would think, and I ignored the things for years before finally spending the 2 minutes to learn what they are. It's always made me assume that the average person wouldn't bother with them.

Re: Wounded QR Codes

#48
post #42
post #39

One thing that still bugs me about QR code error correction is the lack of support for codes with inverted color schemes. Unless I'm mistaken, this feature should be relatively simple to implement (ie. checking for two patterns) yet most of the applications I know fail at reading an inverted code (ie google goggles).

What purpose do inverted colors serve? Is there some use of QR codes that is poorly served by the standard scheme but better served by an inverted one?

Aesthetics of the rest of the image / object it is on. Inverting allows you to have a black 'quiet area' rather than a lighter one.

That being said, if you are putting QR codes on anything aesthetics are probably not something that even registers with you.

Re: Wounded QR Codes

#49
post #14

For those few of us that don't have any device with a built-in capability of interpreting QR codes: http://zxing.org/w/decode?u=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.datagenetics.co...

There are quite a few more applications for the use of QR codes besides sharing marketing infos and links on smartphones.

One of the more creative ones I've seen recently is creating a really long-term data storage (Giga-Year) based on QR-Codes - http://vimeo.com/77028789

Post reply on HN