Live data from Hacker News

The Revolution Will Be Twittered

andrewsullivan.theatlantic.com

41–44 of 44 posts

Re: The Revolution Will Be Twittered

#41
post #13
post #4

How will Twitter self-organisation fare if the Iranian Revolutionary Guard decides to start shooting? It's great that the Iranian people can self-organise despite all the attempted censorship of the government, and certainly the free flow of information is a powerful tool in the hands of the people... but guns are powerful tools too. It's also curious why they did not clamp down on Twitter. After all, the Chinese gov…

"...perhaps there should be a non-profit that exists for the sole purpose of providing rapidly changing and shifting anonymising proxies to people everywhere, to make it so that it is effectively impossible for any government in the world to block something like Twitter." Check out tor ( http://www.torproject.org/ ). It's slow, but it's the closest thing we have to that right now.

Despite this contributes nothing to the Iran thread, I find it amazing that you say 'we'. I neither want to go off-topic here. But it occured to me that people closely attached to the web tend to realize a 'we' amongst them, across all borders.

Re: The Revolution Will Be Twittered

#42
post #20

We might be overstating Twitter's role in this situation. Because we are receiving so many good reports via Twitter, those of us who aren't in Iran might be committing a type of spotlight fallacy by believing that Twitter is having a large effect on the events themselves.

A while back Vancouver Film School (VFS) released a short-film on how Iran embraces new media, namely the web. The piece is titled "Iran: A Nation of Bloggers", can be watched at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MChlT0GvFPM . With about 100000 (one hundred thousand) actively maintained blogs, I can imagine Twitter indeed does play an important role there.

Re: The Revolution Will Be Twittered

#43

It's interesting that something that already happened at least once is suddenly much more interesting because it involves the Islamic world. This was done before in Moldavia ( http://www.wired.com/dangerroom/2009/04/inside-moldovas/ ) but it was not that interesting for the media then because it wasn't Muslims and nobody wanted to anger Russia at that moment.

Moldova, not Moldavia. You've actually got it backwards - the Twitter angle was hyped pretty hard by the media during the Moldovan protests, even though only a small handful of protesters used the service. These kind of bromides about [information technology of the day] enabling a new kind of revolution are as old as the hills - I remember hearing similar stuff about fax machines/email during the Bosnian war - and ty…

I don't understand what I got backwards. I was just pointing out that this is a very similar situation to that one (revolution, twitter, elections) and it has the same media buzz but with the added bonus that it involves a Muslim country hence the US media enjoys it more. Your points about that situation are valid of course but that was not what I was saying.

It's funny you should correct the way I wrote the country name. I know the proper name but I chose to write it like most English users would know it.

Re: The Revolution Will Be Twittered

#44
post #35

i'm just a tad confused. if all internet and mobile lines are cut, how can they use twitter?

http://twitter.com/persiankiwi/status/2169483495 "I am accessing twitter from 148.233.239.24 Port:80 in tehran. you can avoid gov filters from here. spread to others. #Iranelection"

You'll not find much echo on jpost anymore, it/Israel/USA being interferingaccused by I./O.wantsI.talk. Couldn't see anymore whether they'd posted my WED written abt Habibi's "war ./. God" (intestinalrage, notGodwhocheated, youDARE hang them!!!) tostopthemasJ.M.Jordan/Germany. Godblessyou + the24
Post reply on HN