Live data from Hacker News

OpenAI says my prepaid credits were consumed, refuses to show any record

community.openai.com

41–45 of 45 posts

Re: OpenAI says my prepaid credits were consumed, refuses to show any record

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> “You say that, but you haven't explained how it is a liability, and I consider it debatable.” I gave chapter and verse. But let me try to help with the intuition. It’s about accounting. That’s all. Not your intuition. Not my preference. Ready? Record. It’s the agreed upon rules for how some named monetary _thing_, which is constant flow and here defined, can be said to have a value x at time t. Gift card is a liabi…

> Gift card is a liability until used It's your biased interpretation that it's a liability. A clever firm may use a safe fraction of it to collect interest via a bank or directly via treasuries. This turns your logic on its head. The longer the gift card stays unused, the more revenue it generates via interest. Just enough needs to be kept as cash to fund customer expenses for the next two quarters.

You are arguing about accounting jargon. The card has to be tracked, the entries that track it fall under the label "liability".

Re: OpenAI says my prepaid credits were consumed, refuses to show any record

#42
post #37
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not equivalent because the product purchased hasn’t yet been redeemed in the case of the credits. The equivalent would be buying a gift card from a grocery store and then the store saying you can’t use the card because it expired.

Every physical gift card I’ve seen had an expiry date.

Which is illegal in lots of places.

Re: OpenAI says my prepaid credits were consumed, refuses to show any record

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Gift card is a liability until used It's your biased interpretation that it's a liability. A clever firm may use a safe fraction of it to collect interest via a bank or directly via treasuries. This turns your logic on its head. The longer the gift card stays unused, the more revenue it generates via interest. Just enough needs to be kept as cash to fund customer expenses for the next two quarters.

You are arguing about accounting jargon. The card has to be tracked, the entries that track it fall under the label "liability".

The issue is that the author is using it as an excuse to justify stealing unspent customer funds after one year. It's not an appropriate excuse.

Re: OpenAI says my prepaid credits were consumed, refuses to show any record

#44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are arguing about accounting jargon. The card has to be tracked, the entries that track it fall under the label "liability".

The issue is that the author is using it as an excuse to justify stealing unspent customer funds after one year. It's not an appropriate excuse.

> “…stealing unspent customer funds after one year.”

There’s our common ground! The common sense question: why is 1 year legal when there is a federal law saying it’s must be 5 years?

Re: OpenAI says my prepaid credits were consumed, refuses to show any record

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The issue is that the author is using it as an excuse to justify stealing unspent customer funds after one year. It's not an appropriate excuse.

> “…stealing unspent customer funds after one year.” There’s our common ground! The common sense question: why is 1 year legal when there is a federal law saying it’s must be 5 years?

The funds must ideally last forever for the life of the firm. I wouldn't even buy a gift card if it going to expire in five years.

Amazon is another prominent example. It gift card in the US never expires and has no fee. It's a good place for stashing funds. Do you think Amazon doesn't have accountants?

For logical reasons I have noted before, there is no unmanageable risk to any sizable firm with it.

Post reply on HN