Live data from Hacker News

Franken.domains: Stitched-Together Domains, Because Every .com Is Taken

franken.domains

41–50 of 52 posts

Re: Franken.domains: Stitched-Together Domains, Because Every .com Is Taken

#41
post #26
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

it's like Wikipedia begging for money saying they don't have enough

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:Guy_Macon/Wikipedia_has_C... btw Don't give them money until they stop wasting what they have, and chastise them for begging so hard.

[deleted]

Re: Franken.domains: Stitched-Together Domains, Because Every .com Is Taken

#42

These are fun but regular people have so much difficulty with them. I once snagged a 4 letter .net address that was the last 3 letters of my first name with the first initial of my last name as the last character. I thought I was so clever. I had the shortest email address you could ever imagine and it was basically just my first name and last initial. Amazing! Nobody got it. It was confusing. I got blank stares and…

Very true, I found a similar issue with vanity/hack domains too. Picked up https://jo.hn a couple of years ago and the confusion it causes isn't really worth the cool-factor most of the time!

They tend to really just be suitable as a supplementary domain for short links and the like (youtu.be, goo.gl, etc.)

Re: Franken.domains: Stitched-Together Domains, Because Every .com Is Taken

#43

These are fun but regular people have so much difficulty with them. I once snagged a 4 letter .net address that was the last 3 letters of my first name with the first initial of my last name as the last character. I thought I was so clever. I had the shortest email address you could ever imagine and it was basically just my first name and last initial. Amazing! Nobody got it. It was confusing. I got blank stares and…

Ya, I have an .st domain with is @.st and I've had a few people have a lot of trouble with it. With one, it took about 6 or 7 tries to explain it to him before I just took over and typed it for him. Most people do get it, though, and sometimes think it's neat.

Re: Franken.domains: Stitched-Together Domains, Because Every .com Is Taken

#44

These are fun but regular people have so much difficulty with them. I once snagged a 4 letter .net address that was the last 3 letters of my first name with the first initial of my last name as the last character. I thought I was so clever. I had the shortest email address you could ever imagine and it was basically just my first name and last initial. Amazing! Nobody got it. It was confusing. I got blank stares and…

i have a 3-letter .onl domain that is the first 3 letters of my last name

I have actually needed to use it, because my cell provider (Visible) has absolutely moronic form validation that doesn't recognize a hyphen as a valid character in an email address, even though it very much is. (My main .net domain has a hyphen in it)

Re: Franken.domains: Stitched-Together Domains, Because Every .com Is Taken

#45

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domain_hack

It's always struck me as odd that TLDs are not just, well, freely configurable? Domains have always been subject to so much artificial scarcity for seemingly no reason. Why can't a DNS resolver handle .whatever?

What's odd is there seems to be no viable alternatives to DNS at all. Everybody just standardized on this ancient phone book technology managed by some rent seeking "assigned numbers" organization and now there is no escape from it.

Re: Franken.domains: Stitched-Together Domains, Because Every .com Is Taken

#46
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not sure it's possible because dotCom is owned by verisign and designated to the internet root servers. Your ISP, ISP Peering DNS, and any other DNS service would override any of your DNS zones. It does make me wonder if I hosted my own root servers for a new dotCom tld would I get chased down by the internet police?

No, there's no internet police who would stop you from doing that. However you had better point your .com to Verisign's .com or so many things won't work when connected to your DNS server. Also you will never get IANA to recognise you as the new authority for .com which means people will need to go out of their way to use your root zone instead of the de-facto-standard one published by IANA. It's a bit like signing y…

> It's a shame, because ICANN being under US jurisdiction is effectively an attack against the DNS.

Agreed. At least in 2016 we got the US to give up its veto power to the PTI which has global oversight. Still ofc the ICANN is just another company based in Los Angeles and falls under California and US legal jurisdiction. I would much prefer control be transferred to the UN ITU

Re: Franken.domains: Stitched-Together Domains, Because Every .com Is Taken

#47

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domain_hack

It's always struck me as odd that TLDs are not just, well, freely configurable? Domains have always been subject to so much artificial scarcity for seemingly no reason. Why can't a DNS resolver handle .whatever?

It can. You just have to abandon ICANN's system.

Re: Franken.domains: Stitched-Together Domains, Because Every .com Is Taken

#48
post #42

These are fun but regular people have so much difficulty with them. I once snagged a 4 letter .net address that was the last 3 letters of my first name with the first initial of my last name as the last character. I thought I was so clever. I had the shortest email address you could ever imagine and it was basically just my first name and last initial. Amazing! Nobody got it. It was confusing. I got blank stares and…

Very true, I found a similar issue with vanity/hack domains too. Picked up https://jo.hn a couple of years ago and the confusion it causes isn't really worth the cool-factor most of the time! They tend to really just be suitable as a supplementary domain for short links and the like (youtu.be, goo.gl, etc.)

I have even had people confused at [last name].io even though tech industry folks consider that one really common.

I can see why many companies end up paying lots of money to transition over to .com when they get to a certain size.

Re: Franken.domains: Stitched-Together Domains, Because Every .com Is Taken

#49
post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You could've found an EU person to hold the domains for you btw. Regardless, it's usually politically safest to put your domains under your own country's ccTLD. That way, you're exposed to one fewer country's dumb politics.

> you're exposed to one fewer country's dumb politics. That would be .co.uk, so, jail time for hosting memes.

You could get jail time for hosting memes if you're in the UK no matter what domain you use. However, if you use a .me domain, then it can also be taken down for violating any law of Montenegro.

Re: Franken.domains: Stitched-Together Domains, Because Every .com Is Taken

#50

These are fun but regular people have so much difficulty with them. I once snagged a 4 letter .net address that was the last 3 letters of my first name with the first initial of my last name as the last character. I thought I was so clever. I had the shortest email address you could ever imagine and it was basically just my first name and last initial. Amazing! Nobody got it. It was confusing. I got blank stares and…

Do you get the same confused look when your email is @gmx.de or @free.fr or any other lesser known provider? I suppose you've never had this problem because you aren't using those providers, but many people do.
Post reply on HN